0.cached.png

0.cached.png

Marc Gellman

By Marc Gellman

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Normally, I am not the least bit defensive about my remarks in this column. I have always believed the words of that great existential philosopher Popeye: "I am what I am and that's all what I am." However, this week I am feeling a little shaky because my remarks may well be misconstrued by some as anti-animal or, more specifically, anti-penguin. So let me say defensively at the outset that I love animals, and I particularly love goofy animals like penguins, platypuses, ostriches, giraffes, sloths, armadillos and kangaroos who seem to have been designed by drunken angels on the day God was off making other worlds. Yes, I love all animals. My grandfather, Leo Gellman, was a zookeeper at the Milwaukee Zoo. My wife, Betty, and I raise guide dogs for the blind. I have many large dogs. Because of my love of animals I was even a vegetarian for years until my doctor told me that I needed corned beef to live. Heck, I once did a funeral for a woodpecker. Some people have street cred; I have animal cred, pal!

So it is with all that defensive armor in place that I tell you I almost completely loved the recent hit documentary film "March of the Penguins," which lavishly and tenderly photographs the extraordinary breeding habits of the emperor penguins of Antarctica as they march some 70 miles back and forth from the sea and food in order to keep one egg warm enough to hatch into their frozen but stunning world. That a movie where nothing explodes and no one is chased or bloodied or bedded can rise to the status of commercial success is surely a testimony that our culture is not dead yet. However, there is one part of Morgan Freeman's dulcet narration that caught me up short. He opines triumphantly at one point, "This is not just a story of survival, it is a story of love."

Not so fast, penguin breath. I am prepared to admire animal mating lust, animal sacrifice for the survival of their species and even, as we see in the movie, animal cooperative behavior as they construct a living, moving mass penguin scrum to help them survive the freezing Antarctic blasts. However, I am not prepared to believe that penguins or any animals actually fall in love the way we as humans understand romantic love. That's where I get off the iceberg. Look, the "loving" emperor penguin couples stay together just one year, after which they abandon their chicks to the ocean. If perchance the egg or the chick freezes to death, the penguin marriage is dissolved and so too their penguin love. They pick a mate, but they do not choose a lover. They copulate but they do not say or feel about their penguin mate what D. H. Lawrence said and felt:

Read More on News

That is love. What penguins have is beautiful and inspiring but it is not love, and if you need it to be love, you need to get out more.

Penguins don't plight their troth to one another for fish or no fish, for colder or really colder, for seas full of krill or seas full of leopard seals. And all this is just fine with me. They are penguins, for God's sake! They are not people, and however admirable and even inspirational their lives may be to us, they do not posses the thickness of emotion nor the ethical sensibility that alone gives love its unique and defining human essence.Denying that penguins possess the ability to love, is neither insult nor canard. It is not penguinism or penguinphobic. It just preserves the critically important spiritual and ethical distinction between people and all other species of animals.

Anthropopathism is the error of ascribing uniquely human emotions to anything nonhuman. It has both positive and negative correlates. On the positive side we can smile at the loving penguins, but on another day, in another theater, we can ascribe with equal foolishness the human emotion of anger or vengeance to that great white shark in "Jaws." Sharks are not evil anymore than penguins are loving. They are animals--no, I would never say they are just animals because I consider all animals creations of God. They are animals filled with the wonderful scope of behaviors and emotions that are appropriate to animal life. Their unique virtue as animals is to show us a creation that can never be corroded by sin. Their lives are transparent reflections of God's will (or Nature's will, assuming you believe Nature has a will, which is foolish but a topic for another time). When we ascribe love to penguins, we are compelled to ascribe evil to snakes and sharks and scorpions and mosquitoes. I will take my penguins plain, thank you very much, and I will take my sharks as beautiful fish who have no desire to eat helicopters or fishing boats. Perhaps Melville began this destructive move to ascribe human emotions to animals, but "Moby-Dick" and "Jaws" remain mere fictional figments of human imagination. Thankfully this matters not a wit to the beautiful emperor penguins of Antarctica. We have not been placed in this world by God or Darwin (take your pick) to ascribe human emotions to the animals we love or fear or eat or tend or squash beneath our tires on the way home from watching the penguin movie.

Of course, I could be wrong. I am often wrong but never in doubt. Perhaps, during the filming of "March of the Penguins," one of the penguins saw the camera crew and squawked in Penguinese to his or her mate, "Do you think they love?"

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines