10
Loading video...

By John Davenport
Professor of Philosophy, Fordham University
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
For 21 months, Israeli armed forces have been bombing Gaza into a landscape of rubble and buried corpses—a massively disproportionate retaliation for the Hamas attacks in southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, that killed over 1,200 Israelis. The Israeli Defense Force (IDF) tactics, chosen mostly to minimize casualties among their ground troops, have by now killed over 50,000 Palestinians in Gaza.
For comparison, the Gaza death toll is at least 25 times the number of Syrians killed in NATO's bombardment of Raqqa in our war with ISIS, and approaching three times the casualties in the fire-bombing of Dresden during World War II, which many scholars now consider to be war crimes.

...
Read More on Opinion
This was being done in Gaza, Israel told the world, only in order destroy Hamas—but it left unsaid that the method would be total war, namely leveling buildings holding scores of people in order to get a single Hamas fighter. Gaza would be razed, much like Dresden or Hiroshima, in order to eliminate the danger of terror attacks on Israel coming from Gaza.
Yet this endless orgy of revenge by indiscriminate fire, starvation, and destruction of almost all Gazan property seems sure to produce far more young Palestinians who see no hope or worthwhile purpose for their lives other than to die trying to kill Israelis—or perhaps Americans. The level of collective trauma is unimaginable.
Now, however, the true aim behind Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's effort to destroy all of Gaza is coming to light through his discussions with President Donald Trump this week. Netanyahu revealed some of his "vision" for postwar Gaza, and it is far worse than it seemed during the January ceasefire. The prime minister implied that he wants as many Gazans as possible to move out to other countries so that Israel can populate most of the Strip when rebuilt—a forcible expulsion that could exceed the 750,000–1 million Palestinians forced off their lands in the 1948-1949 Nakba. Trump suggested that he was looking for nations to take in Gazans by the hundreds of thousands.
Elements of this horrendous idea resemble what Trump said in February. Perhaps he and Netanyahu will even try to hire mercenary regimes like the warlords of South Sudan and move Palestinians forcibly into their hands?
Likewise, Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz said Monday that the IDF is planning to turn the area in and around the city of Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip into a "humanitarian" zone within which remaining Gazans would be concentrated and then kept there by a giant militarized fence or wall. Gaza was already an open-air prison and unbelievably, now Israel's proposal is to force Gazans who do not flee Palestine for other shores into a much smaller prison, while they turn the rest of Gaza into Israeli settlements.
It goes without saying that these proposals are the textbook definition of an enormous crime against humanity called ethnic cleansing, as the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum website documents. They would repeat what European governments did to Jewish populations through pogroms, attacking and killing them en mass, burning their villages, forcing them off fertile lands and into ships bound for America, or into dense "Jewish quarters" of inner cities where they could be kept sequestered—a series of crimes that culminated with the Nazis building concentration camps.
It is surely staggering, then, to hear the leaders of the world's only Jewish state speak of forcing an oppressed population that they have demonized into a giant new concentration camp. If Israelis wanted to move Gazans on such a scale out of the war zone solely for temporary purposes while "clearing" out Hamas forces, they could have done this in fall 2023 before killing over 50,000 civilians. They could have set up huge camps in the Negev and helped all women, children under 16, and anyone over 70 move into them, with other men screened—all before the complete blitzkrieg of Gaza began.
But it was never Netanyahu's purpose to spare any Gazan lives. His proposal is shocking but it is really just a larger version of what Likud governments have been doing to Palestinians for years in the West Bank—bulldozing their homes, forcing them off their lands into a few dense city centers, surrounding these with militarized barriers, and opening the rest to Israeli settlers. Since the 1970s, Israel's right-wing government policy has always been collective punishment by destroying buildings and forcing residents to move.
Now this horror is being carried out in Gaza with the blessing and support of the U.S. government, making all Americans complicit in enormous new crimes of the kind we associate with the world's worst tyrants. Within the U.S., the forced march toward this catastrophic conclusion is supported by a sustained propaganda campaign to portray the massacre of Gazans as mere Israeli "self-defense," and to attack and threaten anyone who dares to disagree in public by threatening their deportation or condemning them as antisemites.
Over a year ago, I argued that the only morally acceptable solution is for a large international force to take control of Gaza. Hamas should always have been displaced by installing a new non-Israeli transitional government, led by all credible partners in the region and financed by a large consortium of nations seeking a two-state solution, that could force Hamas to the side and resist its attacks by hunting down its ringleaders. The transitional government must then rebuild Gaza with money primarily raised by tariffs on all Israeli goods and services across the globe.
The transitional authority's goal would be to create a peaceful Palestinian state in a revived Gaza, with a border policed by the international group for a long time. In the long run, this is the only morally viable alternative to the ethnic cleaning that Israel has now proposed.
John Davenport is professor of philosophy and director of peace and justice studies at Fordham University.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines