10
Loading video...
By Anna Commander
News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Despite a string of unfavorable national polls, election forecaster Nate Silver says Republicans may still have a path to maintaining control of the House of Representatives in the 2026 midterm elections—though he describes it as a "fairly low-probability outcome" at this stage.
Silver's assessment comes as Democrats continue to hold an advantage on the generic congressional ballot, with several recent surveys showing the party leading Republicans by mid-to-high single digits nationally.
How Republicans could maintain House control in the midterms, Silver says, largely comes down to landing two of these big things: "substantial economic recovery," converting the argument to voters that Democrats are "too far left," and a "systemic 2016-style polling error," Silver added.
Read More on News
Newsweek reached out to Republican House Speaker Mike Johnson's office via email on Monday for comment.
While speaking with Silver, Eli McKown-Dawson, Silver Bulletin Senior Elections Analyst, said in part on Substack when asked about the possibility of Republicans maintaining control of the House, "I think there would have to be a lot of things that go either right for Republicans or wrong for Democrats for that to happen. Right now, if the polls are at all accurate, the national environment is just too blue for Democrats to lose the House realistically, because there just aren’t that many competitive districts."
McKown-Dawson added, "You’d really have to see a big change in what the national environment looks like — maybe people get really unhappy with Democrats for some reason. Because really, if we’re in not a D +6 or 7 environment but a D +3 environment, Democrats can lose the House, because [the map] sort of favors Republicans."
When asked about Silver's "low-probability" prediction, Robert Y. Shapiro, Professor of Political Science and in the School of International and Public Affairs at Columbia University, told Newsweek on Monday in part that, "Nate Silver has this about right, but you have to also figure in the state of the war against Iran. It is looking like the 2006 election where it was clear the Democrats had a good shot in taking the House, though I do not think that 2026 will be such a landslide, but it will produce enough of a majority. That majority would thwart anything but genuinely bipartisan legislation -- Trump will be stopped in his tracks."
He noted that control of the House could lead to Democrats launching impeachment proceedings against President Donald Trump or investigations into his Cabinet members.
"The further debacle for Trump and the Republicans would be if the Democrats gain a majority in the Senate," Shapiro later added. "This would enable them to reject judicial and other appointments, especially the replacements of any older conservative judges who might have wanted to leave the Supreme Court to be replaced by younger judges who would be able to serve longer on the Court."
Democrats Hold Edge Over Republicans, Polling Shows
Silver's comments follow new polling that underscored Democrats' current momentum. A survey from YouGov/The Economist released last week shows that in a general congressional vote, 40 percent would pick the democratic candidate, and 34 percent would pick the Republican candidate. The survey shows that 10 percent were not sure and 15 percent would not vote.
The poll surveyed 1,559 U.S. adults from July 25 to July 27, 2026, and had a margin of error of 3.3 percent.
A new Reuters/Ipsos poll released on Monday also shows Democrats out ahead of Republicans in a congressional ballot test, picking a Democrat 42 percent compared to a Republican with 37 percent. "Independents in the poll picked Democrats over Republicans by 12 percentage points," the poll said in part.
The poll surveyed 4,505 U.S. adults from July 29 to August 3, and has a margin of error of 2 percent.
For Republicans, the road to holding the House likely depends on improving Trump's approval ratings, energizing their base, and benefiting from favorable turnout patterns in competitive districts. Economic conditions, inflation, and voter perceptions of the administration could also reshape the political landscape in the coming months.
Seemingly addressing unfavorable polling, Trump said on Truth Social on Monday: "My REAL Polling Numbers, not those made up by the Fake News Media, are the best they have ever been, and why wouldn’t they be with the biggest tax cuts and employment numbers EVER, the biggest outside Investment in America in World history, a totally secure Border, a giant Victory in Venezuela, the Denuclearization of Iran, unparalleled respect and success throughout the World, and much more?"
"Don’t believe the Radical Left’s Fake Poll numbers," he added. "They are Crooked and Corrupt, just like the Country Destroying Dumocrats are Crooked and Corrupt. VOTE REPUBLICAN FOR GREATNESS IN AMERICA! Thank you for your attention to this matter! President DJT".
Meanwhile, midterm elections are commonly seen as a measure of public approval for the current president, and the president's party has traditionally lost seats during these elections. At present, Republicans maintain a narrow House majority, controlling 218 seats, while Democrats hold 212.
...
What's Next?
With fewer than 100 days until Election Day, Republicans will be looking for signs that economic conditions are improving and that concerns about Democratic policy positions can resonate in key swing districts. Democrats, meanwhile, will aim to preserve their advantage on the generic congressional ballot and translate favorable polling into victories in a relatively small number of competitive House races.
The coming weeks will provide a clearer picture of whether Silver's low-probability path for Republicans is materializing. Analysts will be closely watching economic data, district-level polling, fundraising reports, and the results of special elections for clues about which party has the momentum heading into November.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Gray R. Thomas
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines