
...
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer signed classroom phone restrictions in February, she used the student-centered language most governors now do. It was all about academic success, youth mental health and rescuing children from a life lost staring vacantly into screens.
“These bills will help keep kids focused in the classroom and break their growing dependency on screens and social media,” the Democratic governor said in February.
The child-wellness case is strong enough, and issues like social media addiction and online bullying clearly cause harm to kids. But the latest evidence points to something less sentimental than the minds of children. New York's Democratic Governor Kathy Hochul was nearer the mark a whole year earlier.
Read More on Analysis
"How hard is it for our teachers to teach algebra or geography when they're competing with viral dances, messages from friends, and sometimes threats or bullying?” Hochul said back in January 2025, when discussing a phone ban for kids.
Now, a new working paper from the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) has found limited academic payoff for the kids—but happier teachers. That may be the real victory in these school bans.
Classroom Control
The NBER study examined data from 2018 to 2025 at more than 41,000 schools and found little academic benefit from phone bans, with the average effect on test scores described as “consistently close to zero.”
The same study found that bans also did not significantly affect attendance, perceptions of online bullying or in-class engagement. E. Jason Baron, a Duke University economist and one of the paper’s authors, put it bluntly: “It’s hard to move outcomes like test scores.”
But the policy did move the thing teachers experience minute by minute: device use inside classrooms. The researchers found that cellphone pings fell by roughly 30 percent by the third year of a ban, and teacher surveys showed in-class phone use dropped from 61 percent to 13 percent after schools introduced Yondr pouches to lock away the devices.
Teachers in those surveys said strict bans made them happier in their jobs. That is not a trivial finding. It says the first-order effect of phone bans may not be a leap in student achievement, but the restoration of adult authority, a crucial first step in improving educational outcomes down the line.
Teachers Say the Quiet Part Out Loud
The educator survey data points in the same direction. Preliminary findings from Phones in Focus, a UPenn national survey of more than 20,000 public school educators, found that stricter schoolwide cellphone policies were linked to less in-class phone use and higher teacher satisfaction.
Angela Duckworth, who is leading the project, said, “The stricter the policy, the happier the teacher and the less likely students are to be using their phones when they aren’t supposed to.”
A RAND survey published in 2025 found teachers were more likely than similar working adults to report poor well-being on every measured indicator, and 16 percent of teachers said they intended to leave their jobs.
Education Week’s survey of 270 district recruiters found that 29 percent said a student cellphone policy was a helpful recruiting tactic in 2025, up from 20 percent in a similar 2024 survey.
Chimere Stephens, a senior recruitment official for New York City schools, told the publication: “Teachers tell me all the time that they spend significantly less instructional time managing behavior when phones are removed and more time teaching.”
Why Politicians Sell Child Wellness
The politics of phone bans works because the policy can be pitched as a child-protection measure while delivering an adult-workplace benefit. It speaks to a universal concern among parents, something that can’t be dismissed as a labor issue hyped up by unions, or worse still, a failure of teacher competence.
At least 37 states and the District of Columbia now require school districts to ban or restrict student cellphone use, according to an Education Week tally.
Michigan’s official announcement framed its law around student focus, performance and mental health. And Republican Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders said her state’s “Bell to Bell, No Cell Act” was about protecting children, adding, “This isn’t a red state or a blue state issue; it’s about putting our kids first.”
That rhetoric is politically safer than saying the adult in the room needs the state to help reassert basic working conditions. Yet the teacher-retention case is more immediate and more measurable than the grandest claims about youth mental health.
Recruiters are already treating phone policy as a workplace signal, and Alex Moseman of Tennessee’s Knox County schools told Education Week that “a lot of it boils down to the ability to focus on teaching during the day.”
The unglamorous truth is that a class with fewer buzzing devices is not automatically a healed childhood, but it may be a more survivable job. And if a teacher can get through to the end of class, chances are the kid will get through to the end of school.
Manageability, Not a Cure
The best case for phone bans is practical, not utopian.
A Florida-focused NBER paper by David Figlio and Umut Özek found modest test-score gains in the second year of a statewide instructional-time phone ban. But it also found that suspensions rose in the first year and that the short-term discipline increase was driven especially by Black students.
The new national findings similarly suggest bans can reduce phone use without reliably producing large gains in test scores, attendance or engagement.
Those results don’t expel the case for bans, they discipline it. A serious phone-ban policy would measure teacher time spent policing devices, teacher satisfaction, teacher intent to stay, student discipline patterns and student outcomes together.
The Phones in Focus findings already suggest that storage rules matter, because strict storage policies such as lockers or Yondr pouches performed better than “no-show” rules that let students keep phones nearby.
Jonathan Buchwalter, the Alabama teacher profiled by the National Education Association (NEA), a labor union, said, “I wouldn’t want to work for a school district that doesn’t have these measures in place. I don’t want to go back.”
That is the sentence policymakers should stop talking around. School phone bans may help students, but the clearest early payoff is that they make schools easier places to teach.
If governors want the policy to last, they should be honest about that and judge bans not just by whether children are less distracted, but by whether teachers regain enough order to stay.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines