0.cached.png

0.cached.png

Newsweek Editors

By Newsweek Editors

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


NEWSWEEK: Were there significant advances made in dialogue between the Unites States and the Holy See during your time here?

Jim Nicholson: Yes, I think so. In the Pope's annual speech to the diplomatic corps on January 10, he emphasized food, peace and liberty and freedom, life. Those things are totally congruent with the value systems and the priorities of the United States government and the Bush administration, and we've been working on those very closely in the last three-and-a-half years.

He made a special mention of religious freedom, which is a very important subject to the United States isn't it?

Read More on News

Very important. It's a basic freedom, a basic ingredient to a life of dignity and a life of dignity is the transcendent goal of United States' foreign policy which is to enhance human dignity, not just in the United States, not just Italy, but in the world. That's a value that's as important to President Bush as it is to the Holy Father, and about which they agree--life itself, the family, marriage, the things that the Pope talked about are the things which are the value priorities of the United States.

Do you really sense that the Holy See appreciates the values of the American government?

Yes, I think so, and I think that the Holy Father really admires President Bush and admires what he stands for, his integrity, his character, his courageous stand on these issues around freedom, liberty and the like.

A large part of your time as ambassador was taken up by the war in Iraq. How hard has it been for you to represent a policy that many in the Vatican felt was wrong?

Well we clearly had a disagreement over Iraq, but it's important to analyze that carefully. The Pope said no to war; he said that on Jan. 13, 2003. He said war is not always inevitable, war is a defeat for humanity, war should only be the last result. Those are principles which we in the United States agree on, so the only disagreement was over the imminence of the danger. President Bush saw his responsibilities as being to protect the American people and other people from a dangerous, violent tyrant who certainly had possessed weapons of mass destruction, had used them, had used them on his own people, and so he interpreted his responsibilities that he needed to go into Iraq. Now the Holy Father is well aware of the doctrine of the Church which says that the ultimate responsibility lies with the appropriate civilian authority, exercising their prudential judgement. So President Bush did that. For 10 years they'd hoped that these resolutions of the UN would make [Saddam Hussein] cease, desist and be forthcoming and they didn't, so [Bush] did what he felt he had to do. Since that happened we've been very forward-looking together. We've been working together for humanitarian relief in Iraq, we share common goals and express them about trying to bring freedom to the Iraqi people, freedom from the murderous tyrant of the past, and freedom for religion, peace, prosperity and freedom in the future.

But what many find hard to understand is how the administration could still go to war in spite of the opposition from the Vatican and many other religious groups. Some would say either that it's arrogant to dismiss all those spiritual leaders and their wisdom, or that perhaps the administration is actually wiser than they are. How do you respond to that analysis?

Well the Holy Father is a man for peace, and the president respects him a great deal. He's been here three times to see him in his first term--more than any other president has come to Rome to see him--and the Pope sent an emissary to see the president whom he received and spent a generous amount of time with to discuss this and to get the Holy Father's views. So there was certainly no arrogance. It was certainly not a decision taken lightly or easily. There was a heavy responsibility on the president but he saw the facts of the matter and his responsibility to protect our country from terrorism and tyranny. I mean we've had 9/11 and 9/11 really changed a lot of things. It's interesting and important to point out, by the way, that the Holy Father has been very supportive of our efforts against terrorists, including in Afghanistan, and the Holy Father continues to point out--very recently--that these people who kill in the name of God have to be contained. The first meeting I ever had with the Holy Father was on Sept. 13, 2001 and he said that was an attack not just on you, that was an attack on humanity. It implied that President Bush was going to have to take steps to do something about these terrorists. The president saw Iraq in his composite of responsibilities, one that he needed to take a lead on to protect the world from terrorism.

Yet the Pope and the Curia have often said that the way to tackle terrorists is to address the causes of terrorism, not wage war on a country which may, or may not, have connections with terrorists.

The Pope has said both. He said these people who kill in the name of God have to be stopped, and he also very rightly pointed out many times that we have to tackle the root causes of terrorism, about which we totally agree, which are: ignorance, poverty, desperation, lack of hope. That's why we also lead in areas of development and freedom, giving people freedom, the chance for hope and religious liberty, and food. That's why the United States provides around 60 percent of all the food that goes to the World Food Programme to feed 70 million people a day.

But what a lot of people can't get their head around is the seeming inconsistency over this willingness to uphold human dignity in certain areas of policy, yet still wage a war that many thought unjustified. What do you say to those who hold this view?

First of all, that's an honest debate that people can have. That was an honest disagreement that the Holy Father and the president had. But those are not inconsistent, because the doctrine of the Church recognizes that there are evil forces and that innocent people need to be protected from evil forces which is why the Pope is not a pacifist. The doctrine of the Church is not pacifistic; it recognizes that there are evil forces out there preying on innocent people, and they prey on them physically through terror and they prey on them through depravation and exploitation. We need to work on both fronts to try to enhance dignity, and its constituencies which are peace, freedom and expectations of being able to live and have self-fulfilment, hope and vision.

Robespierre once said that no one likes armed missionaries. In retrospect, might it have been better to have taken a different strategy in terms of bringing human dignity to the Iraqi people?

You know, it's so easy to be a Monday-morning quarterback. I think the president did the right thing, I think he had no choice. One can debate tactics about after we went in, and how, maybe, we did things with respect to the army, or the civil service, but on the threshold question of going in there, the president has done the right thing. Look at what's been revealed since we went in there, look at the mass graves, exhibiting the mass murdering preceded by torture that was going on in that country. Look at the corruption that we've now learned about. We have freed a people. Certainly there are problems there; there's an entrenched insurgency going on in there, but there is also a tremendous amount of good which you don't hear about and don't read about. The schools are open--the hospitals, the libraries, even the trains run. Now the people are facing the opportunity of facing a free election.

The U.S. is said by some commentators to be showing the way forward for Europe, having gone from a period in the 1970s and '80s when the country seemed to have lost a sense of moral values, to today where it's now reclaimed the moral high ground. They argue the U.S. has come through what Europe is going through now. Do you agree with this analysis?

I think the United States under this administration has taken a very courageous and forceful position on important moral questions around life, the family, cloning and human engineering and has been steadfast and was reaffirmed in those positions by the election at home. I think that that can be a model for Europe. I think a lot of people are really wanting moral, predictable leadership from their civilian authorities, and the United States is showing the way. It's also been a great area of congruence for us and me in this job, representing this president with the Holy Father in Europe. So I'm optimistic.

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines