FILE – David Wecht, a Democrat running for the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, arrives for a news conference, Oct. 15, 2015, in Pittsburgh. (AP Photo/Keith Srakocic, File)

...

Gabe WhisnantAndrew Stanton

By Gabe Whisnant and Andrew Stanton

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice David Wecht announced Monday he is leaving the Democratic Party and registering as an independent, citing what he described as rising antisemitism.

In a statement distributed through the state court system, Wecht said, “Acquiescence to Jew-hatred is now disturbingly common among activists, leaders and even many elected officials in the Democratic Party.”

The move highlights internal tensions within the party and adds to the broader political debate over how leaders are responding to antisemitism. Wecht will remain on the state’s high court, but his switch shifts the partisan balance in the critical swing state from a 5–2 Democratic majority to 4 Democrats, 2 Republicans and 1 independent, underscoring potential political fallout ahead.

Read More on Politics

Newsweek reached out to the Pennsylvania Democratic Party for comment.

What To Know

Wecht, who was first elected to the court as a Democrat in 2015 and retained last year for another 10-year term, said antisemitism has, in his view, increasingly taken root on the left since the 2018 Tree of Life synagogue massacre in Pittsburgh. That attack, which killed 11 worshippers, occurred at the synagogue where Wecht and his wife were married and where he once served on the board.

"In the years that have followed, that same hatred has grown on the left. Increasingly, it has moved from the fringe to the mainstream. It is the duty of all good people to fight this virus, and to do so before it is too late," he wrote.

In his statement, Wecht cited examples of conduct he says has been minimized or ignored by Democratic leaders, including “jihadist chants, intimidation and attacks at synagogues,” as well as “Nazi tattoos” and other antisemitic imagery.

While he did not name specific Democratic officials, Graham Platner, a Democratic U.S. Senate candidate in Maine, disclosed last year that he had previously obtained a tattoo later identified as resembling a Nazi-linked Totenkopf symbol. Platner has said he was unaware of its meaning at the time and has since covered it up. The controversy drew national attention after prominent Democrats continued to support his candidacy despite condemnation from Jewish advocacy groups.

Newsweek reached out to Platner for comment.

David Wecht arrives for a news conference, October 15, 2015, in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.

...

Wecht’s departure adds to a public debate within Democratic circles over how aggressively the party should address antisemitism, particularly amid party infighting following the Israel–Hamas war. Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman, a Democrat who has sided with Republicans at times and fueled speculation that he could become an independent, wrote on X in response to Wecht's announcement that "The Democratic Party must confront its own rising antisemitism problem.”

I know David and his legendary father, Cyril. As I’ve affirmed, I’m not changing my party—but I fully understand David’s personal choice,” Fetterman said.

The Pennsylvania Republican Party responded to Wecht's announcement in a statement to Newsweek.

"Justice David Wecht’s statement is a sobering reflection of a troubling rise of antisemitism that is no longer confined to the fringe of the Democratic Party. When someone with his background and credibility speaks out about this issue, it demands serious attention," the statement said. "The question now is whether Josh Shapiro and other Democratic leaders will confront this reality. Will they clearly and unequivocally condemn antisemitism within their own party, or will they continue to ignore it?"

Prominent Jewish Democrats, including Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, have raised concerns about what they view as the rise of antisemitism on the left.

“I think antisemitism is a very real problem in both the Democratic Party and the Republican Party. Please don’t clip my words there. It is a problem on the political left and the political right, and there should be no place for it when someone like JD Vance allows a Nick Fuentes to have a platform to speak or Tucker Carlson to have a platform to speak, and doesn’t condemn it,” Shapiro said in a February interview with the Associated Press.

An American Jewish Committee poll of 2,056 adults from October 10-November 25, 2024, found that 72 percent of respondents believed antisemitism is a problem in the U.S and that 59 percent believed it had increased over the past five years. It had a margin of error of plus or minus 3 percentage points.

What Does His Party Switch Mean for Supreme Court and Democrats? Expert Weighs In

Wecht’s party switch is “more about his personal political alignment with some aspects of the Democratic Party” than his judicial philosophy, Jennie Sweet-Cushman, a Chatham University political scientist, told Newsweek.

“Wecht is known for being somewhat non-ideological in his jurisprudence and sticking more so to institutional reasoning and legal theory in his decisions. I don't think there is any reason to think that would change,” she said. “He won't suddenly change directions towards supporting Republican efforts to thwart democratic process in voting and elections, for example.”

However, he does put a face to the pattern of voters increasingly not wanting to identify with the major political parties, she said.

That trend is “disproportionately impacting Democrats in Pennsylvania,” which is problematic for primary voting and donations, but these independent voters who leave the party may not look much different from other Democrats in how they vote in general elections.

She noted that it is “interesting how identity is playing out in these types of decisions by American Jews.”

“Political party has increasingly become a bundled set of identities that make for a super identity, religion, race, geography, gender, etc.. And that's super powerful. In this instance, Wecht is recognizing that his identity as a Jewish person doesn't align with the Democratic super identity,” she said.

That could be something that “lessens the intense hyper-polarization we have been experiencing,” she said.

List of Democrats Who Have Left Party Since Trump's Election

Party switches are historically rare, but numerous Democrats across the country have left the party since Trump’s election in 2024.

The two most recent switches came from North Carolina, where state Representatives Carla Cunningham and Nasif Majeed both left the party after losing their primaries against more progressive Democrats.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines