10
Loading video...
By AmiLynne Carroll
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Resilience is not a life purpose. It is a survival skill, and we have mistaken the two.
We praise the employee who works through burnout, the patient who faces illness with a smile, the entrepreneur who rebuilds after failure, and the person who keeps going despite circumstances that would exhaust anyone.
We call them strong. We call them inspiring. We tell them how resilient they are. Then we move on, satisfied that we have said something kind, without asking a more important question: Who gets to decide what their life looks like after survival?
Read More on Leadership Insights
The World Health Organization estimates that depression and anxiety account for 12 billion lost working days globally each year. It identifies excessive workloads, limited support, and job insecurity as risks to mental health.
I believe we need to stop treating resilience as the ultimate measure of how well someone handles adversity. The expectation to bounce back can become another burden imposed on people already carrying enough.
Worse, it can turn an experience they survived into an identity they feel obliged to maintain.
...
I know how easily others can define you by what has happened to you. My own experiences, including quadriplegia and a stroke in 2022, could give people ample reason to place me in the familiar category of the survivor.
I understand why. People want to recognize courage, honor hardship and find hope in another person’s story. Yet I refuse to make survival the headline of my identity.
The things that happen in our lives form our stories. They do not determine the entirety of who we are.
The danger begins when praise becomes a prescription.
Borrowed Beliefs
I call one part of this problem "borrowed beliefs." These are ideas about ourselves that we accept from people whose opinions carry weight in our lives.
A parent tells a child they are destined to become an engineer. A teacher identifies someone as the gifted one. A family member measures success by how well someone conforms to expectations.
Often, these beliefs come from people who genuinely love us. Their intentions may be generous, but the conclusions can still be limiting.
Resilience can become another borrowed belief. Someone is praised for being strong and independent, then begins to feel that asking for help would betray the person everyone believes them to be.
They learn to endure quietly because endurance has become their reputation. The people around them see strength; the person living inside that identity may feel increasingly unable to admit what they need.
This is where our cultural celebration of resilience deserves scrutiny. We applaud people for overcoming adversity, but how often do we help them discover what they actually want afterward?
The Dangers of Labels
A person can survive an illness, lose a business, leave a marriage, or recover from burnout and still have no idea what comes next. Survival answers the question of how we got through something. It does not answer who we want to become.
The consequences reach far beyond extraordinary hardship. A professional who has spent decades being dependable may struggle to admit they want a different career.
A caregiver may become so identified with looking after others that their own ambitions disappear from view. Someone who has endured a painful relationship may carry its lessons into every relationship that follows.
The experience changes them, but the label can keep them living inside it.
Imagine a world in which people receive the support to pause, understand their circumstances, and make deliberate choices about their futures. Resilience would still have its place, alongside collaboration, compassion, and the freedom to ask for help.
Now imagine the alternative: workplaces that reward exhaustion as commitment, communities that celebrate silent suffering, and individuals who become so skilled at enduring life that they forget they can shape it.
We have a choice about which future our language helps create.
Courage and Willingness
The LifeCharter Yellow Light Method offers one approach to consider. A yellow traffic light calls for three things: pause, assess, and decide.
The same principle applies when life disrupts our plans. Pause long enough to acknowledge what has happened. Assess what it means, what you need, and which beliefs deserve another look. Then decide on your next step, guided by who you want to be.
This process demands something more difficult than a motivational speech. It requires honest self-examination, the courage to question familiar expectations, and the willingness to act on what we discover.
It also requires other people to make room for that process, without insisting that someone remain strong for their comfort.
Leaders, employers, educators, and healthcare professionals have a responsibility to change the conversation. Stop measuring recovery by how quickly someone returns to their former role. Stop assuming that a capable person needs no assistance.
Build support systems that help people identify their needs, reclaim their agency, and determine their own next steps. Ask people what they want now, and give their answers the same respect you gave their struggle.
The Now of Being
We can acknowledge what someone has endured without making endurance their defining quality. We can celebrate courage while recognizing that asking for help takes courage, too.
And we can make room for people to change, even when that change unsettles the expectations others have built around them.
I often return to a simple idea: Truth. Freshly discovered in the now of being.
You do not have to be the strongest person in the room, the most inspiring survivor, or the one who always finds a way through. You are allowed to be unfinished, uncertain, and uniquely yourself.
The question is what you intend to do with the life you have now.
I get to be who I am. And so do you.
AmiLynne (Babs) Carroll is a speaker and certified life coach who offers paid LifeCharter coaching and programs related to the framework discussed here. All opinions are the author’s own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines