
...

By Shane Croucher
Senior Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The word "plague" conjures the darkest chapters of human history. The Black Death killed somewhere between 30 to 60 percent of Europe’s population when it tore through the continent via rats and trade in the 14th century.
This is the enduring popular perception of plagues. Schoolchildren are routinely taught about painted crosses on doors, bursting pustules, and a near-certain agonizing death for those infected.
So when reports first emerged from the Russian city of Irkutsk about the death from suspected pneumonic plague of anti-plague biolab worker Daria Shipilova, 28, many responded with alarm. After all, left untreated, it has a mortality rate of 100 percent.
Read More on Analysis
Annie Jacobsen, author of Biological War: A Scenario, has sounded a frantic warning across social media and the television networks. She points to the involvement of Russia's domestic security and counterintelligence agency, the FSB, as a tell that this is a big deal for Russian security.
Mike Pompeo, the former U.S. Secretary of State, said the reports from Russia "should be treated with the utmost seriousness, especially considering the source."
"COVID showed us how the lies and obstruction of authoritarian governments seeking to cover their tracks can turn a containable outbreak into a global pandemic," Pompeo said.
The official U.S. reaction elevated concerns. On October 6, the U.S. Embassy in Moscow issued a health alert acknowledging press reports of suspected pneumonic plague in the Irkutsk region, a death, and hospital quarantines.
Washington, it added, has limited ability to help Americans in Russia, especially outside Moscow. The alert repeated the State Department’s standing instruction that U.S. citizens should leave Russia immediately over wrongful detention and security risks.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio, in Reykjavik, said it was incumbent on Russia to share more information with the world. Washington has since sent Moscow a démarche, a formal request for details.
President Donald Trump called the episode a "big problem" for Russia and said he has a call scheduled with his Russian counterpart, Vladimir Putin. Trump played down fears that the outbreak is linked to a bioweapon, though key questions remain unanswered.
But here’s the thing. Pneumonic plague sounds like the nightmare scenario. Strangely, it may be the more reassuring one. If the outbreak is indeed pneumonic plague—and, to be clear, that is in question—then the risk of a pandemic is lower than the reaction implies.
The Reality of Pneumonic Plague
Let’s not kid ourselves. Pneumonic plague is about as dangerous to a patient as infectious disease gets. The World Health Organization (WHO) describes it as invariably fatal when untreated, capable of killing within 18 to 24 hours.
But lethality does not equal pandemic potential in the modern world. And plague is badly equipped for the second.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) describes it as a pathogen that travels in large respiratory droplets, which fall out of the air rather than lingering.
Infection generally requires close exposure—the CDC says six feet—and has historically occurred among caregivers and household members.
For the first day or so after inhalation, transmission risk is minimal. In fact, asymptomatic transmission has never been documented.
A review of more than a century of U.S. surveillance data put the basic reproduction number at about 1.18, barely one onward infection per patient. Most American patients infected nobody, though the CDC’s data record occasional superspreading.
Standard control measures, it says, can push the figure below one. We’re better at keeping our distance from coughers and wearing high-quality medical masks than medieval merchants.
Related Story

Putin’s Birthday Gift to Himself: Living Longer Than You, Comrade
This is close to the inverse of an ideal pandemic pathogen. That’s not to say plague can’t spread. It has, in Madagascar, Uganda and Peru. But ordinary plague, strange though it is to describe plague as ordinary, is a poor candidate for a COVID-style global event.
Plague is bacterial. Meaningful natural resistance remains rare, but the CDC lists ciprofloxacin and gentamicin among first-line treatments, and close contacts can be given seven days of preventive antibiotics. Job done.
The limited evidence from the Siberian case fits that picture so far, though there is much we still don’t know. The heavy Russian state response indicates there may be a darker truth.
No plague diagnosis has been publicly confirmed. Russian authorities told the WHO that no plague case had recently been registered in Irkutsk.
They claimed that the dead woman’s illness first presented as a typical respiratory viral infection, and no dangerous pathogens were found among her contacts. European disease officials report no secondary cases so far.
The vital qualification is that almost all of those reassurances originate with Russian authorities, who took three days to answer a verification request the health regulations expect answered within one.
The WHO’s Maria Van Kerkhove said Wednesday it still cannot complete a risk assessment. It is asking which tests were run, whether a second employee fell ill—and, if this was not plague, what did kill Shipilova.
What We Don’t Know Might Kill Us
That last question is where the story has moved. Every reassuring fact above describes plague as medicine knows it.
But biosecurity specialists note that the Russian response—hazmat teams, locked-down hospitals, roughly 200 contacts isolated, the national public health chief flying in—looks disproportionate to a disease that is treatable and routine for the institute that handles it.
Amesh Adalja of the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security called it "incongruent with the plague response."
"Plague might be a lot of clickbait. People get really excited about it, but it's a treatable disease of the 21st century," he said. "Even if it were a drug-resistant version, it seemed to be a very major response to it."
Of course, that cuts two ways, and only one is alarming. It may mean Russian officials were containing something terrible they are covering up. It may equally mean an opaque bureaucracy overreacted to a death it couldn’t explain, then lost control of the story.
Related Story

Memo To America: This Is What a Crisis Looks Like
Speculation beyond that is premature. Asked in Iceland whether the incident might involve accidental release of a deliberately modified strain, Rubio declined to guess.
"Maybe there’s nothing there. Maybe it’s bigger than we thought. We don’t know," he said, calling speculation on limited information reckless. Trump went further on Wednesday: asked whether this was a biological weapon, he said, "We don’t think so."
But the underlying question remains legitimate. The State Department’s 2025 arms control compliance report says the U.S. assesses that Russia maintains an offensive biological warfare program in violation of the Biological Weapons Convention, and that the Soviet program was absorbed rather than dismantled.
CDC guidance records that the Soviet Union manufactured antibiotic-resistant Yersinia pestis in the 1970s and 1980s for dispersal from the air as a bioweapon.
Shipilova’s own research stands against the engineered-strain theory rather than toward it.
A paper she co-authored, published in April in the proceedings of a Moscow infectious-diseases congress, tested how well nine antibiotics still killed plague bacteria collected from the wild in Siberia.
Stated baldly, that sounds sinister in the current context. But testing wild bacteria against existing drugs is normal surveillance practice. It’s how public health learns whether its treatments are failing before patients find out the hard way.
The authors concluded that the Siberian strains remained highly susceptible. Measuring whether the drugs still work is not the same as making them stop.
Which Plague?
None of the history connects the Irkutsk institute to a weapons program, and the compliance report does not name it as one. Russia’s record makes transparency essential. And Russia’s record on transparency specifically is not happy reading.
But its opacity does not make the worst theories true. Not without harder evidence for us to draw firm conclusions either way.
The useful question in all this was never whether plague is frightening. It is: which plague? The answer may turn out to be none of them.
But if this was ordinary Y.pestis, modern public health holds an unusually strong weapon against it. The medieval memories disguise a far more manageable modern problem.
If it was something else, Russia should say what, and be specific.
The frightening possibility in Siberia is not dealing with pneumonic plague. It’s that, a week on, nobody outside Russia really knows what we are dealing with at all.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines