
...


By Nick Mordowanec and Barney Henderson
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday upheld a Tennessee law that bars gender-affirming medical care for transgender youth—a major setback for advocates supporting the treatment for the community.
Why It Matters
The 6-3 ruling along ideological lines in U.S. v. Skrmetti effectively protects from legal challenges many efforts by President Donald Trump's Republican administration and state governments to roll back protections for transgender people. The challenge was brought by three transgender adolescents, their families and a Memphis-based medical provider against a Tennessee law banning gender-affirming hormone therapies for transgender people under 18.
Read More
Justice Sotomayor Says Supreme Court Just Countered ‘Decades’ of Precedent4 min read

Gavin Newsom’s Chances of Being 2028 Democratic Nominee Surge—Poll4 min read

Mary Trump Makes ‘Fundamental Danger’ Prediction About What Uncle Will Do4 min read


...
What To Know
Senate Bill 1 (SB1), Tennessee legislation that bans gender-affirming care for transgender youth regardless of parental consent and medical recommendation, was signed into law in March 2023.
In April 2023, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), the ACLU of Tennessee, Lambda Legal and Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP sued the state on behalf of families and transgender youth to block the ban. A district court judge later determined that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on their constitutional claims and issued a preliminary injunction, blocking the law from going into effect.
The district court decision was later appealed to the Sixth Circuit, which reversed the lower court's decision. The plaintiffs filed petitions asking the U.S. Supreme Court to review the reversal. In June 2024, the Supreme Court agreed to take up the petition. Oral arguments were heard on December 4, 2024.
The decision may bolster the legal footing of similar laws in at least 26 other states, many backed by Republican-led legislatures, which have enacted sweeping measures to limit access to puberty blockers, hormone therapy and other medical treatments for minors identifying as transgender.
However, the decision does not affect the 24 states and additional territories that allow the care without restriction—nor the more than a dozen states that have laws to protect access to it.
Writing for the court, Chief Justice John Roberts said that Tennessee's law falls within the bounds of legislative authority and does not discriminate against transgender individuals under federal constitutional standards.
His opinion says in part that this "case carries with it the weight of fierce scientific and policy debates about the safety, efficacy, and propriety of medical treatments in an evolving field. The voices in these debates raise sincere concerns; the implications for all are profound."
Roberts added that the court's role is "only to ensure that" the law "does not violate" the equal protection clause, which he said "it does not."
"Having concluded that it does not, we leave questions regarding its policy to the people, their elected representatives, and the democratic process," he added.
Justice Amy Coney Barrett, in a concurring opinion, wrote that transgender status is not marked by the same sort of "'obvious, immutable, or distinguishing characteristics'" as race or sex.
"In particular, it is not defined by a trait that is 'definitively ascertainable at the moment of birth,'" Barrett wrote. "The plaintiffs here, for instance, began to experience gender dysphoria at varying ages—some from a young age, others not until the onset of puberty. Meanwhile, the plaintiffs acknowledge that some transgender individuals 'detransition' later in life—in other words, they begin to identify again with the gender that corresponds to their biological sex."
Justice Sonia Sotomayor, writing in a dissent joined by the court's other liberal justices, condemned the ruling, saying the majority "abandons transgender children and their families to political whims."
"Thus, the majority subjects a law that plainly discriminates on the basis of sex to mere rational-basis review," Sotomayor wrote. "By retreating from meaningful judicial review exactly where it matters most, the Court abandons transgender children and their families to political whims. In sadness, I dissent."
Cathryn Oakley, senior director of legal policy at the Human Rights Campaign, told Newsweek that the decision conveys that SB1 does not discriminate on the basis of sex but instead said that it is a medical regulation and that it treats people the same way regardless of their sex, meaning that transgender boys are subjected to the same regulations as transgender girls and therefore they are not being discriminated on the basis of their sex.
Oakley believes it's "a very incorrect analysis of what sex-based discrimination looks like."
"This is a really disappointing and disheartening decision," Oakley said. "It's truly devastating for the many transgender youths who are living not only in in Tennessee but in states like Tennessee, which have passed bans on their ability to access medical care.
"This medical care is best practice, medically necessary health care that is supported by the entire American mainstream medical and mental health establishment. These young folks, they deserve the ability to access that medical care and to be able to thrive and be well. I very strongly disagree with the Supreme Court that this was not discrimination."
Every major medical association supports health care for transgender people and youth, including the American Medical Association, American Academy of Pediatrics, American Association of Clinical Endocrinology, American Psychological Association, Texas Medical Association and World Health Organization.
Oakley, however, is "heartened" by the fact that the Supreme Court only was talking about SB1 but anticipates continued challenges to these health care bans that will likely require other legal approaches in other parts of the nation.
The Campaign for Southern Equality (CSE) manages the national Trans Youth Emergency Project (TYEP) that aids families of transgender youth impacted by laws that prohibit or restrict access to transition-related care for minors. CSE has distributed more than $600,000 in direct emergency grants to more than 1,200 families of transgender youth, in close partnership with state organizations in every state with a ban, dating to the project launch in March 2023.
TYEP says that since 2021, 27 states across the country, concentrated in the South and Midwest, have passed legislation restricting or banning access to gender-affirming health care for transgender youth. Prior to 2020, no state had advanced a law like the one in Tennessee.
In April, the United Kingdom in a landmark ruling defined a woman under the country's equality law based on biological sex, meaning that a transgender person with a certificate that recognizes them as female should not be considered a woman for equality purposes.
The decision led to protests and condemnation from various transgender advocacy groups.
Some European countries, including Belgium, Ireland and Spain, allow for self-identification, where individuals can more easily change their gender marker on official documents.
What People Are Saying
GLAAD President and CEO Sarah Kate Ellis, in a statement: "The Supreme Court took the place of parents and doctors and stripped away their ability to make private, lifesaving decisions for their children. This ruling is a chilling step toward unchecked government overreach, intruding on the most personal aspects of our private lives. All families are now less safe and left vulnerable to politicians and a Court that has abandoned its duty to protect personal liberties. Every family deserves the freedom to make the medical decisions that help their children live, thrive, and be well."
Lucas Cameron-Vaughn, senior staff attorney at the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Tennessee, in a statement: "Today the Supreme Court told Tennessee transgender youth and their families that they cannot access healthcare that is vitally important for a successful life. This ruling creates a class of people who politicians believe deserve healthcare, and a class of people who do not. We will continue to stand with transgender people in Tennessee and are committed to realizing a world where all people belong, are valued, and can access the necessary healthcare they need."
Edmund LaCour, solicitor general of Alabama, in a statement: "The Supreme Court today recognized that Tennessee's law placing age limits on sex-change treatments is not subject to heightened judicial review. The Biden Administration's contrary position depended on the obvious fallacy that providing testosterone to treat a boy's endocrine disorder is the 'same treatment' as using the drug to disrupt the normal physical development of an adolescent girl suffering from psychological distress. The Supreme Court recognized that these are different medical treatments."
Allison Scott of the Campaign for Southern Equality, in a statement: "I am heartbroken today. No one should be forced to leave their home state to access healthcare – and it is outrageous to see the U.S. Supreme Court uphold these bans and continue to allow the government to interfere with the personal medical decisions of families. The Court's ruling can't change what we know in our bones: our identities, our families, and our lives are strong, worthy, and not up for debate by extremists.
What Happens Next
The ruling marks one of the most consequential developments in the growing legal clash over how far states can go in regulating care for transgender youth, and how far courts are willing to allow them to go.
Updated 6/18/25, 1:38 p.m. ET: This story was updated with additional information and comment from Cathryn Oakley.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines