...
By Claire Dodds
Life & Trends Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A shopper has turned to Reddit after noticing the surge of protein-packed versions of everyday foods—and those that are typically considered treats.
Posting to Reddit, user papyap shared photos of Pop-Tarts Protein and Eggo Protein waffles, writing, “I’m no nutritionist, but I feel pretty sure that eating crap food like Pop-Tarts and Eggo waffles isn’t going to supply us with adequate protein intake.
“I mean, [I don't know] but seems silly to me.”
Read More on Affiliate Links
...
The post quickly attracted responses from other Reddit users discussing whether protein-enhanced snacks are helpful nutrition options or simply the latest marketing trend.
The conversation reflects a broader shift happening across grocery stores and restaurant menus as companies lean into consumers’ growing focus on protein.
According to reporting by USA TODAY, major retailers including Amazon, Target and Walmart have expanded shelves with products like protein snacks, drinks and bars to meet demand.
Target shoppers, for example, can now find items such as Protein Pop snacks with 22 grams of protein, while Walmart has introduced products like David high-protein bars containing around 28 grams.
High-protein diets have gained popularity in recent years, partly due to interest in weight management and muscle maintenance.
USA TODAY reported that in the 2025 IFIC Food & Health Survey, 70 percent of Americans said protein was the top nutrient they were trying to consume more of.
Nutrition experts say protein plays an important role in the body, but the trend has also raised questions about whether people actually need more of it.
“Contrary to all the hype that everyone needs more protein, most people in the U.S. meet or exceed their needs,” dietitian Kristi Wempen wrote in guidance published by the Mayo Clinic Health System.
"Protein is important because it helps with muscle repair, satiety, immune function, blood sugar management and overall health," Abbey Sharp, registered dietitian and bestselling author of The Hunger Crushing Combo Method, told Newsweek. "But I think the media has turned it into the exclusive main character of nutrition when in reality it’s just one part of the cast."
"I do worry that when we exclusively think about adding protein, we may end up displacing other key nutrients like fiber (which only 95 percent of North Americans are eating enough of) or adding excess calories," Sharp continued.
A Varied Diet
The article explains that the recommended dietary allowance for a sedentary adult is about 0.8 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight, roughly 60 grams a day for someone weighing 165 pounds.
Wempen wrote that people can meet their needs through a variety of whole foods such as fish, lean meats, dairy products and plant-based options like beans, soy and lentils.
Online, however, users debated whether fortified snacks actually deliver meaningful nutrition or simply capitalize on the popularity of the nutrient.
Reddit Reacts
One Reddit user pushed back on criticism of the products, writing, “As a person with blood sugar issues, I’m so sick of seeing everyone moan about protein products.
"I can’t have Pop-Tarts, but I can have these. It seems like everyone is quick to say ‘if you don’t get it, it’s simply not for you’ until they see something they don’t get.”
Another added, “I appreciate these extra protein items because they allow me to have a treat every now and then.”
High-Protein Sources
For consumers trying to evaluate whether a product is actually a strong protein source, some online nutrition communities have circulated simple label-reading tips.
One popular rule of thumb compares protein grams to calorie counts: multiply the protein grams by 10, and if the result meets or exceeds the calories in a serving, the food is considered relatively protein-dense.
Examples of high-protein foods based on this calculation:
- lean chicken, turkey, or beef
- canned salmon or tuna
- lentils and beans
- edamame, tofu or tempeh
"Instead of focusing on just one 'superstar' nutrient like protein, I encourage people to think about the synergy of foods and focus on a balance of protein, fiber-rich carbs and healthy fats," Sharp advises.
As for more processed protein products, Sharp assures healthy eaters that they are not all bad.
"I like options that are simple, where the first ingredient is the protein-rich ingredient (rather than it being something sprinkled in for good marketing). Things like protein powder, protein yogurts, high protein pasta (legume-based pasta) and cottage cheese snacks."
The Reddit thread illustrates the divide around protein-enhanced foods: some shoppers see them as unnecessary marketing, while others view them as accessible ways to increase protein intake without drastically changing their diets.
As food companies continue expanding protein-focused offerings, those differing opinions are likely to remain part of the conversation in grocery aisles and online.
Newsweek has reached out to nutrition experts for comment via email.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines