...
By Alice Gibbs
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A retired couple in Western France has been ordered by a court to demolish part of their home after a decades‑old land registry error left a section of the property legally belonging to a neighboring plot, according to French media reports.
Didier and Maryline Gautier, who have lived in their house in Trélazé, a commune in Maine-et-Loire, since the early 1980s, were told by the Tribunal Judiciaire d’Angers in December 2025 that they must remove a central section of their home measuring around 10 square meters [107 square feet]. The ruling requires the demolition to be completed within six months.
Why It Matters
The case has drawn national attention in France after being reported by regional outlet Ouest‑France and later featured on TF1, highlighting how long‑standing administrative errors can have serious consequences for homeowners decades later.
Read More on Life
The disputed section contains the couple’s kitchen and toilet, meaning its removal would effectively split the house in two, a ruling described as "absurd" by commentators on French television.
What To Know
The Gautiers bought their home in 1981 and gradually renovated it over the years. In the early 1990s, they purchased neighboring structures, including a former rabbit hutch and a narrow path separating the buildings. In 1994, they built an extension on the site of that path, after receiving a building permit from the local municipality.
The issue emerged years later, after the death of the neighboring property owner in 2015. The land was sold, and the new owner discovered that the section of land where the extension was built did not appear on the official land registry. French media reported that the omission dated back to a surveying error, meaning the land legally remained part of the neighboring parcel.
...
The neighbor initiated legal proceedings in 2018, but it was not until December 2025 that the Angers court ruled in favor of the neighbor, ordering the demolition of the disputed section and requiring the couple to pay approximately €17,000 [$19,500] in legal costs and damages.
A spokesperson for the town of Trélazé told Newsweek that the 1994 building permit was issued "subject to third‑party rights," noting that disputes between neighbors fall under private law. They also emphasized that France’s land registry does not establish legal property boundaries, which can be determined only through a formal survey conducted by a certified surveyor.
This is not the first time a homeowner has been forced to alter their home because of a demolition order. Last year, a California couple built a home that authorities said violated land and environmental rules and faced a demolition order. While a Washington State couple was ordered to demolish their home due to flood‑risk and county orders just five weeks after moving in.
What Happens Next
Under the court order, the couple have six months to carry out the demolition. French media reported that failure to comply could result in daily fines.
Newsweek contacted the Tribunal Judiciaire d’Angers, the town of Trélazé, and state land authorities in Maine‑et‑Loire via email for comment.
Update, 03/13/26 04:32 a.m. ET: This story was updated with comment from the town of Trélazé.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines