Sarah Boone

...

Jenna Sundel

By Jenna Sundel

News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The jury delivered a swift guilty verdict in the murder trial of Sarah Boone on Friday evening after closing arguments wrapped up.

It took the jurors less than two hours to find Boone, 46, guilty of second-degree murder in the 2020 death of her boyfriend, 42-year-old Jorge Torres Jr. She was found guilty of convincing her boyfriend to get inside a suitcase at a home in Florida, then zipping it shut and refusing to let him out. When she opened the suitcase the next morning, he was dead.

Boone faces a minimum of 22 and a half years in prison and a potential life sentence. She will be sentenced on Dec. 2.

Read More on News

Assistant State Attorney Dave Cacciatore Jr. delivered a dramatic closing argument for the prosecution earlier in the day. He displayed the suitcase Torres died in while presenting the argument.

"This is the box where Jorge Torres was killed," Cacciatore said. "It's a small box, 28 by 20 by 7, 8 inches. Jorge Torres was zipped up in this box. Jorge Torres took his last panicked breaths in this box. The medical examiner explained to us that with each breath Jorge Torres took in, there was less oxygen in this box. Jorge Torres was murdered in this box."

Sarah Boone

...

Cacciatore said Boone "took the law into her own hands."

"Her testimony was that when Jorge Torres was in here, he was laughing and giggling, and they were joking, and then he started to complain that he couldn't breathe," Cacciatore said. "And that's when she said that she wanted him to stay in there, so he could feel uncomfortable, so he could feel her grievances. Ladies and gentlemen, that is not lawful."

Sarah Boone

...

He also argued that Boone was not justified in using deadly force against Torres.

"No reasonably prudent and cautious person would believe that a man who could barely fit into this box, who was incapable of movement, who was begging for his life, who was slowly asphyxiating, suffocating with each breath, would have needed to use deadly force against him," Cacciatore said. "The justifiable use of deadly force utterly fails, utterly crashes like a house of cards."

Cacciatore played several videos for the jury, including one where Boone was instructing Torres on what to say in court in order to get a case against her dismissed.

"Clearly, Jorge Torres is dominating the defendant," Cacciatore said sarcastically. "Clearly, Jorge Torres is the one telling the defendant what to do. Clearly, Jorge Torres is the one calling the shots at 4748 Frantz Lane. Ladies and gentlemen, are we so sure that Jorge Torres wasn't the person suffering from battered spouse syndrome?"

The defense has argued that Boone was suffering from battered spouse syndrome throughout the trial.

Cacciatore also accused Boone of changing her story regarding the events leading up to Torres' death.

"The truth does not change," Cacciatore said. "The facts do not change. The videos do not change, and one any version of events that the defendant has given, they all add up to the fact that there is absolutely no doubt that she is guilty of murder."

When Cacciatore played a video taken by Boone while Torres was trapped inside the suitcase, a family member of Torres had an emotional reaction and left the courtroom. Boone's lawyer, James Owens, requested a mistrial, arguing the reaction could have tainted the jury's opinion.

"What happened here today should not ever happen," Owens said. "There should be safeguards in place. There's no room for this."

Sarah Boone

...

Orange County Circuit Judge Michael Kraynick denied the motion.

During Owens' closing argument, he argued that Boone's use of deadly force was justified.

"I think you will find from considering the evidence in this case, that there is no doubt that Sarah Boone is a victim, that Sarah Boone has been traumatized, that Sarah Boone is still traumatized," Owens said. "And the reason for the trauma is Jorge Torres."

He alleged that Torres abused Boone and she felt "trapped psychologically."

"Due to this clear abuse, Sarah Boone had a reasonable belief of imminent harm under her state of mind," Owens said. "Jorge Torres had a history of violence against Sarah, and as a result, Sarah Boone's actions were the result of fear conditioned by the abuse she endured over time."

Sarah Boone

...

Owens said Torres chose to get inside of the suitcase.

"He's a grown a man," Owens said. "That was his choice. She didn't force him in at gunpoint to get into that suitcase. He voluntarily got into that suitcase because they were drunk and being silly and stupid and playing hide and seek."

Owens argued that Boone did not intentionally kill Torres.

"She loved the man," Owens said. "She wasn't trying to kill him."

Assistant State Attorney William Jay delivered a rebuttal argument.

"Jorge Torres is dead because the defendant believed he deserved to be zipped shut in a suitcase so that she could make him feel how she felt when he cheated on her, when he choked her and to hold him there as a captive audience, according to her testimony," Jay said.

What Has Happened in the Trial So Far

The trial began with jury selection on October 14 and opening statements started on October 18.

Jay argued that Boone intended to kill Torres in his opening statement.

"She did this with the malicious intent to punish him and then she went up to sleep and left him to take his final breaths on this Earth alone," Jay said.

Owens pushed back against the claim in his opening statement.

Jorge Torres, Jr.

...

"The prosecutors mentioned that she wanted him to die," Owens said. "The furthest from the truth, she loved him. She hated the abuse. She couldn't leave. She tried, she tried kicking him out six or seven times. He kept coming back. She changed the locks. He kept coming back. She didn't have the family. She didn't have the support. She was weak, vulnerable."

The prosecution then presented its case. The 14 witnesses called to the stand by prosecutors included law enforcement officers, a medical examiner, Torres' brother, former neighbors of the couple and Boone's ex-husband. The state rested its case on Tuesday.

The defense began presenting its case by calling Boone as its first witness. She answered various questions about the day Torres died.

"He wanted to start the day off by drinking because it was a day off from his job, and I talked him into cleaning and tidying up the house for a sense of accomplishment," Boone said.

Boone said they drank wine, worked on a puzzle, painted, danced and listened to music later that day. She said they concluded the night by playing a game of hide and seek.

"I guess he knew that I couldn't come up with anything to else, tapped me on my knee and said, 'you're it.' So from there I ran up the stairs and hid into our shower, just waiting for him to find me," Boone said.

She said that when she came back downstairs, Torres was getting inside of the suitcase.

Death-in-Suitcase-Florida

...

"I zipped him up," Boone said. "We thought it was funny, and we're joking about how he was small enough to fit inside of the suitcase."

The game then took a dark turn, according to Boone.

"His tone changed, and I knew the tone, and we ended up, I guess, arguing back and forth with one another," Boone said.

Boone said she later went upstairs and fell asleep. She claimed she was "never" trying to kill Torres.

Additional witnesses called by the defense included law enforcement officials, psychologists and a former neighbor of the couple. The defense rested its case on Thursday.

Do you have a story Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines