
...

By Tom Rogers
Editor-at-Large for Newsweek
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
AI will likely be the most transformative technology ever developed. It is on a path to affect our lives in countless ways, is driving the stock market and to some extent the growth of the economy, making it a hugely potent financial catalyst in the present. What naturally follows is an array of views on how the government should regulate AI’s development.
Having served as senior counsel to the House of Representatives Telecommunications Subcommittee in the 1980s when cable television was rapidly developing, when there was significant focus on how its regulation would affect the flow of programming and information to all households in the United States, I find myself reliving the core question faced then of what should be the role of the federal government versus the states in the regulation of a new technology.

...
Read More on Opinion
The cable industry in response was seeking federal pre-emption of state and city regulation to enable the industry to develop without these significant financial burdens, and to subject the industry to uniform national standards as opposed to a patchwork of local regulatory schemes that further undermined the ability of the industry to grow.
The battle back then over cable television regulation was largely fought between mayors of major cities and the cable industry. Cities had discovered that through the competitive process of awarding a cable TV franchise for a city they could extract all kinds of financial payments and require the funding of major projects for their cities by the cable industry. From paving sidewalks to building libraries, the award of cable TV franchises turned into municipal piggy banks. This had the effect of stifling the development of cable TV and the promise it provided of not only vastly more TV channels for Americans, but far more competition to the three broadcast networks that then totally dominated the entire TV industry.
The same themes are replaying themselves in the development of the artificial intelligence industry. The Trump administration has taken the position—which is about to be codified in an executive order that Trump has announced he will issue this week—that the federal government should pre-empt the states from regulating AI with the exact same argument, that a patchwork of 50 state regulatory approaches will thwart AI’s development in the U.S. and will sharply hinder American AI companies from having global leadership and staying ahead of Chinese AI players. The White House AI Czar, David Sacks, has been adamant that there are over 1,000 bills that have been introduced across the states to regulate AI and that this ad hoc, uncoordinated approach is an enormous threat to the promise of what AI can deliver.
There has not been a single coherent AI policy view expressed by the Democratic Party. It is also worth noting that there are many within MAGA circles that believe AI should be deeply regulated on a number of levels and are at odds with the Trump administration laissez-faire approach to its regulation.
The ferocious lobbying that will develop on the regulatory question has only just begun, most notably with a $100,000,000 super PAC called Leading the Future that will be the major AI industry force against state-by-state regulation.
Both sides have some legitimate arguments. There is no doubt that a fragmented regulatory landscape with inconsistent standards that would complicate compliance for AI businesses operating across the country is a very strong argument against allowing state-by-state regulation as an approach. It would no doubt raise the cost of industry development and regulatory compliance significantly, which would be particularly burdensome to smaller companies.
Moreover, conflicting regulatory requirements is definitely a formula for slowing innovation. Thus, federal regulation pre-empting the states by establishing uniform nationwide standards would seem to be a better formula for how AI interstate commerce can be nurtured. It is hard to argue that uniform federal standards would not create far more certainty for businesses that would catalyze growth for an industry that is critical to the American economy’s preeminence faced with a China nipping at our heels on AI industry development.
However, state regulation arguably has its place. As of this year, 27 states have enacted a total of 73 laws related to AI that deal with an array of issues from protections against deepfakes, how AI can be used in health care and education and government use of AI in law enforcement. Other state laws deal with disclosing to users when they are interacting with AI systems and AI companies having to disclose risks that their AI systems pose and how they are addressing them. In addition, safeguarding children, where there have already been suicides among kids involved in intimate chats with AI bots, is a pressing need. The lack of guard rails on the internet when it comes to social media use by minors has proved to be a major problem.
The 1984 Cable Communications Policy Act provides a constructive framework for how to resolve these issues. It is hard to argue that federal preemption of municipal regulation of cable did not drive a hugely robust television industry with far more entertainment and news choices for the public than had previously existed. However, in laying out the cable ground rules there were clear areas where state and city regulation was allowed to continue—from the right to grant and revoke franchises under clear federal standards on extracting payments, setting consumer protection rules such as billing disclosure and how public, educational and governmental access channels on cable systems could be used. In the end, we were able to forge a very workable compromise between the industry and local officials on how each side's needs could be met, and it was accomplished on a bipartisan basis.
AI is certainly a more complicated beast and will undoubtedly have much or more impact on all aspects of life compared to cable. Yet, one thing is very clear. If the federal government is not going to act at all, it is extremely unlikely to stop the current momentum for a growing patchwork of state regulations. A balkanized industry is not in the interest of the industry, the U.S. economy or American consumers. There are major issues of AI safety when it comes to how it interacts with users and an array of safeguards via legislation need to be implemented to limit the potential for heavily warned about misuses of AI.
Creating federal regulatory authority that can address these issues, and what governmental entity will have the right to exercize that authority, is critical for Congress to address.
Just like in the cable TV context, Republican and Democratic governors alike will descend on Washington to preserve their regulatory authority over AI claiming they are far closer to the issues their citizens will confront, and will be able to address problems more expeditiously than the federal government. Codifying a major federal/state regulatory agreement must happen. This will take enormous legislative skill and bipartisan leadership.
The state of AI regulation cannot be left alone to the states.
Tom Rogers is executive chairman of Claigrid, Inc. (the cloud AI grid company), an editor-at-large for Newsweek*, the founder of* CNBC and a CNBC contributor. He also established MSNBC*, is the former CEO of TiVo, a member of Keep Our Republic (an organization dedicated to preserving the nation's democracy). He is also a member of the American Bar Association Task Force on Democracy.*
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines