
...

By Kristen Waggoner
CEO and President, ADF
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When the Lee family in Colorado sought a counselor for their 12-year-old daughter, they had a hard time finding one whose approach allowed their daughter to talk through her identity struggles to achieve her goal of growing comfortable with her body.
Turns out, that’s because it’s illegal in Colorado for counselors to talk with minors to help them resolve gender dysphoria and accept their bodies. While Colorado could have passed a law specifically banning harmful conduct like shock therapy, it banned even voluntary conversations between a counselor and client. In so doing, Colorado’s law takes a choice off the table, leaving only one state-approved option: push children toward gender transition.
Colorado’s free speech violation lies at the heart of a case that was argued Tuesday at the U.S. Supreme Court.
Read More on Opinion
My firm, Alliance Defending Freedom, represents Kaley Chiles, a licensed counselor in Colorado. Under state law, Kaley can’t help a girl who voluntarily wants counsel to regain comfort living as a girl.
Therefore, a young client can’t choose her own goals. Before she even sees a counselor, the state has already decided what an “acceptable” outcome looks like. This stops many kids from getting care that they want and need. Research shows around 90 percent of children who experience gender dysphoria before puberty resolve those feelings—either naturally or through counseling—and live at peace with their biological sex.

...
Colorado has identified no study showing that voluntary counseling causes harm, yet it insists it knows best and forbids kids and their parents from having certain conversations. But Colorado allows kids as young as 12 to get counseling on other topics without parental consent, including counseling encouraging children to transition.
Colorado treats one client-selected goal differently and demands a one-size-fits-all approach—silencing all other views. It’s as if state officials can’t fathom that a girl who feels bodily discomfort might want to grow more comfortable with and accept her body. If such children exist (and they do—in spades), Colorado has no place for them, and no counselor can legally serve their needs.
In what world do we tell a child that certain topics are off-limits to talk about—and that it’s okay to want to become the opposite sex but not to stay the sex that you are?
Colorado’s one-way counseling ban pushes children not away from risk, as the state claims, but toward it.
Studies show that encouraging kids to socially transition interrupts their natural tendency to grow out of their dysphoria, putting them on a path toward lifelong medicalization. Colorado is doing exactly what Dr. Hilary Cass warned against in her independent review of gender identity services in the United Kingdom. Cass cautioned that if voluntary discussions are labeled “conversion therapy” and banned, it will harm the young people who need support most.
Indeed, the cost of such verbal coercion falls squarely on kids. Not only does it stop them from achieving their own stated goals; it risks confusing them even further by pushing them toward drastic measures that they neither need nor want. Far too many young people who transitioned, especially girls, say they did not receive adequate psychological evaluation and counseling before starting transitioning.
Setting aside the issue of whether a child can consent to a life-altering transition, the right to make up one's own mind is paramount. Recent events have painfully reminded us that the ability to express an opinion is the essence of a free society. If counselors can’t speak their views and clients can’t receive advice they want, then free speech is truly in retreat.
Young people deserve so much better than state-approved talking points, yet, sadly, 22 other states have joined Colorado’s censorship crusade.
One of them is Michigan, where Dan and Jennifer Mead reside. When the Meads learned that their young daughter was struggling with her gender, like the Lees, they sought professional help. And like the Lees, they ran into a brick wall. Michigan puts the same legal straitjacket on counselors as Colorado. One can imagine the heartbreak Jennifer felt when her daughter approached her, desperate to talk to somebody, but having no viable options. The government stood in their way.
What does the First Amendment require in these situations? Simple. On matters of moral and spiritual significance, clients should be able to seek a counselor of their choice and set their own goals with that counselor.
We are urging the Supreme Court to rule for free speech. A favorable ruling will put kids’ health and well-being first. And it will allow young people to find a listening ear and a tailored counseling approach, one that respects their own stated goals rather than pushing them down the state-mandated path of chemicals, surgeries, and permanent scars.
Kristen Waggoner is CEO, president, and chief counsel of Alliance Defending Freedom. Follow Kristen on X @KristenWaggoner or follow ADF @ADFLegal.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines