10

Loading video...

Lauren Giella

By Lauren Giella

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A new bill in New Jersey would classify AI chatbots as consumer products, potentially making the companies that provide them more liable for harm done to users.

AI companies generally describe their chatbots as services, platforms or tools. New Jersey Assembly Bill A5607 would instead regulate chatbots as consumer products, subjecting providers to a stricter liability standard and making it easier for harmed users to sue AI companies for damages.

What Does This Bill Do?

Under the bill's product classification framework, chatbot providers would have a "duty to ensure that use of their chatbots does not cause injury to a user." Providers could be held liable even if they exercised all reasonable care in the design and distribution of the chatbot, or if they didn't directly distribute it to the user.

Read More on AI

The bill, sponsored by Assembly members Cody Miller, Marisa Sweeney and Joe Danielsen, with Anthony Angelozzi as a co-sponsor, would also impose new data privacy and content requirements on chatbot providers. These would restrict the use of chat logs for advertising, training and profiling, and generally set a two-year limit on their retention. Introduced in the General Assembly on October 5, 2026, the bill was referred to the Assembly Appropriations Committee on October 19, where it remains under consideration.

Ross Barnes, the founder of UK-based AI consulting firm Galahad, said treating AI chatbots as consumer products is the right instinct.

"When a chatbot gives a customer bad advice, the customer doesn't care whether it came from a person or a model; they care who is responsible," he told Newsweek. "Consumer-product rules answer that question in a way people already understand."

New Jersey's A5607 is based on the People-First Chatbot model bill developed by the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC), the Consumer Federation of America (CFA) and Fairplay. The model legislation treats chatbots as products, not people.

CFA told Newsweek that this type of bill "gives lawmakers a straightforward approach to address the harms caused by chatbot products that have been developed and deployed by tech companies with little oversight or transparency. It is a crucial step forward that would provide meaningful protections for all chatbot users."

How Does This Compare With Other AI Chatbot Legislation?

While much proposed AI legislation focuses on transparency, disclosure and specific protections, this bill takes a more comprehensive regulatory approach.

Another New Jersey bill, A5090, known as the GAI Accountability Act, was introduced in May 2026 and remains in committee. It would impose civil penalties of $20,000 per violation on generative AI platforms that fail to prevent specified harmful conduct, including offenses involving children. It also provides a defense for companies that made reasonable efforts to prevent violations.

New Jersey's A5607 also takes a broader approach than some measures in other states. California's SB 243 and New York's AI Companion Models Law focus more specifically on companion chatbots designed for social or emotional relationships with users. While all these measures address safety, New Jersey's bill would establish a stricter liability framework covering customer service, productivity and other general-purpose chatbots.

Additionally, the proposed bill would apply not only to chatbot developers but also to businesses that distribute or otherwise make chatbots available.

It would restrict the use of chat logs for advertising and profiling, prohibit their sale, require consent for certain uses of personal data and generally limit chat log retention to two years. It would also restrict the use of children's personal data, prohibit certain discriminatory or retaliatory practices against users and prevent chatbot providers from presenting chatbot outputs as professional advice.

Violations of the bill's specified requirements could result in civil penalties of $5,000 per violation, while affected users could sue for actual damages, attorneys' fees and court costs.

Who Would Be Impacted by This Bill?

According to a 2025 Rutgers University study, 74 percent of New Jersey residents reported having used AI tools, compared with 68 percent of the U.S. population. The legislation would cover chatbots such as Anthropic's Claude and OpenAI's ChatGPT. The study found that 57 percent of New Jersey residents had used ChatGPT at least once, while 59 percent favored strict AI regulation because of potential risks.

During her testimony before the Assembly Committee on Public Safety and Preparedness, EPIC counsel Kara Williams said the bill would "limit chatbot providers’ ability to continue exploiting users’ personal data by implementing specific privacy protections over the information users give chatbots."

She added: "Equally important, this bill also sets out a robust liability framework for chatbot providers."

In its written testimony, EPIC said one-third of adults had used chatbots and warned of what it described as "devastating harms," including suicide, self-harm, violence against others, sexual exploitation and predation, financial scams, reputational injuries and mental health harms such as anxiety, depression, unhealthy emotional attachment and AI psychosis.

"Because chatbots are almost entirely unregulated, these harms will only grow," EPIC wrote. "The Legislature should act now to force tech companies to act more responsibly and design chatbots that are safer for everyone."

What are the Next Steps for this Bill?

New Jersey Assembly Bill A5607 was referred to the Assembly Appropriations Committee after advancing from the Public Safety and Preparedness Committee on October 19 by a 5–1–1 vote.

The committee will decide whether to advance the bill, as written or with amendments, before it can be considered by the full Assembly. If approved by the Assembly, it would proceed to the Senate. If passed by both chambers, it would be sent to Governor Mikie Sherrill for her signature or veto.

If enacted, Barnes said the bill would set an important precedent for AI regulation.

"If one state treats chatbots as products, others will follow, and companies will build to the strictest standard rather than run fifty versions," he said. "That's how product safety has always spread."

He cautioned, however, that the rules should target how chatbots are deployed and supervised, rather than freeze today's technology, "because the capability moves every quarter."

Newsweek reached out to New Jersey Assembly members for comment.

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Rhian Morgan.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines