...
By Amanda Greenwood
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The disappearance of Arizona woman Nancy Guthrie has entered its third month, with investigators still lacking a “direct suspect,” according to a source with knowledge of the case who spoke exclusively to NewsNation.
In an interview conducted by NewsNation senior national correspondent Brian Anton, an individual familiar with the investigation said law enforcement has yet to place any name “on the table” as a person of interest, raising renewed questions about how the case was handled in its earliest hours.
The source, whose identity was concealed due to fear of professional retaliation, said the investigation suffered from critical missteps almost immediately after Guthrie was reported missing.
Read More on News
According to the interview, responders quickly concluded that Guthrie had wandered away from her home, framing the situation as a search-and-rescue effort rather than treating it as a potential criminal case.
“That rush to judgment stayed with the investigation,” the source said, noting that detectives proceeded under the assumption that Guthrie had simply wandered off. “They ran it as a search and rescue issue, opposed to a possible criminal issue.”
...
Questions Over Experience and Evidence Handling
The source also raised concerns about the level of experience of those initially assigned to the case. According to the interview, first responders included detectives who were not seasoned homicide investigators. The supervisor who initially responded to Guthrie’s home had never investigated a homicide before assuming oversight of the unit, the source claimed.
“That’s how you end up with decisions being made by people based on loyalty rather than merit,” the source said when questioned about the department’s leadership structure.
Concerns were also raised about how evidence was collected and preserved. The source pointed out that detectives returned to Guthrie’s home multiple times after the initial response, something that, in their view, indicates the scene should have been secured differently from the outset.
“The fact that they had to go back not once, but several times, tells me they should have handled it differently,” the source said.
No Name on the Table
Despite months of investigation, the source told NewsNation the case currently has no clear suspect.
“The people I’ve talked to that are still in the know tell me there’s no direct suspect right now,” the source said, adding that there is “no name on the table.”
Asked whether that was surprising, the source said the absence of a suspect aligned with how the case has unfolded. They suggested the circumstances point to either extraordinary luck or a suspect who may have been “extremely cunning” and capable of avoiding detection.
Internal Frustration and Low Morale
The interview also highlighted low morale within the sheriff’s office. The source described widespread embarrassment and frustration among deputies, particularly surrounding public comments made by Sheriff Chris Nanos during early press conferences.
According to the source, every deputy in the union voted in favor of a no-confidence motion against Nanos, a development that has further strained the department. “I think everyone is walking on eggshells,” they said.
The source emphasized that deputies still care deeply about Guthrie and her family, particularly her daughter, NBC's Today show co-anchor, Savannah Guthrie, stressing that dissatisfaction with leadership does not reflect a lack of concern for the case.
“Just because we have an incompetent leader, it doesn't mean that we don't care, that we don't want Nancy to be brought home safely,” the source said. “We are completely with her and her family.”
Sheriff Responds
Anton reported that NewsNation reached out to Nanos for comment regarding the allegations raised during the interview, but did not receive a response.
As the investigation moves into its third month, questions remain about whether early decisions hampered progress—and whether answers will ultimately emerge in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines