Getty

...

Rachael O'Connor

By Rachael O'Connor

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A relationship expert has weighed in as a Reddit user asked for advice on their loud voice making their partner uncomfortable—and them feeling self-conscious as a result.

Reddit user u/Farts2Long took to the r/AmITheA****** sub on May 25, asking if they were in the wrong for telling their partner to stop asking them to "lower your volume" when speaking.

They explained that when they get "excited about a topic, I naturally start speaking louder than usual"—not shouting, but louder than a normal conversation, and they "don't realize I'm doing it."

Read More on Relationships

But their partner will "often interrupt" asking them to lower their volume—not in a mean or rude way, which the user thinks is "fair," but which still leaves them feeling "demoralized, and a little self-conscious."

Angelika Koch, relationship and breakup expert at LGBTQ+ dating app Taimi, told Newsweek the most important things at play were "timing and tone," as "telling someone mid-sentence that they're being loud, even if it's well-intentioned, can feel a bit humiliating."

Pointing out that "most people don't even notice when their voice rises, it usually happens because of passion or deep engagement," she suggested the couple find a hand motion or light touch that works to let the other know their voice is getting loud.

"Over time, they might even start to catch themselves. But this can only happen if they don't feel like their personality is being attacked," she said.

aita for asking my partner stop telling me to
r/AmItheAsshole

View this post on Reddit

The Reddit user wrote on the post, which has been awarded more than 12,000 upvotes: "I lose my enthusiasm and no longer feel like talking about the thing I was excited about. Even if they don't mean it harshly, it still feels dismissive and discouraging. I've tried to explain how it makes me feel, but they still keep interrupting me."

The user asked Reddit if they were in the wrong "for wanting them to stop interrupting me like that," or if they needed to "accept that I should keep my volume in check," even if they don't realize they're doing it.

And Redditors responded in a big way, many writing that, in their opinion, no one was particularly at fault, but the original poster should work on their volume control.

As one put it: "I'm autistic and so at varying times I both get excited/loud, and then sometimes can find loud voices really overwhelming in a conversation, making it hard to concentrate on what the person is saying to me"

One wrote: "I get it, you're happy to be speaking to someone who cares about something you care about. However, speaking as someone whose partner is the same as you in this situation, it's very hard to be sat trying to engage with someone when they are essentially shouting in your face."

Another said it's "okay to get excited and passionate about something, but you do need to be aware of your volume, especially if he's told you multiple times it's an issue."

And another shared: "You have every right to feel how you feel but it also does sound like you may be disregarding how it makes them feel. Some people shut down when they encounter yelling or are triggered."

Getty

...

Koch told Newsweek the best way to approach this situation with a loved one is through "validation"—making clear the volume "is tied to something good: their passion and energy. Let them know that you value those things and don't want to dampen them. That kind of honesty would invite cooperation, instead of defensiveness and criticism."

The Reddit user, who chose not to give their name, told Newsweek they were "grateful for the thoughtful responses people gave" to their post.

"It's been helpful to see how others view the situation, and I appreciate that most seemed to agree I'm not an a******, while still pointing out that there are things I can work on, which I fully accept," they said.

Have you noticed any red flags that made you end a relationship? Let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured on Newsweek.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines