Getty Images

Carlo Versano

By Carlo Versano

Director, Politics & Culture

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Happy State of the Union Day to those who celebrate.

I, for one, do not. But I do celebrate our Newsweek community, and nothing builds community like collectively watching a two-hour speech that could’ve been an email. Even if that speech starts at 9 p.m., which should be illegal. So tonight, instead of suffering alone, I’m proposing we do it together.

If you're interested, we're going to do a little SOTU watch party tonight over on Subtext, a new service that allows Newsweek members to contact me directly via text message. It's been great fun so far. I plan to sign on right after I get the munchkin to bed, and we can watch and text together...at least until I fall asleep. Come one, come all.

Read More on Opinion

Here's how in two simple steps:

If you aren't already (why not?), become a Newsweek member by signing up here for just $4.99 a month.

Then join me on Subtext here for free. It really is that easy.

Let's be honest. SOTU is a laundry list of policy ideas that will never happen, lies and half-truths about things that did—and if it's an election year, plenty of red meat for the base, interrupted only by half of the room clapping, callouts to random people in the audience, and the occasional heckle or performative walkout. God, it's brutal. In Carlo's America, we're going back to how we used to do it: the president writes and delivers an annual letter to Congress, and we don't have to hear about it.

But alas, we don't live in Carlo's America. We live in Donald Trump's, and tonight is his night to make his pitch to voters ahead of the midterms, at a time when he is at the nadir of his popularity. I suppose the biggest unknown is which Trump will show up. Will he stick to the prompter? Or will he go off on weird tangents? Probably both. Will he deliver a sharp and nuanced message on affordability, the issue atop voters' minds, or crow about how he "beat inflation" and tell parents to stop buying their kids so many dolls? Tune in to find out.

That question of which president shows up to the SOTU is not specific to Trump. Joe Biden gave a somewhat coherent address in 2024 and the media reaction was that he was fit as a fiddle and the concerns over his cognitive decline were overblown. Then three months later he ate it on the debate stage and ended his presidency right there on the spot. So if Trump manages to successfully stay on message and not verbally abuse a Supreme Court justice to their face tonight, it will be deemed a great success.

President Donald Trump delivers the State of the Union address in the chamber of the U.S. House of Representatives on February 4, 2020, in Washington, DC.

...

Here are some other thoughts and questions I have ahead of the address. I hope this gives you some inspiration if you join me on Subtext later. Your voice matters to us, and the best suggestions will be featured in a Newsweek article.

How much does the president dwell on foreign policy, an arena where—I believe, at least—he has had more success than his signature domestic issues of tariffs and deportations. He'll probably crow about the seven or eight (or is it more now?) wars he claims to have ended. But it would be great for the country if he took a beat to explain the rationale for what is increasingly looking like a new regime-change war in the Middle East. I would love to see him argue that decapitating the Iranian regime is of a piece with the so-called Donroe Doctrine (boxing out Beijing and Moscow by toppling their allies and proxies, one by one). The president really should be using this platform to make the case directly to the American people that going to war with Iran is in the national interest.

On immigration, it will be notable to see whether Trump touts the "softer touch" approach he has himself suggested his admin needs. One way to do that is to focus on his successes with border security rather than the messier and far less popular issue of interior enforcement (it still boggles my mind that Trump hasn't even visited the border this term). Does Tom Homan get a shoutout for calming the situation in Minneapolis? Does Kristi Noem get ignored for the various ways her antics at DHS have undercut and humiliated the White House? Maybe they make her the "Designated Survivor" instead.

The portion of the speech dedicated to tariffs could be where things go sideways. His speechwriters surely understand this is one of his worst issues, according to polling, even as it's also evidently one of the few things Trump actually, truly believes in. To make matters worse, he just got publicly embarrassed on his signature issue by the SCOTUS last week. As is customary, those justices will be in the chamber tonight right smack in front of the dais. The biggest open question of the evening is probably whether Trump can manage to get through the speech without succumbing to the urge to take a detour into nasty, personal swipes at the justices who ruled against him.

I'll also be curious if the president dedicates any time in this stemwinder to AI. This is an area where the admin is walking blind to the concerns of regular people, who are not even close to sold on how this technology is going to help them rather than render them unemployable or otherwise disrupt their lives. Can the POTUS make the case that AI is going to benefit society in any tangible way? Or that the benefits won't just be concentrated at the very top of the food chain? Politicians who ignore the growing AI-skeptic constituency are doing so at their own peril.

Then we have the cursed SOTU response, the worst job in politics. The Democrats have chosen Abigail Spanberger, the new governor of Virginia, this year. The bet there is that after nearly 2 hours of hearing Trump talk, someone like her—relatively moderate, competent, female, even boring—will sound like a breath of fresh air by comparison. And Spanberger surely knows that all you have to do to succeed with the response is to NOT go viral. Recall Marco Rubio taking his mid-rebuttal water break, or Bobby Jindal looking like Kenneth the Page from "30 Rock", or Joe Kennedy and his chapped lips. The State of the Union response is where presidential ambitions go to die.

And yes, I may well drown my sorrows.

In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.

When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines