0.cached.png

0.cached.png

Ellis Cose

By Ellis Cose

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


NEXT MONTH'S CENTENNIAL OF PLESSY V. FERGUSON WILL be an occasion to celebrate how much things have changed since the days when Supreme Court decisions reeked with racism. "If one race be inferior to the other socially, the Constitution of the United States cannot put them on the same plane," declared Justice Henry B. Brown, writing for the 8-1 majority that agreed Homer Adolph Plessy had no business sitting in the white section of a Louisiana train. The decision provided legal cover not only for segregated train cars but for the next 58 years of Jim Crow in all its vile, phony "separate but equal" incarnations. The anniversary will also remind us, however, that the questions at the heart of the case (What is "equal" treatment? And what is the government's role in ensuring it?) remain largely unresolved.

John Marshall Harlan, the sole Plessy dissenter, insisted that the Constitution must be "color-blind, and neither knows nor tolerates classes among its citizens." The irony is that though Harlan was standing up for the rights of blacks, his notion of colorblindness has, in recent years, been adopted by those who believe whites deserve a fairer shake. Attacking an affirmative-action program at the University of Texas last month, Fifth Circuit Court Judge Jerry E. Smith ruled that the school "has presented no compelling justification . . . that allows it to continue to elevate some races over others."

An even sadder irony is that in at least one instance Justice Brown's infamous words have proven right. Government, he argued, could not eliminate prejudice: "If the two races are to meet on terms of social equality, it must be the result of . . . a mutual appreciation of each other's merits." In the 100 years since, many blacks and many whites have still not acquired that "mutual appreciation." Consequently, though the doctrine of state-sanctioned separatism was set aside more than half a century ago, the promise of desegregation has yet to materialize. In the mid-'50s, after the Supreme Court declared segregated schools unconstitutional, a young, ebullient Thurgood Marshall predicted that America would be totally integrated by 1963--the 100th anniversary of the Emancipation Proclamation. But confronted with the order to integrate "with all deliberate speed," many white politicians resisted, resulting in a bloody struggle. Integration (which ideally means coming together in interracial harmony) was undermined before it began.

Read More on News

That's clear from the results. In a new review of desegregation research, Janet Schofield, an expert on education and race, concludes that though desegregation got more blacks into more schools (including colleges), it has not substantially improved African-American academic achievement. It does seem to have slightly boosted the reading scores of some black youngsters, but desegregation has had no apparent impact on math skills. The research, says Schofield, may not reflect what integration could bring about, since America never created a truly supportive environment for it. In practice, desegregation often means that even in the same building, black and white kids go to different schools--the whites are on a fast track, the blacks on a slow one.

That is exactly the opposite of what the Warren Court had envisioned when Marshall, then the NAACP's chief counsel, persuaded it to reject Plessy in 1954. The Brown v. Board of Education decision assumed that state-sanctioned segregation was responsible for a sense of inferiority among black children that diminished their motivation to learn. Desegregation was supposed to be the antidote, yet black and Latino parents too often discover that their children, even in desegregated settings, are exposed to the same old stereotypes. Last week a nonprofit group called ACORN released a report blasting New York City public schools for shortchanging minority youngsters. ACORN sent black, white and Latino "testers" to various schools and discovered, time after time, that white and minority parents were treated differently. Whites were offered (often without prompting) information on programs for the gifted. Blacks and Latinos sometimes found even getting into the buildings to be difficult; when they did get in, they were generally told only about "regular" classes.

Desegregation does not have to work that way. Philip Uri Treisman became something of a legend a decade ago when he was stunningly successful at transforming his black students at the University of California, Berkeley, into math whizzes. Though the blacks had started out doing less well, on average, than whites and Asians, the African-Americans soon overtook them. Now at the University of Texas, Austin, Treisman is replicating that success with his "emerging scholars" program. When he arrived in 1989, the school had half a dozen minority math majors. Under Treisman, it's up to 150. How does he do it? With hard work, with interracial study groups and by challenging his charges to excel. Treisman thinks a racial mix of students is key. When blacks and Latinos see whites and Asians "visibly struggling with the same problems," he says, they realize race doesn't have anything to do with intellectual accomplishment.

Treisman is right that education--and integration--should shatter stereotypical assumptions instead of accommodating them. And he's right to worry that the anti-preference trend may kill programs like his, which, though open to all races, target blacks and Hispanics. It would certainly be the supreme irony if the argument for racial justice--colorblindness--ultimately becomes the rationale for maintaining an inequitable status quo.

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines