
By Lauren Giella
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Star Valley Health filed a complaint against Change Healthcare over an alleged breach of contract.
Wyoming’s North Lincoln County Hospital District, doing business as Star Valley Health, filed suit against the payment system Change Healthcare in the U.S. District Court for the District of Wyoming on September 30.
Why It Matters
Star Valley Health used Change Healthcare to manage its billing and accounts and submit claims to payers. According to the court filing, Change Healthcare was responsible for ensuring claims were timely submitted to insurance, but “repeatedly failed to timely submit claims to payers in line with its obligations” outlined in its contract.
Read More on Business
In the complaint, Star Valley Health alleges that Change Healthcare “routinely” breached its contractual obligations, resulting in multiple, sustained failures to timely file over $3.7 million in claims with insurance payers. As a result, Star Valley Health claims it has and will likely continue to sustain damages exceeding $2.5 million.
What to Know
The two parties entered into a contract in November 2022. Star Valley Health is based in Afton, Wyoming, and serves 13 communities with a population of 11,000 to 15,000, which varies seasonally. Change Healthcare is a Delaware-based company with its headquarters in Nashville, Tennessee. In 2022, the company was acquired by UnitedHealth Group’s Optum Insight unit in a $13 billion deal.
In July 2023, Change Healthcare switched to Epic billing software. At this time, the court filing states that Change Healthcare was experiencing staffing issues and was unable to adequately prepare for the implementation of the Epic billing software, causing “a significant backlog in claims processing.”
Change Healthcare was unable to file and facilitate the collection of payment for Star Valley Health’s claims filing using the Epic software, resulting in at least $2 million in losses, according to the court filing.
Star Valley Health said that it was not at fault for the failures to file, noting that it performed its contractual duty by paying Change Healthcare’s invoices each month until it discovered the breach.
Star Valley Health also claims it made repeated efforts to ensure that insurance claims were filed in a timely manner, including holding regular calls and weekly meetings with Change Healthcare during which the timely filing of claims was discussed.
“[Change Healthcare] was well-aware of the timely filing issue. On information and belief, a [Change Healthcare] employee alerted upper-level management of the backlog of claims that had not been filed, yet [Change Healthcare] failed to provide additional resources to handle [Star Valley Health’s] claims,” the claim states. “[Change Healthcare’s] failure to remedy its staffing issues contributed to its untimely filing of claims and caused [Star Valley Health] damages.”
The two parties terminated their contract in June 2024, but Change Healthcare continued to perform services for Star Valley Health. The complaint claims Change Health still failed to file on time. On October 31, 2024, Star Valley Health sent Change Healthcare a demand for payment due to the failure to file $3.7 million in claims with insurance payers promptly.
What Happens Next
In the filing, Star Valley Health demands a trial by jury "on all issues so triable."
In a statement to Newsweek, Change Healthcare said, "The company disagrees with Star Valley’s assertions and will vigorously defend itself."
UPDATE 10/30/2025 at 9:14 a.m.: The headline was updated to include the monetary amount for the settlement.
Have an announcement or news to share? Contact the Newsweek Health Care team at health.care@newsweek.com.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines