By Adam Mills
AI Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Retail has spent the better part of a decade talking about personalization. The promise was straightforward: Better data would lead to more relevant experiences, stronger loyalty and higher conversion. Instead, many shoppers now experience something closer to fatigue—more messages, more noise and more reminders that retailers still don’t really know them.
That tension is becoming harder to ignore as artificial intelligence (AI) moves from experimentation to execution. AI is raising expectations around speed and relevance, and in doing so, forcing retailers to confront whether personalization is actually working.
“Personalization changes behavior when it’s grounded in relevance over volume,” Tony Owens, CEO of Amperity, a customer data platform focused on identity and personalization, told Newsweek.
Read More on Newsweek.AI
When it isn’t actually relevant to them, consumers move on.
When Relevance Arrives Too Late
Amperity’s 2026 State of Personalization in Retail report puts data behind that disconnect. Nearly three-quarters of consumers say they are more likely to purchase when they receive a truly personalized offer or recommendation. Seven in 10 say they are more likely to buy when offers adjust instantly as they browse. Yet more than half still describe shopping experiences as generic, and nearly eight in 10 say it is not rare for retailers to get personalization wrong through irrelevant, mistimed or invasive outreach.
What has changed is not consumer appetite for personalization, but tolerance for getting it wrong. As AI accelerates, the delay between signal and response becomes harder to ignore. For Owens, the pressure is less about personalization itself and more about how fast retailers can act.
“Shopping decisions are made in real time, so if a brand waits hours or even minutes to react, the moment has already passed.”
Retailers routinely capture intent signals—first visits, early browsing behavior, cart building—but in many cases, those signals move too slowly through disconnected systems to influence outcomes. They become useful for analysis after the fact, rather than for shaping the experience as it unfolds.
Why AI Amplifies Failure Before It Fixes It
AI intensifies that problem. It can surface signals instantly and scale decisions across channels, but only when the underlying data is connected. When it isn’t, speed amplifies the shortcomings.
That reality shows up in how consumers describe “wrong” personalization. According to the study, 79 percent say it is not rare for retailers to miss the mark. Owens points to a familiar pattern.
“Most misfires happen when brands act on incomplete or outdated signals,” he said. “When reach is prioritized over relevance, messages quickly feel intrusive.”

...
Recognition has also shifted from a differentiator to a baseline expectation. The same report finds that 83 percent of consumers say personalized shopping is important and want retailers to remember them, including preferences and past purchases. Yet recognition often breaks down as customers move between channels.
Owens framed recognition less as memory than continuity—carrying context across web, mobile, in-store and support interactions. When systems operate in isolation, customers are forced to start over, regardless of how advanced individual tools may be.
Inside the Execution Gap
Those limitations show up in the operational realities that retailers face every day.
“Delivering real-time relevance starts with identifying the shopper and connecting that identity to browsing or purchase history,” Larry Shaw, chief marketing officer at MacKenzie-Childs, a home decor and lifestyle retailer, told Newsweek.
Even when that connection exists, execution can still break down.
“When systems can’t exchange data quickly enough, consistent real-time personalization becomes difficult to execute at scale,” Shaw said.
Those constraints help explain why personalization can still feel generic, even inside organizations that believe they are doing it well.
Shaw points to identification challenges, misalignment across teams, creative assets that aren’t ready to deploy and platforms that don’t operate together in real time. Latency across those systems remains one of the most persistent barriers.
High-intent moments—such as adding an item to a cart—are easier to act on because they offer clear direction within a single session. Earlier signals are harder to capture and harder still to operationalize.
Shaw noted that, “The further down the funnel a shopper moves, the stronger the signal.”
From Advantage to Credibility Test
Taken together, the findings suggest consumers are not rejecting personalization itself. They are rejecting poor execution. That distinction becomes more important as AI plays a larger role in retail decision-making.
For Owens, real-time personalization has shifted from a competitive advantage to a credibility test. Consumers compare every experience to the best one they’ve had—not just to competitors in the same category. In that environment, responsiveness becomes a proxy for trust.
Closing that gap requires more than faster tools. It requires organizational change. Batch thinking—where customer data is processed on fixed cycles instead of in real time—remains embedded in how many teams operate, Owens said, even though customers live in a continuous now. Addressing that mismatch means rethinking how data flows, how signals are prioritized and how quickly decisions translate into experiences.
It also means rejecting the idea that retailers must choose between scale and accuracy.
“Accuracy comes first,” Owens said. “When you get identity and context right, scale follows.”
The Human Check on AI
As AI becomes more central to personalization strategies, both Owens and Shaw emphasize that technology alone is not the answer. The future lies in a clearer division of labor between machines and people—AI processing signals and surfacing insights at speed, while humans apply judgment, context and empathy.
Shaw described that balance in practical terms.
“If what you’re delivering is relevant and valuable, it won’t feel intrusive.”
As AI accelerates, retailers may find that speed alone is no longer enough. Relevance—delivered in the moment—is the difference-maker.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines