Prince Harry and Meghan With High Court

...

Jack Royston

By Jack Royston

Chief Royal Correspondent

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Prince Harry and Meghan Markle began a campaign of legal warfare predominantly against the British press in 2019 and since then have filed 10 lawsuits with just three still live.

The Duke and Duchess of Sussex started strong, winning five of the cases and leaving a picture agency, Splash, bankrupt.

However, more recently Harry's cases have not all been going his way, having lost three and seen the most high profile claims in another scrapped, all while racking up costs estimated in the millions.

Read More on News

And he still has several crunch cases yet to be decided.

Prince Harry and Meghan With High Court

...

Harry and Meghan's Court Victories

The couple have been most successful when suing the paparazzi both in Britain and America.

Meghan and Harry sued over long lens images of the duchess carrying their baby son Prince Archie in a public park in Canada in January 2020.

The case against Splash News forced the agency into Chapter 11 Bankruptcy in America and into administration in Britain.

And when paparazzi agency X17 used a drone to photograph Archie playing with his grandmother Doria Ragland in the private grounds of Tyler Perry's Los Angeles mansion, they won the case at Los Angeles Superior Court in convincing fashion, extracting an apology in the process.

Harry also won an out-of-court settlement from The Mail on Sunday over an article wrongly stating he had turned his back on the Royal Marines since quitting the palace.

However, their two other wins were slightly more complicated, particularly Meghan's against The Mail on Sunday, which imposed such a significant emotional toll that Harry said he believes the case caused her to lose a baby.

She accused the newspaper of breaching her privacy by publishing a private letter she sent her father begging him to stop talking to the media.

However, she ended up having to fight in court to stop more private information being put into the public domain, sometimes more successfully than others.

One trove of private messages that did get released through the case showed she had instructed an aide to give information to the authors of Finding Freedom, a bombshell royal biography by Omid Scobie and Carolyn Durand, which she had previously denied cooperating with.

She triumphed in the end though, and released a statement denouncing the newspaper as a "daily fail."

More recently, Harry became the first royal family member to take to the witness box as a claimant when he testified at his phone hacking lawsuit against Mirror Group Newspapers.

He won and was award £140,000 ($178,000) in damages but the judge also registered a degree of dismay at some of his claims, a warning Harry may wish to heed in relation to his other cases.

"There was a tendency for the Duke in his evidence to assume that everything published was the product of voicemail interception because phone hacking was rife within Mirror Group at the time," Judge Timothy Fancourt ruled. "But phone hacking was not the only journalistic tool at the time, and his claims in relation to the other 18 articles did not stand up to careful analysis."

Harry's Defeats

Prince Harry sued the British government twice over the Home Office decision to strip him of his police bodyguards and lost both times.

He has been ordered to pay 90 percent of the Home Offices costs, thought to be around £500,000, based on a Freedom of Information Act disclosure, on top of his own.

Redemption is still possible, however, as he has gone to the Court of Appeal and were he to win that case he would no longer be required to settle the tab.

Harry's lawyers argued RAVEC, the Home Office committee that decides who receives police protection, did not consult him sufficiently before taking away his protection team.

After quitting the palace in January 2020, Harry ceased to be a working royal and with that loss of role he lost his right to a police team.

However, he argues he should have been eligible to retain the coveted armed officers because of the risk posed to him, wife Meghan and children Prince Archie and Princess Lilibet from far-right racists and terrorists who want revenge for his military service in Afghanistan.

Harry scrapped a libel lawsuit he brought against The Mail on Sunday over its coverage of the case and was warned the newspaper wants him to pay its costs, which it estimated at around £750,000.

And he has also seen the most high profile material from one of his unresolved cases quashed.

The prince was hoping to prove that Rupert Murdoch-owned tabloid The Sun hacked phones, accusing executives of trying to "cover up the truth by making false denials (i.e. lying), concealing documents, creating fake email chains, and destroying evidence."

However, the phone hacking aspect of the case was thrown out meaning he will have to fight on only in relation to less dramatic allegations of "other unlawful information gathering."

This includes, for example, his account of journalists obtaining his ex-girlfriend's flight records so they could photograph her at airports.

It is still possible he could win on those claims, however, which means he would still be able to chalk the overall case up in the "W" column, and force the newspaper to pay at least some of his costs as well as damages.

The other major case he has going is against the Daily Mail and its sister titles, and it alleges phone hacking, wire tapping and other unlawful practices.

The newspaper group's lawyers have issued strongly worded denials and the two sides appear destined to clash over the conflicting testimony of a private investigator.

That was the last case Harry filed back in October 2022 and he has not begun new proceedings against any news outlets since.

If he can win those two cases—and perhaps even his appeal against the Home Office—he may view his era of lawsuits as a success.

But if those cases fail he will not only incur major costs, likely stretching into the millions, but will also come away looking like a defeated former heavyweight champion who has lost his belt.

Jack Royston is chief royal correspondent for Newsweek*, based in London. You can find him on X (formerly Twitter) at @jack_royston and read his stories on* Newsweek*'s* The Royals Facebook page.

Do you have a question about Charles and Queen Camilla, William and Kate, Meghan and Harry, or their family that you would like our experienced royal correspondents to answer? Email royals@newsweek.com. We'd love to hear from you.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines