...
By Soo Kim
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A Reddit post recounting a first-class passenger's firm refusal to switch seats with another traveler has been praised, reigniting debate around airplane seat etiquette.
Posted by u/Stealthytom in the r/delta subreddit, the post titled "Totally just saw the perfect response to seat swapper" has garnered 3,700 upvotes and hundreds of comments since it was shared on July 15.
The post describes an interaction aboard a Delta flight in which a passenger declined a request to switch seats, choosing instead to enforce their paid seating arrangement with calm resolve.
Read More on Travel
"Seated in first class for Delta and as soon as this other person boarded, she indicated that her friend is seated two rows back," the poster wrote. "The person she initially approached seemed uninterested in engaging. She then approached someone else who also declined."
...
The poster continued: "She finally goes back to the original person and asked: 'So you won't switch?' The person replied: 'I'm sorry but I paid more to sit here. Suggest you ask someone who's seated in the back.' Then she goes right on about her business, totally unbothered."
The Reddit user wrote: "RESPECT. After about 20 minutes of boarding, she does indeed go back to sit with her friend, allowing someone else to take her first row seat."
Genevieve "Jenny" Dreizen, an etiquette expert, told Newsweek the response was "an excellent example of how to hold a boundary with kindness, clarity, and confidence, especially in a setting like air travel, where emotions can run high and personal space is at a premium."
Dreizen noted that the individual's words—"I'm sorry but I paid more to sit here. Suggest you ask someone who's seated in the back"—managed to assert their decision without causing a confrontation. "The passenger's response was firm but polite," Dreizen said.
Issues around swapping airplane seats are not new, but they continue to divide opinion. A June 2023 survey conducted for travel booking site Kayak, which polled 1,000 travelers in the United States and Canada, revealed nuanced views on the practice.
According to survey, "you are allowed to ask to switch seats if you ask politely," because 54 percent of travelers "have a soft spot for common courtesy."
However, the survey also identified clear limits on what fliers consider acceptable reasons to switch.
"You are not allowed to ask to switch seats just because you don't like your seat," the survey found, with 77 percent of respondents agreeing that "you get what you get and you don't get upset."
Additionally, those surveyed said passengers should not ask to change seats just because they are nervous fliers, with 64 percent saying that "everyone's a little nervous, not just you."
The Delta passenger's decision to stand firm echoed the survey's majority sentiment that passengers should respect the seating assignments determined at the time of booking—particularly when upgrades or additional fees are involved.
Dreizen emphasized the value of asserting boundaries with grace. "This was a great example of not over-explaining or justifying. The passenger stayed composed and confident. That's what made it so effective," she told Newsweek.
The situation has struck a chord with many on Reddit who faced similar dilemmas, especially when it involves premium seating. Several shared their own anecdotes of being asked to move from aisle seats or exit rows and expressed frustration when asked to give up seats they selected or paid extra for.
U/NeatAdhesiveness8907 said the passenger in the post had the "perfect response," adding that "it seems like so many people are booking basic to get the cheaper prices, but they still try to get the perks of those who pay more. If you want to sit together, pay the price to choose your seats."
U/MONSTERBEARMAN wrote: "Your failure to plan ahead does not constitute an inconvenience on my part."
U/NYerInTex said: "I mean, I get asking politely for a lateral move—aisle for an aisle. First for first. To have the GALL to ask someone who paid a bunch more to sit in a far less comfortable seat with a lesser experience is just utter lack of awareness."
U/Jasranwhit noted: "It's always ok to ask politely, it's always ok to decline politely. (Although asking someone to give up a first class seat for an economy seat is borderline crazy)."
Newsweek has contacted the original poster for comment via the Reddit messaging system. The details of the post could not be verified at the time of publishing.
Do you have a travel-related story to share? Let us know via life@newsweek.com and your story could be featured on Newsweek.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines