10

Loading video...

Madison Williams

By Madison Williams

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Kansas City Chiefs coach Andy Reid seems to keep his trust in kicker Harrison Butker when asked about his ongoing struggles.

But the moves the organization makes don't always align with them having confidence in their veteran kicker. Tuesday's signing of another veteran, Matt Prater, adds more intrigue.

For instance, after Butker missed two field goal attempts in the Oct. 25 game versus the Seattle Seahawks to bring his total to five missed field goals at the time, the Chiefs signed controversial kicker Justin Tucker to their practice squad.

Read More on NFL

The move got lots of backlash because, in a Baltimore Banner report from January 2025, 16 women alleged that Tucker engaged in sexual misconduct during and after massage sessions with them. The Baltimore Ravens released Tucker ahead of last season and he hasn't competed for a team since.

Tucker hasn't played for the Chiefs and the team has kept Butker in the starting role. He has missed two more field goals since the team signed Tucker, bringing his season total to seven. That is a career high for him in a single season.

Sunday against the Atlanta Falcons, Butker made all five extra-point attempts and didn't attempt any field goals. Despite that performance, the Chiefs worked out Prater, 42, on Tuesday, NFL Network's Mike Garafolo reported.

Kansas City Chiefs, Harrison Butker

...

Although no one in the organization has said anything, this move alone shows that the Chiefs are losing confidence in Butker. Why else would they be working out an additional kicker with Tucker already on the practice squad?

Prater has been in the NFL since 2007. He has made 83.8% of field goals in his long career. Prater spent last season with the Buffalo Bills, but hasn't competed this season. He made 18-of-20 field goal attempts in 2025, which is already better than what Butker has done this season.

The Chiefs will likely wait to see how Butker performs on Sunday versus the Arizona Cardinals before making a decision about him moving forward. Kansas City then has a big matchup against the Bills on Thanksgiving Day, and they don't want to lose because of missed field goals or extra points. If Butker can't be reliable until the end of the season for the Chiefs, then it's smart to look for an alternative.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines