Supreme Court

...

Suzanne Blake

By Suzanne Blake

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The U.S. Supreme Court will be hearing a case that could decide how companies are liable for using profits as payback for trademark infringement.

The High Court announced Monday it would be listening to the case between a Virginia real estate developer and another in Georgia regarding a $43 million dispute over the trademark of the "Dewberry" name.

Atlanta-headquartered Dewberry Group appealed a ruling by a lower court in favor of the Virginia-based Dewberry Engineers, and now the Supreme Court will hear the case as early as October.

Read More on U.S.

The Virginia district court originally ruled that Dewberry Group would have to send $43 million of its profits after determining intentional trademark infringement occurred.

Supreme Court

...

The case focuses on the Dewberry name, which was first used by Dewberry Engineers when it began operations in the 1950s. While the organization was initially an engineering company, it added a real estate development department in the southeastern U.S., where Dewberry Group would also conduct business.

Dewberry Group was founded in 1989 by John Dewberry, offering a range of similar services.

The trademark infringement case first came to a head when Dewberry Engineers sued Dewberry Group, then called Dewberry Capital, in 2006 with an early settlement decided the following year.

But after Dewberry Capital turned into Dewberry Group in 2017 and started offering several services through sub-brands like Dewberry Living, Dewberry Engineers again pursued legal action to keep the other organization from getting federal trademark protection.

In 2020, Dewberry Engineers officially sued Dewberry Group again, alleging trademark infringement and violations of the settlement agreement.

"Allowing plaintiffs to bulldoze corporate distinctions in this manner threatens broad, harmful consequences," Dewberry Group wrote when it appealed the case.

Alex Beene, financial literacy instructor at the University of Tennessee at Martin, said while the case concerns a dispute over two smaller real estate groups, there could be widespread implications on trademark cases in general.

"Most trademark cases are fairly straightforward, with an entity either found to be in the clear or guilty of infringement," Beene told Newsweek. "The repercussions of infringement usually center on simply being unable to use in naming or branding surrounding the trademark moving forward, with the financial fallout normally being minimal."

If a decision is reached showing significant financial penalties, however, it could change the ways larger corporations deal with trademark infringement.

Beene said it could even become "a cautionary tale" for entities thinking of using a name or branding in a trademark for their own business.

"If it's a simple cease-and-desist, which is the common tactic for most cases today, it will remain a slap on the wrist for many," Beene said. "However, if there's monetary gain to be made, it opens up a whole new playing field, and not necessarily a good one."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines