0.cached.png

0.cached.png

Barrett Sheridan

By Barrett Sheridan

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Yesterday was one of those days where so many people on the Internet were wrong that I almost couldn't sleep because of it.

I'll restrain myself to just one example: Mark Gimein's defense of Goldman Sachs in The Big Money. (Disclosure: Newsweek and The Big Money are owned by The Washington Post Company.)

I don't have any problem with a well-reasoned defense of Goldman's strong second-quarter profits, seen by some as "obscene." Bankers are supposed to be greedy and grab what they can, so anti-Goldman anger is in large part misdirected─it probably should be focused on the regulators and politicians who gave trillions in tax dollars to Wall Street but required little in return, other than a polite request: "Please don't go bankrupt and destroy the world." But Gimein seems to completely misunderstand why people are upset. In his words:

Read More on News

The real objection of Taibbi and other Goldman bashers is that Goldman, except for one bad quarter at the nadir of the financial crisis, has made profits. Big profits.

That's a ridiculous statement on its face. Goldman has had many, many successful quarters spread out over many, many years. Does Gimein not understand why this year's banking profits are more rage-inducing? Or, put another way: IBM made $3.1 billion this quarter, roughly the same as Goldman's $3.4 billion in profits. How come people aren't poking their pitchforks in IBM's direction instead of Goldman's?

Simple: Because Goldman Sachs has been and continues to be the beneficiary of extraordinary public assistance, and billions of dollars of taxpayer money. Surely no one has forgotten that Goldman accepted $10 billion in TARP money last fall, which it paid back to the government─with interest. Great. It's perhaps easier to forget that Goldman received $12.9 billion of taxpayer dollars when AIG wound down its derivatives contracts. (At the suggestion of the banks and their political allies, those contracts were paid off at 100 cents on the dollar─in other words, Goldman and the rest of Wall Street funneled a ton of risk to AIG over the years, and then didn't have to pay any price at all when it was found that their choice of counterparty was a bit, ahem, unwise. Socialism for the rich.)

It's also probably easy to overlook all the other government programs, like the Temporary Liquidity Guarantee Program, which Goldman has used to borrow $28 billion virtually cost-free. Then there's the Federal Reserve's Term Asset-Backed Securities Loan Facility, which lets banks like Goldman use crappy assets (credit-card and student-loan debt, for instance) as collateral for loans. Oh, not to mention the fact that the federal government let Bear Stearns, Merrill Lynch, and Lehman Brothers die (or get absorbed into larger firms) while breathing life into Goldman (and JP Morgan, etc.) and granting the survivors the gift of oligopolistic profits in the process.

There is way more to mention, but luckily, the Taibbi that Gimein mentions, Matt Taibbi of "vampire squid" fame, has compiled most of them in one place, so there's no need to repeat them all here.

So no, the Goldman antipathy is not an "attack on profits per se," as Gimein believes, nor is it even discomfort with speculation or risk-taking. It's the feeling that regulatory agencies held captive by the bankers they're supposed to regulate have given away trillions of dollars and required next to nothing in sacrifice. It's the feeling that the taxpayers paid the tab for a lobster dinner, and got canned tuna in return─only to see some glistening, red carapaces at the Goldman table next door.

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines