Laura Smith PA Salute

...

Sophie Clark

By Sophie Clark

Live News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A county official in Pennsylvania resigned from her supervisor position over the weekend after seemingly mimicking SpaceX and Tesla chief Elon Musk's apparent Nazi salute, in a post on TikTok.

Laura Smith, the Republican vice chair of the Towamencin Township Board of Supervisors went on the app to tell her friends "who are struggling this week" that "my heart goes out to you" while tapping her chest and then making a salute in the air, like Musk did last Monday.

She resigned a day later and deleted the video from the social media site, but denied trying to make an offensive salute.

Read More on News

Smith has been contacted for comment via email.

Laura Smith PA Salute

...

Why It Matters

Musk made a salute last week which created public and political division. The Anti-Defamation League, a nonprofit fighting antisemitism, said he made an "awkward gesture." Both Dan Goldman, the co-chair of the House Bipartisan Task Force for Combating Antisemitism, and Nick Fuentes, a white nationalist who has previously praised Adolf Hitler, have said they believe Musk made a Nazi salute.

Many public speakers gesticulate with their arms, however, the combination of Musk's support of the far-right party Alternative for Germany and his time spent on right-wing corners of social media has convinced many people that this salute was a Sieg Heil, not a gesture of him sending his heart to the crowd.

What To Know

Smith has stepped down from her supervisor position in Pennsylvania. She said she resigned to "allow the Township to move forward without the encumbrance of the fallout of my video."

Board Chair Charles "Chuck" Wilson III has not said anything on his public Facebook page about the salute, although he appears not to have used that Facebook page since 2021.

Kristen Warner, another Republican on the board, has a "Stand Together Against Antisemitism" sticker on her Facebook profile picture but has also not used that page to speak out against her colleague's actions.

The Democrat assistant secretary and assistant treasurer on the board, Kofi Osei, used his Facebook page to call for the resignation of Smith, Wilson, and Warner for "being Nazi sympathizers," while asking people to be polite to their staff members as they are not elected officials.

Joyce Snyder, Democratic Towamencin supervisor and secretary, spoke with Newsweek about the salute.

"My neighbors have overwhelmingly spoken out against her video. My impression is that most of my neighbors have found her statement to be lacking in apology for the hurt she has caused," said Snyder.

She added that, while she has "no doubt" that some people will feel emboldened by Smith's actions, "many more have spoken out against her."

Snyder said: "I love my community and the people who make it up."

Supervisor Osei spoke with Newsweek saying: "The township community has overwhelmingly condemned her salute and are glad to see her submit a resignation."

He said that he did not see her resignation as a full apology. "After initially defending her video, a statement that does not include the word "sorry" and continues to say the video was "mischaracterized" is not an apology but I'm glad she resigned."

Supervisors Warner, Wilson, and the Board of Supervisors have been contacted via email for comment.

Smith also resigned as a board member of the Montgomery County-Norristown Public Library.

What People Are Saying

Laura Smith said in her apology posted by the Township on Sunday: "A video I posted recently to social media has been greatly mischaracterized," she wrote. "Not wishing to give offense, I removed the video from my accounts. I abhor racism, anti-Semitic or discrimination in any fashion or form and my record as a township supervisor attests to my commitment to treat all people with dignity and respect."

Joyce Snyder told Newsweek: "I was recently told I had hurt another person. The words I used were: 'My intentions are irrelevant, I am truly sorry for the hurt I caused you.' I believe that Laura has not apologized for the hurt she has caused ... Our Township has had a tumultuous few years. I think this incident is an indication that it is past time for new leadership in Towamencin."

Kofi Osei told Newsweek: "I'll say that I do not go out of my way to divine anyone's inner thoughts so I look at their actions. These types of "jokes" only make sense if you are a Nazi or value Nazi supporters. The lack of strong and/or timely response by most of the local Republican elected officials and leadership speaks volumes."

Montgomery County-Norristown Public Library said in a Facebook post on Saturday: "We reject hate in all its forms and remain committed to fostering an inclusive, respectful, and supportive environment for everyone."

What Happens Next

Many Towamencin Township residents online condemned Smith's video, commenting on the Towamencin Township Facebook page with their opinions on her salute, making it clear that they do not embrace any form of hate.

The backlash over Smith's TikTok video comes as Board Chair Chuck Wilson is up for re-election at the end of this year. This story will be updated with Wilson's comments if a response is received.

Musk, meanwhile, is facing a Tesla boycott in Germany but otherwise has not been asked to resign from his position as administrator of the newly created Department of Government Efficiency.

Update, 01/27/25, 8:55 a.m. ET: This story was updated to include comment from Towamencin Township Supervisor and Secretary Joyce Snyder.

Update, 01/28/25 6:40 a.m. ET: This story was updated to include comment from Towamencin Township Supervisor and assistant secretary/assistant treasurer Kofi Osei.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines