10

Loading video...

Steve Mollman

By Steve Mollman

News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Elon Musk's SpaceX faces a threat to its U.S. government funding as a top congressional Democrat demands answers about restrictions on satellite communications that have disrupted Ukraine's military operations against Russia.

Representative Jim Himes, who is set to become chairman of the House Intelligence Committee in January, has warned that Congress could restrict funding for SpaceX-developed systems unless questions about changes to Ukraine's military-grade Starshield service are answered, according to a November 20 letter to Musk reviewed by Newsweek.

The warning raises the stakes in a dispute that has already drawn scrutiny from Republicans and Democrats, with billions of dollars in federal contracts potentially at issue.

Read More on News

"Simply, our committee cannot authorize funds for the development of government systems that the government will not fully control," Himes wrote in a classified communication to Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton, according to CNN, which said it obtained an excerpt of the document.

In his letter to Musk, Himes also requested a meeting with senior SpaceX officials to discuss the Starshield restrictions.

Newsweek also sought comment from SpaceX, the Pentagon and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence.

Why Himes Is Threatening SpaceX Funding

Himes said committee staff had requested a briefing from SpaceX on multiple occasions but received no substantive response.

The Connecticut Democrat warned that the company's handling of the disruptions raises questions extending far beyond Ukraine.

"My view, which I have conveyed to senior Administration officials, is that SpaceX's potentially unilateral modification of a U.S. Government contract, combined with its lack of responsiveness to congressional oversight, calls into question every contract the U.S. Government has with SpaceX," Himes wrote in the letter.

Himes argued that although the government-purchased Starshield service uses SpaceX's commercial Starlink satellite constellation, that does not give the company authority to make unilateral changes to the service.

One option available to Himes is a mechanism known as "ring fencing," which allows lawmakers to restrict funding for certain projects through the annual Intelligence Authorization Act until specified conditions are met. He could also work with congressional appropriators to block or redirect additional funding.

No funding restrictions have been imposed, and it remains unclear whether Himes would have sufficient support in Congress to carry them out.

SpaceX holds billions of dollars in federal contracts and provides satellite and launch capabilities that are critical to U.S. national security.

The company has become deeply integrated into American defense operations, complicating any effort to restrict funding without disrupting capabilities the military itself relies on.

Elon Musk speaks with Donald Trump at a SpaceX Starship launch in Brownsville, Texas, on November 19, 2024. A top Democrat is threatening restrictions on SpaceX funding over satellite disruptions affecting Ukraine.

...

Ukraine's Starshield Restrictions Spark Congressional Scrutiny

The funding threat follows repeated restrictions on Ukraine's access to SpaceX satellite services during its war with Russia.

After similar restrictions were lifted in late October, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said November 12 that his forces were again experiencing Starshield disruptions along the more than 700-mile front line and in Russian-occupied Ukrainian territory.

"These are not random errors but systematic speed restrictions," Zelensky said, as previously reported by Newsweek.

Two days later, Zelensky said the restrictions had been in place for five days and were undermining Ukraine's ability to intercept Russian attack drones.

"They say it is some kind of technical issue. We do not believe that is the case," Zelensky told reporters.

He also raised concerns about the political implications of limiting service in Russian-occupied Ukrainian territory.

"If you impose restrictions there, you are already partially recognizing the temporarily occupied territories as not ours," Zelensky said.

SpaceX denied introducing new restrictions or making changes to its satellite operations, Reuters reported November 14.

The dispute has centered on the distinction between Starlink, SpaceX's commercial satellite internet service, and Starshield, its military-focused system.

Ukrainian forces rely heavily on satellite connectivity for battlefield communications, drone operations and air defense.

In October, restrictions that cut satellite connectivity when equipment moved faster than 100 mph hampered Ukrainian drones used to intercept Russian attacks.

Who Ordered Ukraine's Starshield Slowdown?

The central question remains unanswered: Did SpaceX independently impose the restrictions, or did the Trump administration direct the company to do so?

Musk has maintained that the U.S. government controls Starshield.

"Starshield systems are owned and controlled by the US government. Any limits on speed or usage are decided by the US military and ultimately POTUS," Musk wrote on X in October.

He separately accused Ukraine of violating the terms of SpaceX's commercial Starlink service by using it for offensive drone attacks.

"Ukraine military violated Starlink terms of service and used it for offensive drone strikes to kill people. That loophole was closed last week," Musk wrote October 24.

Serhii Beskrestnov, a defense technology adviser to Zelensky, disputed Musk's characterization, saying existing restrictions already prevented Ukraine from using commercial Starlink for long- or medium-range drone strikes, Reuters reported October 24.

Two days earlier, the news agency reported, citing two U.S. officials and a Western official briefed on the matter, that the order to impose the October Starshield restrictions came from inside the White House. The officials did not identify who made the decision.

Secretary of State Marco Rubio denied that anyone in the White House had ordered the slowdown.

"No one at the White House ordered anyone to slow down internet or slow down speeds so that certain drones couldn't use it," Rubio told reporters October 17.

He added: "Nobody ordered that Starlink speed to be slowed down. It sort of happened, but my understanding is it's been restored."

Trump has also denied personal responsibility.

"It wasn't me, and I don't think it was Elon," the president previously told reporters.

Asked by Newsweek about the Starshield restrictions and Himes' funding threat, the White House referred to Trump's previous comments on the matter.

CNN reported Friday that SpaceX executives and defense officials had privately told some lawmakers the original decision came from the White House, citing a source familiar with those discussions.

The conflicting accounts have intensified questions about who exercises operational control over systems developed by SpaceX but managed by the U.S. government.

Republicans Also Call for Starshield Investigation

Concern over the disruptions has crossed party lines.

Representative Mike Turner, an Ohio Republican who serves on the House Armed Services Committee, called for a congressional investigation in October.

"There needs to be an investigation. There needs to be a congressional investigation," Turner told CBS News' Face the Nation.

"People's lives are at risk, and lives are lost over these things," he added.

Appearing separately on the same program, Republican Senator Kevin Cramer of North Dakota also supported an investigation but cautioned that the disruption might have resulted from a technical problem rather than a deliberate decision.

A bipartisan group of nine senators separately requested a Pentagon inspector general investigation into whether actions by the Defense Department or its contractors contributed to the disruptions.

CNN reported Friday that the inspector general declined the request and directed lawmakers to the relevant military branches.

Democratic Senators Jeanne Shaheen of New Hampshire and Chris Coons of Delaware escalated the pressure on November 13, demanding that Musk preserve records concerning the restrictions.

"The October and November restrictions now raise the disturbing possibility that these vulnerabilities persist even within systems on which the U.S. government relies," the senators wrote in their November 13 letter to Musk.

They requested preservation of records dating back to September 1, including communications between Musk, SpaceX executives, the White House and Pentagon.

The senators gave Musk until November 30 to confirm that appropriate preservation measures had been implemented and answer questions about who authorized the restrictions, their technical parameters and which remained in effect.

What Happens Next for Musk and SpaceX?

Once Himes becomes committee chairman in January, he could pursue investigations into SpaceX's government contracts and seek restrictions on funding.

Democrats on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee are also preparing to investigate the Starshield disruptions when they assume control of the panel.

Himes has asked Musk to explain what changes were made to Starshield in October, why they were made and whether SpaceX acted independently or at the direction of a U.S. government official.

He also demanded a precise technical explanation of which parts of Ukraine currently receive Starshield service, which do not and whether SpaceX is independently making those decisions.

"It is difficult for me to continue supporting the authorization of funding for these SpaceX-developed, government-owned systems until I receive satisfactory answers to my questions about the Starshield service in Ukraine," Himes wrote in his November 20 letter to Musk.

"SpaceX must be transparent with this Committee so we better understand the circumstances surrounding the October 2026 Starshield service disruptions in Ukraine and so we can make a fully informed decision about whether Congress should proceed with SpaceX as a contractor on other national security initiatives," Himes wrote.

Newsweek reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Steve Mollman, Gray R. Thomas

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines