10
Loading video...

By Jennifer Radcliffe
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
An upstate New York school superintendent moved to clarify a controversial policy concerning LGBTQ+ students after hundreds of students walked out of class Friday, saying discussions about sexual orientation or gender identity do not automatically require educators to notify parents.
Richard Chapman, superintendent of the Liverpool Central School District in Onondaga County, northwest of Syracuse, apologized for failing to explain the district's legal guidance clearly, saying the original memo was written for staff "in legal terms."
"It was my responsibility to take something this complicated and nuanced and explain it clearly to everyone in our community. I didn't do that as well as I should have, and I'm sorry," Chapman wrote in a letter to families published by WSYR. "A student talking with a teacher or counselor about who they are does not, by itself, mean a call home," Chapman wrote.
Read More on News
Newsweek reached out to Chapman for comment.

...
He added that a parent would be contacted "if a child needs an adjustment to their educational setting."
The clarification followed a Wednesday school board meeting at which the district's attorney, Kate Reid, argued that recent Supreme Court decisions and federal enforcement actions had left districts with little flexibility in handling gender-related accommodations.
Why the District Says It Changed Course
During the meeting, Reid told board members that the Supreme Court's handling of Mirabelli v. Bonta had fundamentally altered the legal landscape for schools. She argued that districts could no longer rely on prior guidance that deferred to students' wishes about whether parents would be informed of gender-related accommodations.
"What it means is that that is the law of the land," Reid said.
Matt Jones, a Liverpool school board member, said he's disappointed that the country has lost ground in supporting all students.
"You know that I think this is barbaric, but I think that's unfair to barbarians," Jones told Reid during the meeting.
Reid noted that issues involving morality, ethics and religious beliefs fall within parents' constitutional authority to direct their children's upbringing, according to the courts.
Related Story

Four States Approve Transgender School Sports Restrictions
Related Story

Map Shows States Banning Transgender Athletes as Supreme Court Rules
Related Story

NYC Pride March: Polls Show How American Views on LGBTQ Rights Have Changed
At the same time, Reid drew a distinction between a student discussing sexual orientation and a school affirmatively accommodating requests.
"We do not need to necessarily pick up the phone if a child says, 'I am homosexual,'" Reid said during the meeting. "Before we start facilitating anything that the child asks us to do and accommodating that or not telling their parent, we're running afoul of Mahmoud and Mirabelli combined."
Federal Investigations and DOJ Enforcement
Reid pointed to a broader federal effort to investigate school policies that allegedly withhold information from parents. "The federal government said they will be actively investigating districts that keep secrets from parents," she said.
She also told board members that districts that ignored the ruling would do so "at their peril" and cited what she described as a national consensus among school attorneys and insurers that the decision should be treated as controlling.
"They're going to get sued and they're going to lose, and they're not going to have insurance," Reid told board members.
Recent federal actions largely support that claim. On Wednesday, the U.S. Department of Education announced investigations into five school districts in Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Colorado, Illinois and Minnesota, over "Gender Support Plans" and policies that allegedly concealed information about students' gender identities from parents. The department said it would investigate potential violations of the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) and the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment (PPRA).
Earlier in November, the department announced additional investigations involving districts in New Mexico and Pennsylvania and said it was working with the Department of Justice on enforcement involving Pine-Richland School District in Pennsylvania.
The Justice Department has also filed lawsuits against Kansas City, Kansas Public Schools and Anne Arundel County Public Schools in Maryland, alleging that district policies violated FERPA and PPRA by facilitating gender transitions at school and withholding related information from parents. Those allegations remain subject to ongoing litigation.
However, the federal actions generally involve education records, gender-support plans, information collected from students and school-facilitated social transitions. They do not establish a final judicial ruling requiring schools to report every private conversation involving sexual orientation or gender identity to parents.
What to Know About Mirabelli v. Bonta
The legal debate centers on Mirabelli v. Bonta, a California case challenging policies that required schools to obtain a student's consent before disclosing the student's gender transition to parents and required educators to use students' preferred names and pronouns at school.
In March, the Supreme Court vacated a lower-court stay of a permanent injunction as it applied to parent plaintiffs. In a per curiam opinion, the court found that the parents were likely to succeed on their constitutional claims and said California's policies likely triggered strict scrutiny because they interfered with parents' rights to direct the upbringing and religious development of their children.
The litigation remains ongoing, however, and the High Court did not establish a comprehensive nationwide rule governing every discussion of sexual orientation or gender identity between students and school employees.
Reid acknowledged that the case was not final, but she argued that the court had already announced a binding constitutional standard.
Not all legal experts agree with Liverpool's interpretation.
Derek Black, a constitutional law scholar interviewed by WSYR, questioned whether the Supreme Court's action requires all of the measures Liverpool says it must take.
"The court is saying you cannot make it your policy that we're going to hide information from parents," Black told the station. "That's different than saying our policy is now that we're going to tell parents everything."
Student Backlash
Students opposed to the policy staged a walkout Friday at Liverpool High School.
According to Syracuse.com and other local media outlets, students carried signs reading "I'm queer. Call my Mom!" "We deserve privacy allies not informants" and "Outing students isn't safe."
Giada Murray, a Liverpool senior interviewed by WSYR, said students fear the policy could damage trust between students and educators.
"Right now, I feel the students don't feel safe being themselves," Murray told the station. "You shouldn't be outed, and you should be able to come out when you're ready."
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here. Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Kate Nalepinski and Edward T. Cummins
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines