A stock image shows a healthcare provider vaccinating a patient.

...

Maria Azzurra Volpe

By Maria Azzurra Volpe

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


As flu season hits the country with over 81,000 hospitalizations and 3,100 deaths reported so far, a large number of Americans are still hesitant to get vaccinated against it, but why?

As of December 2025, only 34 percent of adults across the country had gotten a flu shot. Among those who decided against vaccination, 16 percent worried about its safety, and 13 percent rejected it because they “never get sick."

New research from Cornell University suggests that people’s decisions about whether or not to get the flu shot are not always based on raw facts, but rather on intuition and how that “gist” aligns with their core values.

Read More on Health

Psychology professor Valerie Reyna says that many experts have misunderstood how people make these health decisions.

While traditional decision-making emphasizes weighing risks and benefits in a rational way, Reyna’s research reveals that people often make this decision based on how they feel about it, which means that they don’t just consider numbers, but how they perceive them.

A stock image shows a healthcare provider vaccinating a patient.

...

For years public health campaigns have focused on providing people with specific, quantitative data about the flu vaccine, its effectiveness, side effects and the risks of contracting the flu.

However, the new research suggests that this approach does not always work, because it overlooks the way people actually process information on a deeper emotional level.

Reyna and her team tested this theory through studies involving over 700 college students and nearly 200 community members. Participants were asked about their flu vaccination habits, knowledge about it and their perceptions of its risks and benefits.

Among the younger adults, vaccine knowledge and accessibility explained only 14 percent of the variation in intentions to get flu vaccines. That total jumped to 58 percent when considering responses to the gist questions. In the community sample, similarly, gist questions improved the ability to predict vaccination intentions from 57 percent to 80 percent.

“We make decisions based on the bottom-line gist of information: What does all this information boil down to? What’s the decision really about?” said Valerie Reyna, the Lois and Melvin Tukman Professor of Human Development in the Department of Psychology and College of Human Ecology.

“If we know the essence of how someone feels about these ideas, we can explain and predict their intentions with respect to vaccination.”

These findings suggest that people’s decision-making process is driven less by rational analysis and more by intuition.

Categorizations of risks and benefits simply as none, low, medium or high significantly predicted whether people intended to get a vaccine or not. Study participants who perceived benefits as none or low, or risks as medium or high, tended to not vaccinate.

“Part of our mind looks at details and precise facts, but the other part of our mind looks at the bottom-line, qualitative gist—and that’s the more determinative part,” Reyna said.

“People form a global impression of what they are told and experience, for example, ‘Overall, I think the benefits from vaccination are high and the risks are nil.’ That would be a gist for people who get vaccinated, and that’s what we showed.”

The research emphasizes the importance of reaching people through sustained communication that incorporates gist principles, in contrast to prevailing approaches that rely on lists of facts and trust in experts, to reduce vaccine hesitancy.

Reyna suggests that practitioners should put facts into context to enable a conceptual, gist understanding and explain how vaccine risks and benefits map onto core values—a desire to keep family and neighbors safe, for example, or to make free and informed choices.

“If you follow that recipe, you will be much more likely to make a difference with people, according to our research,” she said. “You have to take the right approach, and it’s fundamentally different from what we’re currently doing.”

Do you have a tip on a science story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have a question about flu shots? Let us know via science@newsweek.com.

Reference

Reyna, V. F., Edelson, S. M., Garavito, D. M. N., Galindez, M. M., Singh, A., Fan, J., & Suh, J. (2025). A New Look at Vaccination Behaviors and Intentions: The Case of Influenza. Behavioral Sciences, 15(12). https://doi.org/10.3390/bs15121645

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines