
...

By Monica Sager
Live News Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Experts are blasting claims that Rex Heuermann's daughter is anyway involved in the Gilgo Beach murders, calling the idea "beyond preposterous."
Attorney John Ray held a dramatic press conference on Thursday, presenting what he called "sadistic" and "demonic" artwork created and viewed by Victoria Heuermann. Ray drew eerie parallels between her art and the gruesome murders her father is accused of, highlighting dismembered body parts and cannibalistic themes.
However, experts are pushing back against these sensational allegations that Victoria Heuermann's "demonic" artwork connects her in any way to her father's alleged murder spree.
Read More
Victoria Heuermann’s ‘Demonic’ Artwork: Breakdown of the Sadistic Images8 min read

Chilling Details Revealed About Rex Heuermann’s Daughter1 min read

‘Demonic’ Details Revealed About Rex Heuermann And Daughter: ‘Human Devils’19 min read

"In twenty years of involvement in the field of serial murder research, I have never seen anything like this press conference," Enzo Yaksic, who runs the Atypical Homicide Research Group, told Newsweek. "Nothing shown translates into the propensity to commit violence."

...
Rex Heuermann showed no emotion last week as he was charged with two more murders—Sandra Costilla and Jessica Taylor. The 60-year-old architect, first arrested in July 2023, was already accused of killing four women found in burlap sacks along Ocean Parkway over a decade ago.
Before these latest charges, Heuermann was already facing accusations for the "Gilgo Four" murders: Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, Amber Lynn Costello, and Maureen Brainard-Barnes.
"The fact that she had a painting of the bodies, does not mean she was involved with these killings," said forensic psychologist Eric Hickey told Newsweek. "It's highly unlikely."
The 'preposterous' claims
During the press conference, Ray said Rex Heuermann did not lead a double life, but instead family members, particularly Victoria, knew about the killings and could have assisted.
Dr. Gary Brucato, forensic psychologist, said about 20% of serial killers operate in groups.
Hairs on some of Rex Heuermann's victims could have been from Victoria rather than transferred by her father, Ray said. This goes against what District Attorney Raymond Tierney announced last week.
"I don't think I've ever had a case in modern time where a father-daughter team teamed up to sexually assault and murder young women," Hickey told Newsweek. "That just doesn't happen."
Brucato called Victoria's behavior a form of "normalization" because she was around murders. He thinks she thought nothing of the fascination.
He also suggested Victoria could have suffered from Stockholm Syndrome. The disease is a reaction to developing a psychological bond to a captor or an abuser.
Instead, Hickey told Newsweek that it's "highly unlikely" that the Heuermann family knew about Rex's alleged actions.
"The father could have had a strong influence on his daughter in terms of the dark side, in terms of thinking darkly, without her ever knowing he's actually a killer," Hickey said. "He could be sharing some of his fantasy with her and his interest in the dark side and suffering of people and giving her some ideas."
Victoria Heuermann would not know that the events are actually happening, but instead her father would be "expressing himself through her and enjoying that kind of control," Hickey said.
"I think in the end, we'll find that he was simply manipulating his daughter," Hickey said.
The images
One of the pictures depicts a person impaled by antlers. Yaksic said it is "directly from the NBC show "Hannibal."
Ray had said this was a similar position as how Shannan Gilbert was found dead.

...
Ray has represented Gilbert's family, after the 24-year-old disappeared in Oak Beach in 2010. The search for Gilbert led to the hunt for a possible serial killer when 11 sets of human remains were discovered along a property on Gilgo Beach in Suffolk County.
The search first turned up the remains of Barthelemy, Waterman, Costello and Brainard-Barnes. Suffolk County detectives said for a while that Gilbert was not one of Rex Heuermann's victims claiming her death was not a murder and was "most likely an accident."
Shannan Gilbert's sister Sherre has intensely disagreed for years, pointing to 911 calls.
At Thursday's press conference the attorney said he is still working on Gilbert's case as well as those of other alleged victims that escaped Rex Heuermann.
Gilbert's sister on social media Thursday that she does not agree with "anything John Ray is doing." She called the press conference "disrespectful" and that Ray should have focused on just her sister's case.
"He cuts his nose to spite his face!" the post reads. "I do not support nor condone his actions whatsoever!"

...
Yaksic went on to say that if Ray's team's logic is correct, then the millions of true crime fans are also "capable of committing homicide."
"Oddly enough, the entire plot line of the show is that the daughter of a serial murderer aided him in killing," Yaksic said. "In my opinion, this team is suffering from something called 'true crime brain rot' where the proliferation of true crime culture influences and transfigures thoughts on real-life cases."
One image appears to be of remains that are "half eaten," which Ray said relates to the cannibalism Victoria was interested in. There are others with a "cult-like cannibalistic ritual."
"It is beyond preposterous to claim that a family is involved in witchcraft and cannibalism as part of a larger network of people," Yaksic said.

...
Even more so, Yaksic said the exposure to this type of imagery can be a protective mechanism.
"(It is) similar to those who play violent video games to safely exercise their destructive thoughts and emotions," Yaksic said. "Pornography also has the same protective effect and research demonstrates that potential offenders who consume it are often placated by it alone which has led, in part, to the decline in serial." murder.
Heuermann's family
Vess Mitev, the attorney for Veronica and her half-brother Christopher Sheridan, said he does not "comment on frivolous sideshows by people with no clients related to this case."
"They're two young adults that are caught in the cross hairs of this deeply unfortunate case that they have nothing to do with other than they are related to Mr. Heuermann" Mitev told Newsweek. "Very, very dark time in their lives."
Ellerup married Heuermann in 1996. Victoria was born a year later.

...
Ellerup filed for divorce shortly after his arrest, but she continues to insist that her husband is not capable of murder.
"You don't marry someone and know that he's a serial killer and don't do anything about it," Hickey said, suggesting that Ellerup truly did not know about Rex's alleged actions.
The children and their mother, Asa Ellerup, continue to live the Massapequa Park home they once shared with the alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer. Since their father's arrest, the home in a suburban Long Island neighborhood has been the subject searches from investigators.
It is still under discussion as to whether they will be present at Heuermann's next court appearance.
Do you have a story Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines