10
Loading video...

By Christopher Hale
Political philosopher
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Last weekend, the White House shared an AI-generated image of Donald Trump dressed in papal regalia, seated on Peter's throne, and raising a hand in benediction on social media.
The image, originally posted on Trump's Truth Social account, quickly went viral, drawing both amusement and criticism. Many Catholics found it disrespectful or even blasphemous. On Monday Trump dismissed the backlash, stating, "You have to have a little fun," and noting that his wife Melania thought the image was "cute."
This incident exemplifies how political theater can overshadow the solemnity of religious traditions. As the papal conclave begins, media narratives have begun to frame it through the lens of American electoral politics.
Read More
What the Next Pope Can Learn From Francis: A Muslim’s Reflection | Opinion6 min read

The Next Pope Should Heal Divides in the Catholic Church | Opinion5 min read

What I Saw—And Felt—At Pope Francis’ Funeral | Opinion5 min read

Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle faces unfounded gambling rumors; Cardinal Pietro Parolin is subject to health scare speculations; and Cardinal Robert Prevost's record on clergy abuse is being scrutinized. These stories, while attention-grabbing, risk reducing the conclave to a mere political contest, ignoring the profound spiritual discernment it entails.
The papacy is not the presidency. The conclave is not a campaign. Understanding the future of the Catholic Church requires moving beyond the simplistic binaries of liberal versus conservative and recognizing the deeper theological and pastoral debates at play.
Unlike a political campaign, a conclave has no declared candidates, no televised debates. Yet Western media often cast it as a "liberal vs. conservative" showdown. The global Catholic Church, however, fits poorly along left-right ideological lines common to American politics. This secular lens imposes false binaries on a sacred event, obscuring the Church's real internal dynamics.
Internal vs. External Focus
One key fault line often overlooked is whether the next pope's focus will be ad intra (internal) or ad extra (outward). Cardinals in pre-conclave meetings have discussed both "the relationship of the church with the contemporary world" and internal crises like clerical abuse and Vatican finances. Some electors want a pope who will put the Church's house in order, while others seek one to energize its global mission.
An ad intra pope would prioritize governance and reform: cleaning up corruption, enforcing accountability for abuse, and restoring discipline and unity in Rome. An ad extra pope, by contrast, might emphasize evangelization, interfaith dialogue, and the Church's advocacy on global issues.
These differences are real, but reducing them to simplistic "conservative" or "progressive" labels misses the nuance. A churchman can be doctrinally traditional yet insist the Church engage the modern world boldly, or vice versa.
The Liturgy Wars
Another major debate concerns Catholic liturgy. Tensions have grown around the use of the traditional Latin Mass as opposed to the modern vernacular Mass. Pope Francis angered traditionalists by restricting the old rite in 2021. Within the College of Cardinals, views diverge: at least 17 cardinals publicly objected to curtailing the Latin Mass, while others back Francis' one-form approach.
Liturgy cuts to the core of Catholic identity, and it doesn't map neatly onto political camps. Some prelates branded "conservative" are driven chiefly by preserving reverence and continuity in worship. Likewise, those deemed "liberal" might prefer modern liturgy yet remain orthodox in doctrine. The next pope will have to bridge this liturgical divide—a pastoral challenge, not a political one.

...
The Question of Synodality
Perhaps the most consequential rift is over synodality—Pope Francis' push for a more decentralized, consultative Church. A strong majority of electors support continuing Francis' synodal reforms, valuing assemblies of bishops (and laity) that foster dialogue on Church issues.
Yet a minority is wary, fearing that synods could undermine doctrinal clarity or papal authority. Recent synods have broached sensitive questions—like welcoming LGBTQ Catholics or expanding women's roles in ministry—which alarms those who say too much decentralization risks confusion and division.
Here again, a cardinal's stance on synodality flows from his vision of Church governance, not a party platform. The conclave will decide whether the next pontificate will slow or accelerate the synodal process.
What's Really at Stake
Watching the media coverage, one might think the Catholic Church is about to elect a Democrat or a Republican. In reality, the cardinals are not partisan delegates, and the papacy is not a presidency.
What's at stake is far more profound than politics: the future course of a 1.3-billion-member faith community. The cardinals must choose a spiritual leader to steer a 2,000-year-old institution through challenges that defy Left-Right labels.
Yes, factions exist—some want Francis' reforms to continue, others quietly prefer a doctrinal reset. But reducing the conclave to an American-style political contest trivializes it. Instead of asking if the next pope will be "liberal" or "conservative," we should ask how he will tackle those real ecclesial issues—internal reform, liturgy, and authority—that are truly on the cardinals' minds.
When the white smoke rises, the world will not be witnessing a partisan victory, but a moment of spiritual succession—the transfer of the keys of Peter to a man chosen in silence, prayer, and profound responsibility. The next pope will not be a liberal or a conservative in the way American pundits understand those terms. He will be a pastor, a theologian, a symbol of unity for a deeply divided world.
If the media figures covering the conclave want to serve the public—and better communicate the reality of the Church—they must abandon the lazy political shorthand and start asking better questions: What kind of leadership does the Church need now? What internal wounds must be healed? What mission must be reawakened?
This is not a political election. It's a religious discernment. And it deserves to be treated with the gravity, complexity, and reverence that such a moment demands.
Anything less isn't just bad journalism. It's a profound misunderstanding of what the Catholic Church—and this moment in history—actually represents.
Christopher Hale is a Democratic operative from Tennessee. He led national Catholic outreach for President Obama's reelection campaign and served as the cofounder of Catholics for Harris.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines