San Francisco Giants DH Rafael Devers.

...

Jon Vankin

By Jon Vankin

Contributing Sports Writer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


In one of the most stunning MLB trades not only of this season but of any recent year, the Boston Red Sox on June 15 traded their four-time All-Star, nine-year veteran slugger Rafael Devers — who also just happened to be the highest-paid player in franchise history with a $313.5 million, 10 year contract — to the San Francisco Giants.

The trade sent shockwaves through the baseball world, with officials from competing teams asking if the trade reports were real. That's how unbelievable it sounded, that the Red Sox would trade the face of their franchise — especially considering that the return included no real impact players.

San Francisco Giants DH Rafael Devers.

...

Read More on MLB

Fans were outraged by the deal, with many accusing the Red Sox of making the trade only because they wanted to save the money owed on Devers' contract.

Now, more than two months and 60 games later, Devers' performance in San Francisco as well as, even more importantly, the won-loss records of the two teams appears to vindicate Red Sox chief of baseball operations Craig Breslow's decision to ship Devers out of town.

Devers had been a contentious figure in the Boston clubhouse all season. In spring training he refused to switch positions from third base to designated hitter, after the Red Sox signed free agent Gold Glove third baseman Alex Bregman.

More MLB: Insider Reveals Red Sox's Reasons For Dumping Rafael Devers in Devastating Trade

Devers eventually relented, but clearly was not happy, feeling "lied to and betrayed" by the team, according to sources close to him who spoke to ESPN.com.

Then in May, after a season-ending injury to first-baseman Triston Casas, Devers refused to try his hand at first, even when team owner John Henry made a special trip to Kansas City, where the Red Sox were playing on the road, to make a rare personal appeal to Devers, who rebuffed him.

That appeared to spell the end for Devers with the Red Sox, the team that signed him at the age of 16 in the Dominican Republic, with a $1.5 million bonus.

But does Devers now, 12 years later, carry a "curse" along with him, as sports data journalist Neil Paine wrote on Monday?

Before the trade, the Red Sox held a record of 37-36, a winning percentage of .506. Since jettisoning Devers, Boston's record is 36-24 a .600 winning percentage — the third-best in MLB over that time span.

More MLB: New Details Revealed on Red Sox's Effort to Communicate With Rafael Devers

The Giants? They were 41-31, .569, before acquiring Devers. Since the 28-year-old joined the Bay Area team? They've gone 23-37, a .383 percentage — second worst in the game.

Combining the records of the Giants and Red Sox, teams with Devers on the roster have compiled a record of 60-73, a .451 winning percentage, making that hypothetical team the fifth-worst in MLB.

"Since getting moved out west, Devers has struggled to replicate his success with the Red Sox. In 60 games with San Francisco, Devers is slashing just .226/.335/.407 with 10 homers," noted BoSox Injection writer Eric Cole on Wednesday. "While the power and ability to draw walks has remained, that batting average is ugly no matter how you look at it."

Devers' slash line (that is, batting average/on base percentage/slugging percentage) with the Red Sox was .272/.401/.504, an OPS of .905. But with the Giants, Devers' OPS has dropped 163 points to .742.

In 334 plate appearances with the Red Sox, Devers' offensive wins above replacement number was a healthy 2.3. In 260 plate appearances with San Francisco, Devers' oWAR is a barely passable 0.6.

More MLB: Ex-Red Sox Exec Rips Team Over Rafael Devers Debacle 'Malpractice'

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines