brandon keith riley-mitchell

...

Joshua Rhett Miller

By Joshua Rhett Miller

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A Pennsylvania prosecutor is calling on state lawmakers to close a "loophole" that allowed a registered sex offender to become a parent via surrogacy.

Footage of Brandon Keith Riley-Mitchell celebrating the first birthday of his son, Atticus, with husband Logan Steven Riley went viral this week, stoking criticism from conservatives that erupted upon revelation of his status as a registered sex offender in Pennsylvania.

The scrutiny comes after Riley-Mitchell, 39, and his partner had previously raised more than $2,000 via a crowdfunding drive to become fathers using a gestational surrogate.

Read More on U.S.

"In gestational surrogacy, the child is not biologically related to the surrogate mother," Riley wrote on GoFundMe. "Instead, an embryo is created via in vitro fertilization (IVF) using an anonymous donor egg. The embryo is then transferred to the gestational surrogate who carries the baby as if it were any other pregnancy. Once the baby is born, the intended parents (Brandon and I) would have full legal custody."

The fundraiser, which has since been removed but is still archived, did not indicate details of Riley-Mitchell's prior conviction in 2016 for sexual abuse of children and possession of child pornography.

BRANDON KEITH RILEY-MITCHELL

...

Logan Riley announced in November 2023 that the couple had found a surrogate after creating four embryos through an egg donor program in 2020.

"After three long years of searching, a family friend... reached out in early 2023 to see if we were still looking," the since-deleted fundraiser read. "After multiple conversations and a great connection with her family, we decided to proceed. Our surrogate went through extensive medical and social worker evaluations in order to be approved for surrogacy. Once approved, the lengthy legal and financial process began. We are so excited that our amazing surrogate will carry one of our embryos for us, helping to expand our family!"

Riley said the couple planned to hold a fundraiser in 2024 to help offset the "substantial costs" of becoming fathers.

"Thank you to everyone who already donated to our surrogacy fund, your contributions are greatly appreciated," he wrote. "We have incredible friends and family!"

A district attorney in Pennsylvania, where the couple lives, is now calling for legislative action while noting current state law did not preclude Riley-Mitchell from becoming a father.

"I thoroughly appreciate the concerned and outraged emotions expressed by many that a loophole exists in the law to allows a registered sex offender to become a parent through surrogacy without the same intense scrutiny, accountability, and judicial oversight mandated for the adoption process," York County District Attorney Tim Barker told Newsweek in a statement late Tuesday.

"This is an issue ripe for review and remedy by our Pennsylvania Legislature."

Barker said he had "full confidence" that York County elected officials would pursue any "constitutionally permissible legislative actions" to protect children.

"Pennsylvania law currently does not, in and of itself, prohibit a registered sex offender from becoming a parent through surrogacy," Barker added. "Given this fact, no one presently has brought forth to my office an allegation of a criminal violation being perpetrated by Mitchell in York County. Accordingly, my office lacks any legal basis to act on this matter."

Petition To Remove Child

More than 3,000 people have signed an online petition launched Tuesday calling for the boy to be removed from the home of the couple, who live in southern Pennsylvania outside York. There is no indication or suggestion the child has been harmed in the care of his parents.

"A Tier 1 registered sex offender, Brandon Keith Riley Mitchell, was convicted in Pennsylvania for the sexual abuse of a minor and is publicly listed on the Megan's Law registry," the petition reads. "Despite this, he and his partner have recently obtained custody of a newborn baby through surrogacy. This is possible only due to a dangerous legal loophole in Pennsylvania that allows sex offenders — even those convicted of crimes against children — to access custody through private or unregulated reproductive arrangements."

Repeated attempts by Newsweek to reach Riley-Mitchell and Riley were unsuccessful, but Peter Kratsa, Riley-Mitchell's former attorney, said his client had served his sentence and completed post-conviction requirements without incident. No law prohibited Riley-Mitchell from becoming a father, Kratsa emphasized.

brandon keith riley-mitchell

...

"Brandon's matter in Chester County involved allegations in 2013 of inappropriate electronic communications with a minor, aged 16-to-18 years old," Kratsa said in a statement. "There was no allegation of physical contact. Brandon immediately accepted responsibility for his conduct, served his sentence without incident, and engaged in extensive counseling. Brandon did nothing illegal or unethical in becoming a surrogate parent. He was completely transparent."

Kratsa's statement concluded: "Perhaps the attention of those decrying his parenthood would be more appropriately directed toward those who are not held accountable for child abuse, are not punished, and make no efforts at rehabilitation."

The York County Department of Probation Services assumed supervision of Riley-Mitchell's case from 2017 through 2021 following a transfer from Chester County. He then successfully completed his supervision in 2021, Barker, the D.A., noted.

"Pursuant to his underlying conviction and sentence, Mitchell became a registered sex offender and must comply with those requirements regardless of his probation/parole supervision being closed," the prosecutor's statement continued. "Mitchell has not been alleged to have violated his registration conditions, and our office has not received criminal charges to prosecute him for any such offenses."

What the Surrogate Knew

The husband of the couple's surrogate, meanwhile, told Newsweek Riley-Mitchell did admit to having "prior interaction with the law," but said the matter had been resolved.

"He said he had 'something in my past' but had gone through the court system," Theodore Martinovich told Newsweek, adding that he ultimately balked at Riley-Mitchell's offer to provide more details.

"I didn't know the story and I didn't care to dig into it," he said.

brandon keith riley-mitchell

...

Riley-Mitchell, a former teacher at Downingtown West High School from 2010 through 2015, was charged in 2016 for allegedly requesting nude images and video from a 16-year-old student.

Authorities later found more than 12,000 text messages between Riley-Mitchell and the victim between May 2013 and December 2014.

Riley-Mitchell, who later pleaded guilty to felony possession of child pornography, was sentenced to a minimum of three months confinement and a maximum of 23 months in prison. He was also ordered to have no contact with the victim or unsupervised contact with minors, as well as to surrender his teaching licenses and certificates, court records show.

Riley-Mitchell now works at a pharmaceutical company in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, according to his LinkedIn profile.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines