Photo by Lia Toby/Getty Images for BFI

...

George Chesterton

By George Chesterton

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Growing up in England in the 1980s, it was your patriotic duty not just to watch and enjoy James Bond movies, but to pore over them in obsessive detail.

It was expected of British boys to store an encyclopedic knowledge of the villains, the women, the cars, the gadgets, the facile one-liners. Bond was and is, after all, one of the few powerful representations of British manhood left in an era in which the nation as a whole was felt to be in a long, drawn-out retreat on the world stage.

With the news that Robert Pattinson is to be the seventh canonical 007, the now Amazon-owned franchise will begin its latest bout of myth-building nonsense. I use the word nonsense quite deliberately, because there came a point sometime in the early 1990s when the pennies fell from my eyes. Having watched Bond films over and over again, and witnessing the media excitement that Pierce Brosnan was replacing Timothy Dalton, I just stopped lying to myself. Bond films are almost all irredeemably terrible.

Read More on Opinion

Nothing that has happened since Brosnan, including the spurious claims that Daniel Craig went on to refresh the franchise and the espionage mythos, has changed my mind. Bond movies are crap. No other franchise would get away with making so many bad films in succession. The animated My Little Pony saga has more high-octane action and suspense than James Bond.

Where to start? The first two movies, Doctor No and From Russia With Love are passable period pieces, benefiting hugely from the fact they did not have 20 or so previous films to nod back to in a sticky mess of tedious self-referentiality. Goldfinger, supposedly the Bond by which all others are judged, is lamentably stupid. I must stress here (I’ll be doing a lot of stressing) that suspending my disbelief is not the problem. Fantastical plots, unfeasible action and general silliness are not hurdles to my enjoyment. But hang on a minute: the villain Goldfinger is going to gas everyone for miles around Fort Knox then detonate a dirty bomb inside to raise the price of the gold he’s been hoarding. There’s fantastical and there’s just plain stupid.

From the fourth film onward, each new iteration is a parodic palimpsest of its predecessors. Ever more pointless. Ever less interesting. Sean Connery, like all Bonds after their first two outings, operates on well-remunerated autopilot. The special effects look lamentable even for the various eras in which the films are made. In On Her Majesty’s Secret Service, which has become a connoisseur’s choice for Bond snobs, each fist fight and car chase is sped up to a ludicrous degree so that what are supposed to be key moments of action feel more like a Harold Lloyd caper.

I grew up with Roger Moore’s Bond and have seen his films more than those of any of the other lead actors, so I should retain some childlike affection for watching him in action weekend after weekend. But whatever nostalgia they engender, the films themselves lack tension, pace, menace and most of all they lack the one thing their reputations insists they do have—wit. Those one-liners and double entendres are about as funny as Connery’s Bond forcing himself on a woman.

By the time Moore quit Bond he was 57, his eyebrows exhausted from overuse, looking like he should be Joan Collins’s latest caddish boyfriend in Dynasty rather than dodging bullets from a fire truck.

On the set of Moonraker

...

Each new attempt to breathe new life into Bond, update it, make it relevant, make it less offensive to modern sensibilities is doomed to fail because the model is broken and has been since 1964. And to add another stress: I don’t object to Bond because of the misogyny or the casual racism (unpleasant as those things are), but because the movies are bad movies.

In many ways, I’ve always thought Moonraker is the purest and most truthful Bond of all, partly because it is so ludicrous it just gives up pretending it has any mooring in anything resembling reality, and partly because it was made to cash in on Star Wars hysteria, so in that sense at least you can excuse why it got made, if not how. Moonraker is the moment Bond finally collapses under the weight of its own internal contradictions and every film since—even the so called "good" ones such as Casino Royale—exist in the second-rate purgatory of their own redundancy.

You can’t "fix" Bond. Not even Pattinson and Amazon’s billions can save something that broke down 60 years ago. It’s not so much flogging a dead horse, but battering the ghost of a horse that decomposed, returned to the earth and became a fossil.

Critics have been arguing the Bondiverse has been out of date for decades, so the debate about the sexism and aggressive promiscuity, the lack of a clear Cold War enemy, Britain’s ever denuded importance, and our culture’s preference for emotionally vulnerable male leads is as worn out as the crotch on Daniel Craig’s swimming trunks. The bigger issue is the quality of the product itself and the prospect that any new iteration will maintain that tradition of turgid repetition.

Related Story

James Bond Is Back. So Is Spying

James Bond Is Back. So Is Spying

I urge you to rewatch any of Brosnan’s four outings (five minutes should be enough). They look like TV movies now. Craig’s films are more competently made, but boring and pretentious. Even that avowed attempt to resurrect the character and the franchise ended in just another layer of mummification.

There are a few caveats. Pattinson is a fine actor with the potential to be a dark, charismatic Bond (if that’s your kind of thing). Bond soundtracks have often been magnificent, thanks mainly to the genius of composer John Barry, but since his last score, the music has become yet another expression of the movies’ diminishing returns through parody and cosplay.

Even if you love Bond, given what Amazon did to Tolkien’s raw material in The Rings Of Power, the chances of the new Bond shaking the dust off this tired old concept seem very slim. There are fears Amazon will make Bond "woke," but it makes little difference any way they choose. Bond is supposed to be Britain’s superhero and, much like the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Bond represents the ultimate victory of intellectual property over ideas. Bond is entirely dependent on the former and entirely devoid of the latter. All Bond has is familiarity. And we all know what that breeds.

George Chesterton is Newsweek's Director, Publishing & Subscription Strategy.

The views expressed in this article are the writer’s own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines