10

Loading video...

Rear Adm. James McPherson

By Rear Adm. James McPherson

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Florida’s Army National Guard is stretched so thin by competing demands that its readiness for the next emergency may be compromised, according to the force’s commander, Maj. Gen. Robert Carruthers. That’s the reality Governor-elect Byron Donalds will inherit in January when he takes responsibility for the Florida Guard and a state still recovering from Hurricane Isaias.

Donalds is far from alone. Twenty-one states will have new governors next year. Twelve of them—Alabama, Alaska, Florida, Georgia, Iowa, Nevada, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas and Wyoming—have Guard troops supporting the ongoing law enforcement operation in Washington, D.C. Each of those governors should commit to ending that mission as one of their first official acts.

Deploying the Guard to D.C. has always been ill-conceived.

Read More on Opinion

Whatever you make of the administration’s claims about crime in D.C., the Guard is not designed for routine domestic law enforcement. I started my career as a military policeman, and I’ve spent decades working between the military and law enforcement. Both professions are crucial to our nation’s security. Both deserve our utmost respect. But they are not interchangeable. The training required to confront enemy combatants or respond to natural disasters differs fundamentally from the training to police our streets, enforce the law and de-escalate potentially dangerous encounters with civilians.

Members of the National Guard cross as a street as they patrol near the National Mall on September 8, 2025, in Washington, D.C.

...

The longer the mission drags on, the more it hurts Guardsmen, the communities they serve and the Guard itself.

Initially pitched as a temporary response to a public safety emergency, Guard troops have now been in D.C. for some 15 months. The administration itself has touted dramatic reductions in the crime rate that ostensibly prompted the emergency.

During visits to Washington over the past year, I’ve spoken with soldiers deployed from as far away as Alabama and Hawaii. When I asked about their current mission none were certain, though some spoke of “providing additional security” to D.C. Most interestingly, none of them knew when their deployment would end so they could return to their families.

America’s armed services have a longstanding tradition of staying above the partisan political fray. We take an oath to defend the constitution and serve our country, not an individual president or political party. That impartiality is what gives our military moral authority to match its physical might. The longer the D.C. mission drags on without a clear timeline or objectives, the more it appears to be politically motivated.

The indefinite deployment takes a toll not just on the troops but on the Guard itself. With units also deployed overseas, other current and former National Guard leaders have echoed Carruthers’ concerns that troops and equipment are spread thin. Maj. Gen. Jack James, commander of the 42nd Infantry Division, says the Guard needs a “traffic cop” to help manage competing demands for troops and resources. And retired Maj. Gen. Randy Manner, a former senior National Guard Bureau official, has warned that the D.C. deployment is diverting money and personnel from training and other critical readiness needs.

To be clear: none of this is a reflection on the men and women called to serve in Washington, D.C. They have carried out their mission admirably, often with great personal sacrifice. The problem is, that mission made little sense at the time, and even less now.

The number of Guard troops in D.C. has declined from its summer peak. But embattled Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth recently expanded the remaining troops’ mandate, authorizing them to use military vehicles and boats and allowing more troops to carry rifles.

Governors—especially those newly elected—should tack in the opposite direction.

Georgia has the most troops deployed to D.C. of any state. During her campaign, Governor-elect Keisha Lance Bottoms pledged to “make sure our National Guard members are focused on protecting and serving the people of Georgia and supporting Americans during genuine emergencies.” She can follow through on that promise and set an example for other governors by moving swiftly toward an orderly withdrawal.

Like the military itself, this decision can, and should, sit apart from partisan politics or ideology. Those who questioned the deployment from the start can act on their opposition. Those who agreed with the president and believed in the mission can simply acknowledge that circumstances and priorities change over time—especially with the administration admitting that the emergency has passed.

Governors cannot predict when disaster might strike. But they can ensure that their National Guard is ready when it does. And they owe it to the men and women who serve to not keep them away from their loved ones and community without good reason.

One of the soldiers I met in D.C. last month told me, “I guess I will be spending Thanksgiving and Christmas here instead of with my family.” This should be the last holiday season that our troops sacrifice time with their families for this misadventure.

Retired Rear Adm. James McPherson served as the 39th Judge Advocate General of the Navy and, during President Donald Trump’s first term, as General Counsel and Acting Under Secretary of the Army and Acting Secretary of the Navy.

The views and opinions expressed are the writer's own and do not necessarily represent the views of the Department of Defense, its components or any state government entity.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines