
0.cached.png
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The U.S. headquarters of Haier Inc. in midtown Manhattan is a little bit unusual. For one thing, it's hard to get to the receptionist's desk: there are a half dozen black, three-foot-high compact refrigerators blocking the way. Each appliance has a piece of paper taped to the door: as is, $150.00, reads one slip. If you're looking for a small refrigerator, Haier America will sell you one-- on the spot. Behind the receptionist there is a showroom chock-full of Haier products--food freezers, home wine coolers, clothes washers, air conditioners and the world's first "combination compact refrigerator and desk"--a new product conceived to appeal to dormitory-confined U.S. students.
Haier, the leading appliance maker in China, is well known in its home market for its innovative goods. The company sells a clothes washer with an attachment for kneading noodle dough, a clothes washer that will clean potatoes (popular with farmers) and a "prevent near-sightedness TV," designed for children of working parents. It cuts off when anyone gets within two feet of the unit. Laugh, but such products have helped boost Haier's sales to more than $5 billion annually and placed it among the world leaders in appliance sales (No. 6). Twenty years ago, the company didn't even exist. CEO Zhang Ruimin was asked to rescue a faltering refrigerator plant in the eastern port city of Qingdao. He did. Today, Haier has 30,000 employees (more than one tenth in research and development), 13 foreign factories (including a new one in South Carolina, managed by Americans) and a surging export business. The company just bought a historic bank building in New York City, complete with Corinthian columns, that will serve as Haier's new U.S. headquarters.
The China boom is by now a well-documented phenomenon. Who hasn't heard of the Middle Kingdom's astounding economic growth (8 percent annually), it's mesmerizing consumer market (1.2 billion people), the investment ardor of foreign suitors ($40 billion in foreign direct investment last year alone)? China is an economic juggernaut. According to Nicholas Lardy of the Brookings Institution, a Washington, D.C.-based think tank, "No country has expanded its foreign trade as fast as China over the last 20 years. Japan doubled its foreign trade over a 20-year period; China's foreign trade as quintupled. They've become the pre-eminent producer of labor-intensive manufacturing goods in the world."
Read More on News
But there's been something missing from the dazzling China growth story--namely, the Chinese multinational. No major Chinese companies have yet established themselves, or their brands, on the global stage. But as Haier shows, that is starting to change. After 100 years of poverty and chaos, of being overshadowed by foreign countries and multinationals, Chinese industrial companies are starting to make a mark on the world.
To be sure, there are still plenty of Chinese firms brazenly copying foreign products and dumping them (with phony brand names, like Sone) in Asian countries. But a new generation of large and credible firms has emerged in China in the electronics, appliance and even high-tech sectors. Some have reached critical mass on the mainland and are now seeking new outlets for their production--through exports and by building Chinese factories abroad, chiefly in Southeast Asia. One example: China's investment in Malaysia soared from $8 million in 2000 to $766 million in the first half of this year.
That is a big change--China has long had more of a trading than an overseas-investment mentality--and Southeast Asian leaders are scrambling to cope with the elephant in their midst. While foreign investment is rising again, ASEAN economies are being buffeted not just by rising Chinese imports, but by the loss of manufacturing capacity to China. Taiwan, now in recession and facing record unemployment, is watching its precious information-technology sector gradually pack up and move to China. Compal, the island's second largest laptop manufacturer, recently announced that it was moving its production to China, following on the heels of desertions by makers of scanners and computer disk drives. Both Intel and Dell Computer have recently moved key operations from Taiwan to Hong Kong. Last month Intel CEO Craig Barrett urged Taiwanese companies to move up the high-tech ladder, because there is no stopping the migration of lower-cost manufacturing to its cross-straight rival.
Meantime, a flood of cheap Chinese imports--motorcycles and clothes, for example--is already strangling domestic manufacturing in Vietnam and Indonesia. "The pressure China is putting on the regional economy is real and enormous," says Le Van San of the Institute of World Economy, a Hanoi-based think tank. "After China joins the World Trade Organization, that pressure will increase."
Singapore is also feeling the heat. Last week Singapore Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong outlined a comprehensive plan for a "new Singapore" that would lessen dependency on electronics production, which has been damaged by Chinese competition. Goh said Singapore must become more entrepreneurial and seek more petrochemical, pharmaceutical and biotechnology businesses. "Our biggest challenge," he said, "is to secure a niche for ourselves as China swamps the world with her high-quality but cheaper products. China's economy is potentially 10 times the size of Japan's."
For all China's export prowess, it will be years before Chinese firms achieve the managerial and operational expertise of Western and Japanese multinationals. For one thing, many of its best companies are still at least partially state-owned. What's more, China has a shortage of managerial talent and little notion of marketing and brand-building. Its companies are also handicapped by the country's long tradition of central planning, a fragmented political system, inefficient use of capital and antiquated distribution system, which makes building national companies a challenge.
But the Chinese are coming. One reason is that Beijing is obsessed with building a strong domestic IT sector--and insists that foreign firms share technology with their mainland partners. That tough philosophy is paying dividends. Chinese firms are learning how to make some fairly sophisticated products, usually via joint ventures with top Western and Japanese manufacturers. For example, the Chinese firm Capitel Group has a mobile-phone production alliance with Nokia China. But it's also branched out on its own, designing and making middle-market wireless phones. "Capitel is a partner but also a competitor," says Chijin Liu, a vice president of Nokia China. "We extend our help so that they can learn how to build and promote a local brand. This is inevitable." China's latest five-year plan is a chipmaking call to arms. Beijing aims to build 25 silicon-wafer factories before 2005. "China's chip industry will make remarkable progress," says Steve Lyons, a spokesman for Motorola.
China is already the world's third largest producer of electronics, and becoming a player in the global appliance market. Xiamen Republic Electronic Co. makes DVD players that are now sold in United States. And with its huge production capacity--growing by about 20 percent a year--the Chinese are relentlessly driving down global prices. "We will see the emergence of globally competitive Chinese firms," says the Brookings Institution's Lardy. He cautions that in their zest for size, global status and broad product lines, the Chinese are paying too little attention to profitability. That's the formula that got Korea's once vaunted chaebol into trouble following the Asian financial crisis.
Twenty years ago, U.S., European and Japanese companies started moving into China to supply the local market with household goods. Now those same companies are getting whipped by Chinese competitors. Ming-Jer Chen, a business professor and Chinese management expert at the University of Virginia, notes that any company that can become a market leader in China has achieved the economies of scale necessary to succeed internationally. Over the past six years, the market share of foreign TV makers in China has dropped from 70 percent to less than 20 percent. Matsushita opened the first microwave-oven plant in China in 1995. Two years later the Chinese company Galanz started making microwaves and selling them for half Matsushita's price. Matsushita is now phasing out microwave production in Japan--and exporting the products from China. "They're very strong competitors," says Yukio Shotoku, overseas managing director for Matsushita. "It's amazing because they've achieved such excellence in three years."
Chinese companies now make more than 43 million TVs yearly. Konka, one of China's largest TV makers, sells its branded TVs in the United States, and has set up factories in Mexico to service the American market. TCL, another major TV maker, exported 11 million units from its Chinese factories last year. It has more Southeast Asian factories than any other Chinese company. "We fell behind the U.S. in science and technology for 50 years," says Li Hailing, a 22-year-old manager at TCL's mammoth plant in Huizhou, China. "It's hard to start from zero, but we've done it."
High technology remains the ace in the hole for foreign companies. But even there the Chinese are gaining ground. In the first half of the 1990s, the U.S. and European companies Lucent, Alcatel and Siemens, in combination with Chinese partners, dominated the telephone-switch market in China. That business is now led by the Chinese firms Huawei, Datang and ZTE, none of which even existed before 1985. Huawei's share of the China switch market doubled last year (to 35 percent), and the Shenzhen-based company is now exporting functional but low-priced phone equipment to developing countries (mainly in Southeast Asia). It just invested half a billion dollars in a Mexican production facility. Dong Tao, an economist with Credit Suisse First Boston in Hong Kong, has predicted that within 10 years China will become the world's leading producer of information-technology equipment--thanks largely to the migration of Taiwanese and Western technology plants to the mainland.
Like many big Chinese companies, TCL is expanding rapidly in Asia. Two years ago the company smelled an opportunity in Vietnam, which has 80 million people but a small TV market. Manager Terry Yi was dispatched to Ho Chi Minh City to survey the country. What Yi found, he says, was that Vietnam's TV-market leaders (Sony and Samsung) were gouging consumers--charging $700 for the same units that they were selling for $400 in China. High prices, not weak buying power, were holding back TV sales.
Enter the dragon. Yi figured that TCL could make and sell TVs in Vietnam for much less than the Japanese and Korean competition, and still make a decent profit. Perhaps more important, TCL's timing was good: stung by a falloff in foreign investment, Hanoi was ready to loosen trade restrictions. Yi persuaded top management to invest $6 million in a Vietnamese plant--and he smartly made sure that the operation was 100 percent owned by the Chinese; there would be no inefficient joint-venture arrangements with a local company.
The TCL factory, 40 kilometers east of Ho Chi Minh City, was and up and running within a year. It now sells 13 color-TV models at prices that, on average, are one quarter less than Sony and Samsung. TCL already has a 10 percent market share (third in the market), and it's growing. The factory, which also makes DVD players, will double its TV production this year. Yi boasts that his company pays the plant's workers $70 a month, considerably more than Vietnam's minimum monthly wage of $42.
Yi's biggest challenge has been to overcome the rotten reputation that Chinese products have in Vietnam. Until recently, China's emphasis was on exports, not foreign investment. But Yi is cleverly gearing up to exploit new trade rules coming into effect from the ASEAN Free Trade Agreement, or AFTA. Under AFTA, preferential tax treatment will be given by ASEAN's 10 member countries to exports from other nations in the trade group. Right now, Indonesia slaps a 50 percent tariff on Chinese TV imports. But the levy would be only 30 percent if the units came from Vietnam. So TCL wants to build its Vietnamese plant into an export base--and not just for TVs. Yi is already planning a second Vietnamese factory that will make desktop PCs, refrigerators and telephones.
The new AFTA rules, in addition to China's coming WTO membership, could spell trouble for basic manufacturers in the region. China's textile, garment and shoe manufacturers, the world's largest, are breathing down the necks of Indonesian producers, who worry that they could lose their lucrative export sales to the United States and Europe. Textiles, garments and shoes--Indonesia's largest nonenergy exports--accounted for $8 billion in foreign-exchange earnings last year. "China is killing our export markets," says Sunyoto Tanudjaya, CEO of Great River International, one of Indonesia's biggest garment manufacturers. "Their plants have lower costs and are more efficient."
To compete, Tanudjaya has cut his Great River work force by a quarter and boosted productivity. So far, Chinese clothes imports have not made strong inroads into Indonesian stores, but if the rupiah continues to strengthen against the dollar, as it has since Megawati Sukarnoputri became president last month, Indonesian manufacturers could begin losing sales. Indonesia's poor political and security climate is another problem. "Slowly, we are losing out to China," laments industrialist Sofyan Wanandi. "If we don't start performing better, it's bye-bye."
Not long ago, U.S. automobile and electronic manufacturers were broadsided by a bold bunch of corporate newcomers from Japan. Thus was born the term Japan Inc. Are we starting to see the emergence of China Inc.? Yes, but Chinese companies still have a long way to go. While many Chinese products could pass for leading international brands, others are clearly not up to current standards in industrial design or quality. Capitel's simple-looking mobile phones will not be confused with more sophisticated devices from Nokia, Motorola and Ericsson. Some Chinese TVs seem to have suspect picture quality. What's more, many Chinese companies seem to want to make nearly everything but the kitchen sink--and that is a quick way to lose money. Haier has 69 different product lines. Nearly every large manufacturer in China, including TCL and Haier, wants to make mobile phones.
More important, there are issues of corporate governance. Chinese companies have absurdly complicated ownership structures. Zhang describes Haier as a "collective" rather than state-owned. In fact, the company has some units that are publicly owned, others that are government owned, still others that are controlled by upper management. "That's a big issue," says Chen of the University of Virginia. "It has implications for management incentives, decision making and eventually for investors, especially in a global context. Very often you don't know who management reports to."
Before Chinese companies break into the Fortune 500, there must be lots more industry consolidation in China. Local and provincial governments own many firms, and use them, in many cases, as employment centers. They tend to resist mergers or selloffs to similar companies. There are scores of TV manufacturers in China. There used to be two dozen or so carmakers, before Beijing stepped in and streamlined the domestic industry.
But if those issues get solved, watch out. China has a good education system, which turns out 140,000 engineers a year. They are in the vanguard of China's robust high-tech sector. And while top managerial talent is lacking, the Chinese are tackling that problem with their usual ardor. In less than a decade more than 60 MBA programs have popped up in the country. And Chinese companies are slowly becoming quasi-private. TCL was founded in 1982, but it didn't become a top-tier company until the mid-1990s, when the Huizhou City Council sold management 42 percent of the company. That unleashed the entrepreneurship that comes naturally to Chinese people, but which Chen says "has been repressed for a long time by the Chinese system."
Perhaps not for much longer. The Chinese take pride in their exports, says economist Andy Xie at Morgan Stanley Hong Kong, and pride in their new generation of companies. "We have the mission to make an outstanding company for the sake of China's greatness," says TCL general manager Felipe Suen. There is a saying in China that "once you have three knives, you can survive anywhere." The Chinese are sharpening their edges.
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines