Concerned mother.

...

Darlin Tillery

By Darlin Tillery

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A mother of a 12 month old girl is questioning whether asking her nanny for updates about daily outings is too much after a comment she says left her unsettled.

In a post on Reddit by user Fun-Pollution4835, the parent explained that she encourages her daughter’s nanny to take the child to local activities such as the library, museum, music class and playground.

'Overkill'

The original poster (OP) said she supports those outings, but wants to know where her daughter is throughout the day.

Read More on Life

The issue came to a head when the nanny told the mom they were heading to music class. When they returned home, the child had a new toy.

After asking where it came from, the nanny said they had also gone to the museum, a stop the mother had not known about. When the parent gently said she would prefer a quick text if plans change, she said the nanny responded that it seemed like “overkill.”

The OP turned online to ask: “Am I asking for too much here?"

Concerned mother.

...

Most Reddit contributors sided firmly with the mother amid more than 200 comments.

"What?! Not overkill at all. Surprised by that comment," shared a supporter.

"I i always would update... if we were going somewhere not initially mentioned, unless maybe it was like Dunkin' or a gas station. I would just reiterate your expectation."

Another pointed out that the nanny, "is literally your employee. If you want updates on where she is going with your child you should get updates.

"Her opinion on ‘overkill’ isn’t relevant. How hard is it to send a text?”

is it really overkill to want updates from our
r/Nanny

View this post on Reddit

The discussion touches on a central issue in nanny parent arrangements: communication and trust.

According to MommyBites, “When a nanny lies–even about something as small as whether or not bedtime went smoothly–it breaks the trust in the nanny-parent relationship which can be hard to mend.”

The piece lists dishonesty among behaviors that should concern parents, adding that, “in general, dishonestly is a valid cause for concern when you’re entrusting this person to take care of your children.”

While the Reddit post does not accuse the nanny of lying, some commenters suggested that undisclosed stops could erode confidence if they continue.

Managing Expectations

Advice on strengthening nanny-parent partnerships often centers on expectations.

In an article on Care.com, one mother, Betsy, said: “If you want your nanny to help with dinner or do laundry or light cleaning—and she’ll have the time free during the day to do them—let her know from the start.

"You don’t just want to spring major new demands on a nanny, because then she’ll feel taken advantage of.”

The same article includes guidance from Joanna, a mother of two, who said: “Leaving notes about biggie things is not OK— your nanny and your children, deserve a discussion.

"If you leave a note, your nanny might feel attacked. It’s so easy to read the wrong tone in a note.”

The Sticking Point?

Back on the Reddit thread, the OP said she raised the matter gently, framing it as a preference for a quick text update when plans shift. The nanny’s use of the word “overkill” appears to have been the sticking point.

The conversation reflects the balancing act many working parents face: granting caregivers autonomy while wanting visibility into their child’s day.

Newsweek has reached out to Fun-Pollution4835 for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.

To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines