
...

By Peter Aitken
Politics Weekend Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito sat out another Supreme Court decision, most recently issued on Friday in Chevron USA Inc. V Plaquemines Parish, Louisiana.
The court, in an 8-0 decision, decided to vacate and remand the case, which sought to hold oil and gas companies liable for damage to the Louisiana coast. Ultimately, the case focused not on the matter of responsibility but whether there was a right to move the case from a state to federal court.
Newsweek reached out to the Supreme Court via a submission form on Friday for comment.
Read More on U.S.
Why It Matters
The Supreme Court has faced increasing scrutiny over the past few years as several ethics controversies mounted around some of the justices, particularly over undisclosed gifts, travel, and financial conflicts. The justices largely police themselves, fueling criticism that recusals are inconsistent and insufficiently transparent.
Justices, such as Clarence Thomas, have faced repeated calls to step aside from politically sensitive cases, including election-related disputes and cases involving major donors or industries. Even after adopting an ethics code, which some critics alleged lacked enforcement mechanisms, bipartisan concerns about the justices.
Alito has faced particular scrutiny during participation in cases related to presidential immunity and the January 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol.
Reports emerged of flags associated with conservative movements seen outside residences owned by Alito following the 2020 election. This has led to calls from some members of Congress and ethics watchdog groups for Alito to recuse himself from cases related to these topics. Alito did not recuse himself in those cases.

...
What To Know
Alito did not participate in the decision, having recused himself in January after disclosing a financial interest in ConocoPhillips, the parent company of Burlington Resources, which was a party to the case in the lower court.
The conservative justice initially participated when the High Court agreed over the summer to hear the dispute, but later filings prompted his withdrawal, according to a letter from Supreme Court clerk Scott Harris.
This is just one of now dozens of cases from which Alito has recused himself for conflicts of interest due to his or his family's stock portfolio: Bloomberg in 2024 reported that Alito or his wife owns stock in companies such as Raytheon Co., ConocoPhillips, and a subsidiary of Johnson & Johnson, to name a few of the two-dozen companies comprising his investments.
As such, Alito had recused himself from 64 cases between 2021 and 2024 alone due to his ownership of shares in those companies, far more than other justices did, according to the outlet.
The justices backed an opinion delivered by Thomas, with Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson filing a concurring opinion in the judgment. The court disagreed with Louisiana's argument and held that Chevron had satisfied the requirements to remove the case to a different court.
Issues of Recusal
A significant development since the adoption of the ethics code has been the emergence of a clear divide between the court's liberal and conservative justices regarding the disclosure of recusal reasons. The three liberal justices—Jackson, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan—have consistently provided explanations for their recusals, citing specific provisions of the Code of Conduct. In contrast, the six conservative justices have generally not offered such explanations when recusing themselves from cases.
The code itself calls for justices to recuse when they have financial, professional or personal conflicts. It also includes a "presumption of impartiality" and states that the "rule of necessity may override the rule of disqualification." These provisions have been criticized by some as potentially weakening the effectiveness of the recusal process.
Thomas has been a central focus of calls for recusal and ethics, with repeated calls for him to step aside from cases linked to the 2020 election and Donald Trump due to his wife, Ginni Thomas’s, political activism and his own undisclosed luxury travel funded by billionaire donors.
Thomas has declined to recuse himself from those matters, even under intensified pressure from lawmakers and advocacy groups who argue that his participation undermines public confidence in the Court’s impartiality.
Update 4/17/26, 12:44 p.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines