10
Loading video...

By Dan Gooding
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani's plan to shutter Rikers Island depends on more than constructing four new jails—the city must somehow reduce the number of people it incarcerates by nearly 2,500 before the last replacement facility opens.
The city's new system, announced by the Democrat on Friday, will have room for 4,500 people, including 340 places in hospital-based therapeutic units. Around 6,000 people are currently incarcerated, meaning the Mamdani administration is counting on a nearly 38 percent reduction before Rikers closes in 2032.
The administration acknowledged that its calculation is not a forecast. In its newly released strategic plan, the city describes four scenarios through which the jail population could be reduced to around 4,100, leaving little room for the plan to succeed if the reductions don't materialize.
Read More on U.S.
"The plan announced today is an excellent step forward," Zachary Katznelson, executive director of the Independent Rikers Commission, told Newsweek on Friday. "There is no question that Rikers hurts public safety, so the mayor's commitment to close it—and replace it with a safer, more humane system—is a victory for all New Yorkers."

...
Plans to close Rikers have been in the works for several years, and they remain divisive—not just among unions representing prison guards or those fearing dangerous detainees will be let out onto the streets, but among advocates who feel the site should have been shuttered long ago.
New York Civil Liberties Union Executive Director Donna Lieberman said in a statement shared with Newsweek on Friday that Rikers was "an unconstitutional hellhole with a long history of human rights abuses," adding that the city was under a legal mandate to close it by 2027, not 2032.
"Every day it remains open, the lives and well-being of the New Yorkers forced to be there are at risk," Lieberman said. "It’s long past time for the City to come up with a concrete plan and timetable to reduce the jail population, build robust alternatives to incarceration, and finally close Rikers Island."
When reached for comment, Mamdani's office deferred to his press conference and the administration's plan.
How Mamdani Plans to Find 2,500 Beds
Diverting Those Deemed Low-Risk
One major aspect of the plan is to not jail certain people in the first place.
Of the roughly 20,000 people who pass through Rikers each year, the administration identifies around 400 people currently within the site who it assesses as lowest risk and another approximately 600 low-risk people charged with Class C felonies or lower as potential diversion candidates.
The report states that a majority of this population, if convicted, would face only a few weeks in jail or prison before returning to the communities anyway, but that time away can cause "significant disruptions to housing, employment, benefits, health care, and family connections."
This scenario assumes population reductions of 40 percent to 60 percent among relevant male groups, and 60 percent to 80 percent among equivalent groups of women through services and alternatives to detention, such as substance abuse treatment programs.
Release People Already Detained
The second pathway to cutting the city's overall jail population is to release those already detained who are also deemed low-risk with Class B felonies, as well as those who are higher risk but need further assessment or connections to other services.
This part of the plan, which would cut an estimated 700 people from the current population, includes $5 million each year toward programs that offer alternatives to incarceration (ATI), which the plan says reduces rearrests by around 50 percent within the first year and 61 percent in the second.
Plans also include working with state agencies to expand ATI program options, streamlining assessment and referral processes, as well as the expansion of electronic monitoring.
Related Story

Mamdani Announces Plan To Close Notorious Rikers Island Jail
Make Cases Move Faster
The plan says that approximately 1,470 people have been detained pretrial for more than a year, including 289 for two to three years, and 210 for more than three years. More than 840 people detained on murder charges have been waiting resolution for an average of 690 days, the report said.
Mamdani and his commission pushing forward with the closure want case-delay reforms to reduce the population by around 800, the largest of the four categories.
One major problem, though, is that City Hall cannot dictate how quickly all those cases move forward. The plan says leadership here rests "principally" with the Office of Court Administration and proposes working with judges, prosecutors and defense lawyers on discovery, competency proceedings, staffing and scheduling.
Stop People Coming Back
Nearly half of jail admissions involve people released from Rikers during the previous year, according to the plan.
City Hall identified roughly 1,600 people in jail on any given day as being the highest risk of repeated arrests and readmission.
It proposes housing, mental health and substance abuse interventions, and assumes reductions of roughly 30 percent for men and 50 percent for women in the relevant populations.
A separate analysis from the Vera Institute for Justice, using New York City Board of Corrections data, found that releasing inmates into work programs would aid in the effort.

...
Why Did Rikers' Population Rise Again?
The Mamdani administration makes one argument about Rikers' rising population, saying admissions are not the problem, but the length of stay is.
In 2025, the report said, 56 percent fewer people were sent to Rikers pretrial than in 2017, but the jail's population was only 22 percent smaller.
The average length of stay has increased from 63 days in 2017 to 102 days in 2025. The report estimates that if the 2025 length of stay had remained at the 2017 level, the average population would have been about 4,200 rather than 7,165.
"The jail population today is artificially inflated by three main issues: the unacceptable length of time it takes to resolve criminal cases—much longer than anywhere else in New York state and almost twice as long as other major cities across the U.S.," Katznelson said.
"That doesn't just keep people locked up in jail longer than necessary, it keeps crime victims waiting for answers and accountability, the number of people with serious mental illness. Rikers holds more people with serious mental illness than any psychiatric hospital in the country, and the revolving door of incarceration for many people.
"Tackling those will not only lower crime and improve individual outcomes, but will also safely lower the jail population. It was fantastic to see the unified front and commitment among the key stakeholders at the announcement today to get the job done."
Where Will Remaining Detainees Go?
Under the plan, Rikers' remaining population—the majority awaiting trial rather than serving a sentence—would be placed in four jails in the New York boroughs of Brooklyn, Manhattan, the Bronx and Queens.
The Brooklyn jail, already under construction, would open in 2029, while the Bronx and Queens sites have a targeted readiness date of 2031, with the Manhattan jail to open in 2032. The new sites would cover around 4,160 beds, with the remaining at outposted therapeutic sites with around 340 beds available, the report said.
According to the report, Rikers has been plagued with deteriorating facilities that would be replaced with sites that are better equipped to "remedy the wrongs" of the site, including providing clean, safe environments with access to mental and physical healthcare.
"We owe every person in custody dignity and humane conditions, and every correction officer and staff member a functional and safe place to work," Bronx District Attorney Darcel Clark, Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez, Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg and Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz said in a joint statement Friday.
"The plan to replace Rikers with borough-based jails will help achieve that, but we have a long way to go and many obstacles to overcome to do it correctly and preserve the tremendous progress in public safety our city is experiencing."
Mamdani Cannot Do It Alone
Even if Mamdani commits the funding and programs outlined in his plan, City Hall does not control all of the decisions needed to reduce New York City's jail population to 4,100.
The administration acknowledges as much, with its plan saying that the jail population is shaped by the combined effect of decisions across the criminal justice system and specifically identifies the Office of Court Administration, district attorneys, judges, public defenders, nonprofit organizations, correction officials and other city agencies as having roles in reducing it.
Katznelson said that the commission looked forward to being one of the groups working with City Hall on legislation that will "ensure steady progress toward closure, even while inevitably delaying it past 2027. That means that any extension must include clear, mandatory benchmarks to hold everyone accountable to New Yorkers, who deserve immediate and sustained improvements to safety and justice—and the permanent end to Rikers Island."
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Dave Siminoff.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines