
...

By Tom Roddy
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
John Barnes is reminiscing about the famous battles between England and Scotland during his playing days. Three of his 79 caps between 1983 and 1995 came against the "Auld Enemy," but he was a glued spectator for many more. One aspect, in particular, stands out.
"I will always remember how Scotland was probably louder than England, even when we played at Wembley," Barnes tells Newsweek. "The Scottish crowd, generally speaking, has been a little more passionate than the English crowd wherever it was."
Images of tartan-clad away fans invading the hallowed turf of the old Wembley Stadium back in 1977 spring to Barnes's mind. The raw emotion of the crowd back then was mirrored on the pitch in the players' desire for victory.
Read More on Sports
"I just remember them being very frenetic matches," the 53-year-old, who scored 11 times for England, says. "That's to do with you playing against your team-mates, whereas now they're not playing against guys from their clubs, so I don't suppose it has that dynamic anymore."
In 1985, Jock Stein's Scotland team that beat Bobby Robson's England 1-0 in front of 66,489 people at Hampden Park in Glasgow had seven players that were signed to clubs below the border. "You don't have the [Kenny] Dalglishes and the [Graeme] Sounesses anymore [Barnes's Scottish team-mates at Liverpool], you don't have the players who played with each other in the same clubs or against each other in the same leagues. That has disappeared but, in terms of rivalry from a fans' perspective, it's exactly the same."
A match of this magnitude is required at the moment to inspire the masses who continue to flock to Wembley, despite England crashing out of Euro 2016 to Iceland with a whimper. Gareth Southgate, the interim England manager, leads the country into tonight's 2018 World Cup qualifier against Gordon Strachan's Scotland at the top of group F. Southgate, the former under-21s manager, was promoted to the position when Sam Allardyce was dismissed by the FA after just one match in charge, due to being caught in a newspaper sting offering advice on how to "get round" FA rules.
Barring disaster tonight, Southgate looks set to be instated full-time, but Barnes believes a former England manager deserves another shot at the job.
"I think it would be a good appointment, but my personal favorite is Glenn Hoddle," Barnes says. "I think Glenn Hoddle would be a fantastic manager because this England team needs direction, it needs coaching, it needs somebody that is really going to take the bull by the horns and not just be a friend to the players.
"This is a group of young players that needs direction from a coach who is very tactically astute, who is very strong and isn't afraid to make hard decisions, shout, tell them off and be very critical; this is what you need when you are young."
Like many pundits and spectators, Barnes believes the pool in which Southgate has to pick from has a chance for a bright future—but it lacks a vital component.
"What I've said for the last two years is that they've got great potential," the former Liverpool forward says. "But that potential hasn't been realized and we can't get carried and mistake potential for current ability. Because they have great potential we assume they are the finished article and we should win the World Cup and we should do well at the Euros because we look at the players we've got."
Barnes splits international squads into three categories. "The majority of international players," he says, "should have good experience aged between 23 and 30, then you have some over 30 and some under 23; we've got loads under 23, a few over 30 and haven't got that middle band of top players who have been regular names on the team sheet.
"If you look at the Gary Cahills and Chris Smallings, who are between 23 and 30, they weren't the main players like [John] Terry and [Rio] Ferdinand that we had for many, many years. They've been around for a long time but haven't been the main players for England.
"We have got young players like John Stones and Raheem Sterling [aged 22 and 21], and then we have Wayne Rooney and a few over 30. We have missed a generation and that's where your quality should come from."
Times have changed since Barnes wore the Three Lions on his chest. Wales, Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland joined England in France this summer, while Scotland failed to qualify for the European Championships. But Barnes still believes this fixture remains the biggest derby for Southgate's side.
"Scotland was England's greatest rival, historically," he says. "From the point of view of quality, they always were the top two teams.
"That has changed now with the emergence of Wales and Republic of Ireland, and maybe Northern Ireland, but, in terms of the history of the two countries and the passion that both fans have for football, this is still top."
Former England footballer John Barnes was speaking on behalf of Bonuscodebets.co.uk, a website that helps punters build their betting bankroll by searching out the finest bookmaker bonus offers.
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines