
...

By Brendan Cole
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A move to clamp down on ship operators that have helped Russia trade oil despite Western sanctions could lead to a confrontation at sea between the West and Russia and an environmental catastrophe, a geopolitical risk expert has warned
As part of the sanctions to hurt Russia's ability to finance the war it started in Ukraine, the G7, the European Union and Australia imposed a $60 price cap on a barrel of seaborne Russian crude oil from December 2022 and on oil products from February this year.
While the move caused a steep decline initially in oil tax receipts and meant Russia faced a budget deficit each month up to July, Moscow scrambled to find new, mostly Asian markets for its energy products, circumventing the sanctions with a "shadow fleet" of vessels. In response, the EU may soon task Denmark with inspecting tankers carrying exports from the eastern Baltic and passing through the Danish straits, the Financial Times reported, citing unnamed sources involved in discussions.
Read More
Russia’s Gas Production Collapses to Late-Stage USSR Levels4 min read

Russia May Copy China to Rescue Economy—But It’s Unlikely to Succeed3 min read

Russia and China on Collision Course as Beijing Rejects Putin’s Price Hike3 min read

The UN Convention on the Law of the Sea governing maritime traffic includes clauses that allow states to detain vessels if there is evidence that they pose a major threat of coastal damage.

...
Markus Korhonen, senior associate leading geopolitical risk, at the global intelligence consultancy, S-RM, told Newsweek that the Russian fleet consists of typically older vessels that would not qualify for internationally recognized insurance and represent "a significant environmental risk."
However, the prospect of Denmark inspecting and blocking these ships without Western insurance to tighten the sanctions regime against Russia and mitigate the danger of an oil spill, presents another problem.
"Given the importance of energy export earnings for Russia, in the event that Russian oil tankers are systematically prevented from navigating through the Baltic Sea, Russia will have to react," he said. "There is also notable concern that a ship will fail to stop when called to do so by the Danish navy."
"This has the potential to lead to either direct confrontation, or dangerous naval maneuvers by oil tankers in a narrow and shallow sea, the environmental implications of which could be dire," Korhonen added.
Russia's oil revenue recovery
Curbing Russia's energy exports has been a problem for the West seeking to punish Moscow for Vladimir Putin's full-scale invasion of Ukraine. In October, the U.S. Treasury Department notified ship management companies in 30 countries requesting information on around 100 vessels it suspects of busting sanctions, Reuters reported, citing an unnamed Treasury source.
Russia has had an "almost complete export volume recovery" in oil after initially being hit hard by the oil cap, Chris Weafer, chief executive officer of strategic consultants Macro-Advisory Ltd, told Newsweek. He said that in October, Russia shipped 3.5 million barrels per day of crude on tankers and an additional 1.2 million barrels per day via the East Siberia pipeline.
He said Russia has also benefited from a barrel of Brent crude rising from around $70 in July to $95 in late September, allowing it to reduce the discount it had previously offered at a time when it devalued its currency, the ruble, against the U.S. dollar.
"Realistically, the only way the price cap can work is if the buyers enforce it," Weafer said. But he notes that Russian law now bans such sales and "there is no evidence that the current buyers are even considering such a move.
"Why would they when they are able to buy oil cheaper than Western counterparts and gain an economic competitiveness advantage?"
He said that what the G7 and the EU had in mind with the oil cap was the old tanker market structure where most Russian oil was moved by a few very big tanker operators with large fleets that would have been easy to monitor and enforce.
"Instead, what has emerged is a greatly dispersed fleet ownership with the flexibility to disappear and reappear with a new name faster than the G7/EU can catch them," he said.
However, Weafer said that the price cap had driven up transport costs and even though the discount on sales is considerably less than it was through most of the first half of the year, "it is still a discount."
"It means that the Russian budget—and Russian oil producers are getting less money for the exports than they would otherwise without sanctions," he added.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines