...
By Matthew Impelli
Life & Trends Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A man has won overwhelming support online after standing up to his girlfriend's brothers in a wrestling match after they repeatedly mocked him for not being "big and strong" enough to date her.
The 29-year-old original poster (OP) described on Reddit this week a family gathering where her three brothers—who view physical dominance as a key measure of manhood—challenged him to a wrestling match after making dismissive remarks about his masculinity.
According to the OP, his 28-year-old girlfriend's brothers had been making condescending remarks since they first met him. They insisted that she should be with a, "Big, strong guy", and ridiculed him for his French heritage, implying that French men were cowards.
Read More
Stranger Puts Sharpie and Post-Its in Women’s Locker Room—Awe at Result3 min read
Man’s Valentine’s Day Proposal Seemed Perfect—Until He Checked the Pictures3 min read
Bride Can’t Hide Reaction As Wedding Vows Interrupted by ‘Screaming’ Child4 min read
'Mood turned sour'
What they didn't know was that the OP had years of experience in judo and Brazilian jiu-jitsu. Instead of backing down, he accepted their challenge in front of 20-30 party people and pinned each one of the bros with ease.
"It was a stunning silence in the party and the mood turned sour so I took my leave," Effective_Turnover66 told fellow Redditors.
...
The next day, his girlfriend accused him of humiliating her brothers, claiming they had only been "playful" and that he should have been the mature one.
The argument escalated when she dismissed his concerns about their behavior, calling him, "Too sensitive."
Breaking Point
She confronted him outside his apartment, saying the incident had been embarrassing for her. She insisted he should have ignored her brothers' taunts because, "They were a little drunk, so you being sober should have been the mature one."
When he asked whether she would have stepped in if they took things too far, she insisted she would have—despite having done nothing when they repeatedly mocked him.
Frustrated by her response, he told her, "I don't think I'm interested in continuing the relationship."
She accused him of "gaslighting" and apparently threw out buzzwords from TikTok, but he remained firm.
Her brothers later messaged him: "Come on dude, we are over that. You proved yourself. Cut her some slack."
Instead of engaging, he blocked them.
Reddit overwhelmingly backed Effective_Turnover66, amid more than 600 comments, with users urging him to leave the relationship for good.
"You break up, that's what," a supporter advised the OP, adding, "Do you really want to deal with this for the rest of your life?"
Another person was more direct: "Agreed. Just get a new [girlfriend], brother, this one is just as misogynistic as her douchecanoe brothers. Don't start nothin', won't be nothin'."
Many critics pointed out that his girlfriend refusing to acknowledge her brothers' behavior was a major red flag.
"Run, leave and don't look back," a user declared.
"If your girlfriend can't even acknowledge or respect the fact that they kept saying s*** and comparing you to her exes, what else will she allow?"
Relationship Conflicts and Family Influence
Disputes involving a partner's family are a common theme in online discussions, particularly when a person feels unsupported.
Newsweek previously reported a viral Reddit post which described a similar situation where a man considered breaking up with his girlfriend after realizing she repeatedly dismissed his concerns about her family's behavior.
The discussion drew attention to patterns where one partner downplays issues rather than addressing them.
Another Newsweek article highlighted how financial disputes can create tensions in relationships. In that case, a man labeled his girlfriend a "gold digger" after she expected monetary support despite earning less than him.
Like the OP's scenario, the argument stemmed from one partner feeling taken for granted while the other refused to acknowledge a problem.
'On a break'
In a message to Newsweek via Reddit, the OP shared a gloomy update on the situation, saying, "We are on a break, with me wanting to break up with her permanently.
"Also, she has been asking her friends to contact me to tell that she is sorry [and to urge me to] at least talk to her.
"Also thinking back, I'm not sure why she was with me."
Newsweek's "What Should I Do?" offers expert advice to readers. If you have a personal dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money and work, and your story could be featured on WSID at Newsweek.
To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines