
...

By Ellie Cook
Senior Defense Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
After 19 Russian drones crossed into NATO member Poland early Wednesday, there are uncomfortable, pressing questions for the alliance about how well it could intercept a much larger Russian drone or missile attack.
It is, ultimately, unprepared, analysts say. No one but Israel has built up the capability to defend against a large-scale, sustained aerial attack, said Sam Cranny-Evans, an associate fellow at the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI), a major British defense think tank.
Observers say the problem isn't the quality of the systems, it's the quantity. Stockpiles have been funneled to Ukraine for years, and existing factories are hard pressed to more quickly churn out new equipment like interceptor missiles. On top of that are long waits between ordering kit and receiving it and discomfort in Europe over how reliant it is on the U.S.
Read More on World
"Europe has individually capable defensive systems, but nowhere near enough volume to defend itself in the event of a major and protracted war," Matthew Savill, the director of military sciences at RUSI, told Newsweek.

...
European countries have broadly pledged to increase military spending, although nations forming NATO's eastern flank, close to Russia, have more keenly felt Moscow's presence and traditionally spent a higher percentage of their GDP on defense. By 2030, there may have been enough of a "meaningful increase" to mean Europe can properly defend itself, Cranny-Evans told Newsweek.
"It will take time," Savill said, as well as investment in cheaper systems to deal with drones and other types of threats, like loitering munitions.
What Is a Drone Wall?
The type of air defenses NATO would use to intercept a large-scale drone attack is different from how the alliance would take out incoming ballistic or cruise missiles.
But the number of Russian drones that crossed into Poland, and how far they reached, adds a new urgency to the mammoth task of working out how NATO would take out many drones at once without turning to expensive air defense missiles, which can cost millions of dollars apiece. Cheap drones, like Russia has used in Ukraine, come at a fraction of the price.
Andrius Kubilius, the European commissioner for defense and space, said on Wednesday, shortly after the Russian drones crossed into Poland, that "we must urgently develop" a "drone wall" across the "entire EU Eastern flank."
The idea of a drone wall is essentially about layered defenses, from interceptor drones to cannons and missiles, plus electronic warfare and attempts to jam or spoof incoming drones.
Each layer of defenses would have a go at taking out an incoming threat, said U.K.-based drone expert Steve Wright.
"We need to step up the defense," Wright told Newsweek. But "there isn't a silver bullet," he added.
Many companies now are looking for new ways to make sure drones don't hit their targets. DroneShield, a mostly Australian-owned counter-UAS (unmanned aerial systems) company, say "the problem is getting more complex."
"You really need to look at it as multiple layers that you need to defend against," Matt McCrann, the company's U.S. CEO, told Newsweek. DroneShield says it has "close to 50" national militaries as customers and said in June it signed a $40 million deal to provide its technology to an unnamed European military.
An increasingly dominant tactic is using interceptor drones to smash other drones from the sky before they can reach their destination. Johannes Pinl, who heads defense company MARSS, said their hit-to-kill interceptor drone is "like a knife, cutting through the incoming targets" without using explosives or fuel for tens of thousands of dollars.
The MARSS interceptor drone would be one of the first defenses to engage drones, like the Shahed or Gerbera drones Russia frequently deploys, from roughly 5 kilometers away, Pinl told Newsweek. Pinl said the interceptor drone would be best suited to shielding cities and critical infrastructure from drone attacks.
"The issue with Europe and NATO [is] they're five years behind," Pinl said. "This technology, this drone wall, is deployed in the Middle East. They put budgets aside for this drone wall, and they've silently built up this drone wall.
"They are prepared. But Europe has done "nothing."
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines