
...

By Anna Skinner
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
In a sharply worded dissent to the Supreme Court's decision preserving birthright citizenship, Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito argued that children born in the United States to migrants living in the country illegally should not automatically receive citizenship under the Fourteenth Amendment. Yet Alito also said those children should not be blamed for their parents' actions and argued that many of them should be allowed to remain in the country.
The dissent came Tuesday in Trump v. Barbara, in which the Supreme Court struck down President Donald Trump's attempt through an executive order to end birthright citizenship for many children born to immigrants. The majority held that children born in the United States to parents who are unlawfully or temporarily present in the country are citizens at birth under the Fourteenth Amendment.
Alito, one of three conservative justices who dissented, called the ruling "one of the most important decisions in the history of the Court" and said the majority had made "a serious mistake." Justice Clarence Thomas and Justice Neil Gorsuch also dissented.
Read More on U.S.

...
Alito argued that the Citizenship Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment has been interpreted too broadly. He wrote that the amendment now grants citizenship to "virtually everyone who happens to be born in this country," including the children of so-called "birth tourists"—women who travel to the United States primarily to give birth before returning to their home countries.
According to Alito, a proper reading of the amendment's text and historical background shows that citizenship should be limited to children who "owe allegiance solely to this country" at birth.
Northeastern University School of Law professor Rachel Rosenbloom told Newsweek that Alito is misreading the Fourteenth Amendment.
"Justice Alito seems to be trying to soften the blow of his shocking conclusion by saying that Congress should make some provision for at least some U.S.-born children of undocumented parents, but it is not at all clear how that would work," Rosenbloom said. "The bottom line is that Justice Alito is comfortable leaving the fate of these children to Congress, rather than honoring the intentions of the framers of the Fourteenth Amendment: to keep the nation from ever returning to the caste system of the Dred Scott era."
While much of his dissent focused on constitutional interpretation, Alito devoted several paragraphs to the practical consequences of changing birthright citizenship rules. He acknowledged that millions of children have been born in the United States to mothers who entered or remained in the country illegally and argued that they should not be held responsible for decisions made by their parents.
"Those children are not responsible for their parents' violation of our immigration laws," Alito wrote.
He argued that the situation stems from decades of immigration policies and enforcement practices that encouraged unlawful migration. The justice blamed what he described as a "coterie of actors," including federal officials, states, cities and private organizations, for creating the perception that U.S. immigration laws would not be strictly enforced.
According to Alito, that environment contributed to large-scale illegal immigration and the growth of a population of American-born children whose parents lacked legal status.
Related Story

‘Victory Remains’: Wong Kim Ark’s Family on Birthright Citizenship Ruling
Despite his disagreement with the Court's ruling, Alito stopped short of advocating the removal of those children or forcing them to leave the only country many have ever known.
"Some members of this group have lived here for years, and they have a strong moral claim to be able to remain in the land where they grew up," he wrote.
However, former federal prosecutor Neama Rahmani told Newsweek that under Alito's interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment, such children would have no legal right to remain in the U.S.
“Alito seemed to distinguish between the legal or constitutional right to citizenship and some moral or equitable right to remain in the United States," Rahmani said. "But under Alito's interpretation, children of undocumented parents would have no right to remain in the United States unless Congress enacted legislation conferring some sort of status, like DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals). Otherwise, those children would potentially be citizens of their parents' home country or stateless."
The justice suggested that Congress, rather than the courts, should address their future status.
"Congress can and should address their situation," Alito wrote.
He argued that the Fourteenth Amendment determines who must receive citizenship, but not who may become a citizen through legislation. As examples, he pointed to groups that have received citizenship through acts of Congress, including children born abroad to American parents and immigrants who later become naturalized citizens.
"These people and the millions of immigrants who have been naturalized are no less American than those who are fortunate enough to be born here," he wrote.
The dissent ultimately failed to persuade a majority of the court. Chief Justice John Roberts, writing for the court, concluded that children born in the United States to parents who are unlawfully or temporarily present are "subject to the jurisdiction" of the United States and therefore citizens at birth under the Fourteenth Amendment.
Still, Alito's opinion highlights a lesser-noticed aspect of the birthright citizenship debate: even while rejecting automatic constitutional citizenship for certain U.S.-born children, he argued that many of those individuals have developed compelling moral claims to stay in the country they call home and that Congress should consider a legislative path forward.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Jenni Fink and Sam Wilson.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines