Aaron Judge #99 of Team United States reacts after the last out of the eighth inning was recorded by Team Venezuela at loanDepot park on March 17, 2026 in Miami, Florida. (Photo by Megan Briggs/Getty Images)

...

Tyler Erzberger

By Tyler Erzberger

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Three years ago, the United States of America lost to Japan in the World Baseball Classic finals in a cinematic masterpiece.

Both teams were revved up, and in the closing at-bat, Shohei Ohtani struck out Mike Trout to win the crown for Samurai Japan in a beautifully played game.

It was more lethargic in the sequel defeat to Venezuela on Tuesday.

Read More on MLB

The Americans walked into the venue wearing the jerseys of the men's team that recently won the gold medal in hockey at the Winter Olympic Games, but that is as far as the comparisons can go.

While the men's hockey team gave up their bodies for an inch of an advantage against a more talented Canadian side, the USA baseball "superteam" seemed nonplussed throughout the entire game aside from one flash of Bryce Harper heroics.

The hitting was abominable, as players who have won MVPs were swinging wildly in counts with 92 mph fastballs zipping by them. Any time a player would get lucky to get on base, the hitter behind them would softly ground out or pop up with a semi-confused look on their face.

All the while, manager Mark DeRosa would be lurched over in the dugout, wondering why his Ferrari broke down before it got out of the parking garage.

More news: Tarik Skubal Branded ‘Traitor’ by Furious Fans for Leaving Team USA in WBC

PHOENIX, ARIZONA - MARCH 02: Manager Mark DeRosa #9 of Team USA watches batting practice during a workout at Papago Park Sports Complex on March 02, 2026 in Phoenix, Arizona. (Photo by Chris Coduto/Getty Images)

...

More news: Mark DeRosa, Team USA Lineup vs Venezuela Sparks Outrage Ahead of WBC Final

So, as the Americans went down disappointingly with the Miami crowd cheering on the Venezuelans, who was the main problem?

Is it on DeRosa, who was seemingly out of his depth from player management to outright understanding the rules of the tournament?

After being one of the best hitters of the entire tournament for Team USA and one of the lone players to show emotion on the basepads, DeRosa benched Gunnar Henderson in favor of the veteran Alex Bregman in the final.

What about Tarik Skubal, one of the best pitchers in the world, who joined Team USA for the semifinals and finals but didn't pitch after pulling himself from the team after three innings of work against Great Britain?

Skubal threw over 60 pitches a few days ago for the Detroit Tigers at spring training. Couldn't he have done that for the team when they needed him the most in one of the knockout games?

Or is the main culprit Aaron Judge, the best hitter of his generation, who, once again, in a do-or-die championship game, didn't show up? He struck out three times and didn't get on base in any of his four attempts.

Each time Judge went up to the plate, the silent American fans leaned forward in their seats, hoping for him to ignite them. Instead, it was much maligned Harper who got the fans out of their seats with a two-run homer in the bottom of the eighth to tie the game momentarily. Judge came up after him with "U-S-A!" chants ringing across the ballpark, and he watched a third strike come across the plate.

There's no player or coach to blame for the USA's loss. It was a combination of every little bad quote, players deciding to leave the team, and lackluster hitting that snowballed into something bigger than the actual play on the field.

At the helm, though, DeRosa will be the one who gets the brunt of the blame. It's what happens when you're the leader of a team that was supposed to be superheroes but looked more like side characters throughout the tournament, even when they were winning.

For Judge, Bregman, Cal Raleigh, and other players who failed to live up to the moment, they will have a chance at redemption in only a little over a week as the MLB season begins. If Judge can lead the New York Yankees to a World Series championship, the WBC nightmare climax will be nothing more than a bad memory for a majority of fans in the United States.

But for DeRosa, there isn't and shouldn't be a chance for redemption. When Team USA makes its way to Los Angeles in two years to play at the Summer Olympic Games, someone else should be holding the clipboard as manager.

Maybe they'll know the tiebreaker rules.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines