
...

By Billal Rahman
Immigration Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis shared a viral social media post claiming that Arizona teachers were "glorifying a murder" with Halloween costumes allegedly referencing conservative activist Charlie Kirk’s death.
But school officials said the costumes were math-themed, predated the incident, and had no connection to any political figure, and shared a photo that they said supported that assertion.
Turning Point USA spokesperson Andrew Kolvet, whose X post DeSantis shared, later walked back his earlier assumption about the motive behind the costumes, citing the photo shared by the school official, and expressed relief that the situation may not be as sinister as first believed.
Read More on News
Newsweek emailed DeSantis' office for comment outside normal working hours, and asked Vail School District officials to provide original copies of the photographs.
Why It Matters
Charlie Kirk, the co-founder of conservative student group Turning Point USA, was shot and killed on September 10 during a public event in Utah. Authorities have described the shooting as a targeted attack, though investigations into a motive are ongoing. Kirk’s killing prompted widespread reaction, with his supporters portraying it across conservative media as emblematic of escalating hostility toward right-wing figures. That political context has fueled heightened sensitivity online, with claims or incidents—like the Arizona teachers’ Halloween photo—quickly spreading as supposed examples of ideological cruelty.

...
What To Know
The viral photo shared by Kolvet shows the teachers wearing white T-shirts splattered with fake blood and the words "Problem Solved" emblazoned across the chest.
"Concerned parents just sent us this image of what's believed to be teachers in @vailschools in Tucson, Arizona mocking Charlie's murder with costumes that read "Problem Solved" and blood down the left side of their shirts. They deserve to be famous, and fired," he wrote.
"It’s been really disturbing to see teachers across the country glorifying a murder just because they disagreed with the victim," DeSantis wrote in a post on X on November 1, quoting Kolvet's post.
The Florida governor was one of many MAGA figures, including Utah Senator Mike Lee and former swimmer Riley Gaines, to share the image and accuse the teachers of mocking Kirk's death, because the blood was on the same side as the influencer's neck wound.
A statement from Vail School District Superintendent John Carruth was shared with Newsweek confirming that the image originated from Cienega High School’s math department, and apologizing, acknowledging that the outfits had caused "confusion and concern."
"The shirts were worn in reference to solving math problems," his statement read. "Any references that these shirts were related to something other than that are simply false and untrue. The staff wearing them care deeply about children, most of them live in our community and have served families in Vail for many years."
Carruth said the shirts were also worn last year, but that they would not be worn again. They were "not intended as a reference to any person, event, or political issue," he added.
Christopher King, a member of the school district board and Republican candidate for Arizona's state Senate, posted a screenshot of an email chain dated October 31, 2024, showing the teachers in the same T-shirts. "Here are the same teachers last year wearing the same shirt," he wrote. "They are math teachers making a math joke for Halloween. They're not attacking anyone."
A spokesperson for the school district shared a screenshot of the same email chain and photo with Newsweek, and a screenshot of the shirts available for sale on Amazon.
A visual-forensics analysis by Newsweek suggests it’s highly plausible that the two screenshots were taken by different individuals using different devices: The differences in format (JPG vs PNG), resolution, cropping, and absence of shared metadata all point toward independent captures of the same content.
Newsweek has confirmed via a search of Amazon that T-shirts matching the design and look of those worn by the teachers, were first put on sale in summer 2024.

...
In a follow-up post on X DeSantis wrote, alongside a screenshot of the school district's statement shared on Facebook: "Here is the explanation from the school district re: the bloody shirts. Some have cast doubt on this explanation, but people can read it and decide for themselves."
Kolvet also issued a follow-up statement sharing King's photo and acknowledging that the costumes had been worn in previous years, but remained critical of the teachers' choice.
"We've seen enough evil since Charlie's murder that I'd actually be relieved if this isn't another example," he wrote on X. "That being said, it's a very weird costume for teachers in general, but after what happened to Charlie, I'm absolutely floored they wore it again."
Others suggested, without evidence, that the photo shared by King as proof the teachers wore the same T-shirts last year was AI-generated, edited, or actually from this year as well.
Carruth expressed concern that some individuals "were being targeted online as a result of this misunderstanding." A screenshot circulating on social media lists the names and numbers of the staff in the photo from this year shared by Kolvet.
What People Are Saying
Journalist Mehdi Hasan wrote in a post on X: "Insane that they’re doxing and inciting against a group of math teachers who used these T-shirts last year too. Same people who pretended to care about political violence after Kirk now just putting a target on these innocent teachers’ backs."
**Far right commentator Benny Johnson wrote in a post on X: "**All of these teachers need to be fired immediately. Sick and evil. They aren’t even hiding it anymore."
Republican Senator Mike Lee of Utah said in a post on X: "One of the most famous men in Arizona history was recently gunned down in cold blood—wearing a shirt that became soaked with blood in a way that was reminiscent of the ghastly shirts they wore. Their "we wore these last year too" defense—even if it’s true—doesn’t help them much."
Update, 11/03/2025, 1:18 p.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines