
...

By Alia Shoaib
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
New Jersey is one step closer to banning surveillance pricing after lawmakers passed legislation that would limit how retailers use shoppers' personal data to set individualized prices.
State lawmakers passed the Fair Price Protection Act on Tuesday, which would prohibit retailers and third-party grocery delivery platforms from using consumers' personal data collected through electronic surveillance to charge different prices for the same grocery and food products. The bill now awaits the signature of Democratic Governor Mikie Sherrill.
Why It Matters
The use of artificial intelligence and consumer data to personalize prices has become an increasingly contentious issue as retailers gain access to more information about shoppers' habits, online activity and purchasing behavior.
Read More on News
Critics say surveillance pricing is a predatory practice that enables companies to charge customers different prices for the same products based on their personal data. Opponents of legislation restricting the practice argue it could have unintended consequences, such as making it harder for retailers to offer personalized discounts through loyalty programs.
What the New Jersey Bill Would Do
The New Jersey Senate approved the Fair Price Protection Act in a 22-14 vote after it passed the Assembly 51-20-1.
The bill would ban retailers from using consumers' personal data—including information gathered through electronic surveillance and biometric monitoring, genetic information, and protected class data—to determine the price of food items.
If signed into law, shoppers in New Jersey could no longer be charged different prices for the same grocery items based on their personal data.

...
Lawmakers' Partisan Views on Surveillance Pricing
State Senator Joe Lagana, a Democrat who co-sponsored the bill, described surveillance pricing in a news release as "a modern form of consumer fraud" that "quietly manipulates prices based on a customer's private online behavior."
"At a time when families are already struggling with the rising cost of basic necessities, the Fair Price Protection Act will put a stop to these deceptive practices and ensure businesses treat shoppers equally, without weaponizing their own personal data against them," he said.
New Jersey Republicans criticized the bill on social media, arguing that it would have "unintended consequences."
"Retailers warn it could eliminate loyalty programs because of new limits on using consumer data for discounts," they said, adding, "Kiss your ShopRite PricePlus card good-bye."
State Democrats said in the news release that the bill would not prevent retailers from offering promotional discounts to broadly defined groups—such as teachers, veterans and seniors—or through loyalty programs.
The legislation includes a one-year moratorium on the installation of new electronic shelf labels while the state studies whether the technology could facilitate surveillance pricing. Retailers already using electronic shelf labels would be allowed to continue doing so during that period.
Other States Restricting Surveillance Pricing
Maryland and Connecticut have already enacted laws restricting surveillance pricing, while similar legislation in New York is awaiting the governor's signature.
More than 50 bills have been introduced in 26 states to restrict or ban the practice, according to Money.com.
What Happens Next
The Fair Price Protection Act now heads to the governor, who will decide whether to sign it into law.
If signed, the measure is scheduled to take effect one year after enactment.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines