
...

By Khaleda Rahman
National Correspondent
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos defended his work history and conduct in a report sent to the Pima County Board of Supervisors on Tuesday.
It comes as the sheriff has faced questions about misrepresenting his work history and his handling of the investigation into the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, which is now in its third month.
Nanos sent in a 22-page report answering the board’s questions during the board’s meeting on Tuesday, and the board later voted to delay discussion until its next meeting so supervisors have time to review it.
Read More on News
Newsweek has contacted Nanos for comment via an email to his attorney sent outside regular business hours. The board of supervisors has been contacted for comment via email.

...
The Context
Nanos has come under pressure and faced calls to resign since The Arizona Republic reported that he misrepresented his work history on a public resume and in a sworn deposition. The Republic’s report in March said Nanos had resigned in lieu of termination in 1982 after a string of disciplinary issues, two years earlier than he indicated on his publicly posted resume.
A spokesperson for the sheriff’s department told Newsweek at the time that the discrepancies “were administrative in nature” and “not intended to mislead or misrepresent Sheriff Nanos’ work history.”
Nanos has also faced criticism over the investigation into the disappearance of Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of Today co-host Savannah Guthrie. She was last seen at her home outside Tucson, Arizona, on January 31 and reported missing on February 1.
Authorities believe she was kidnapped, and in February, the FBI released surveillance footage from a doorbell camera, showing a masked man, whom they called a suspect, outside her front door on the night she disappeared. But since then, investigators have not identified a suspect or provided details about any significant breakthroughs in the case.
What To Know
The board had required Nanos to provide sworn testimony in person or in writing to a set of questions on four topics by Tuesday: his prior representations about his employment history with the El Paso Police Department, disciplinary actions, his department’s cooperation with federal immigration authorities and instances of his department exceeding its budget.
The board worked with an attorney to draft questions under a state law that would compel the sheriff to provide answers, with non-compliance providing a path for Nanos to be removed from his position.
Nanos provided his responses in a report written by his attorney, James Cool.
In the document, Cool wrote that Nanos did not need to answer an “unlimited inquisition” by the board but had decided to answer the questions “in the interest of transparency and in the spirit of cooperation."
He wrote that Nanos’ employment history “is irrelevant to the performance of his duties as an elected official subject to oversight” by the board, and that giving testimony in a civil lawsuit and managing the department’s website are not among the duties of his office.
Cool also said that Nanos’ "minimal disciplinary history” is irrelevant to the performance of his duties.
The attorney wrote that Nanos was the subject of various disciplinary actions while employed with the El Paso Police Department, including counselling, reprimands and suspicions.
"That discipline, and the actions that gave rise to it, happened more than four decades ago. The Sheriff has little specific recollection of those events," he wrote.
Cool added that Nanos has never been suspended during his four decades at the Pima County Sherif’s Department and that his prior testimony about not being suspended came as he was questioned about the Arizona Peace Officer’s Bill of Rights.
“Bad faith media reports have divorced this testimony from its context to suggest Sheriff Nanos was untruthful about his disciplinary history with the El Paso Police Department. But context matters,” Cool wrote. “Both immediately before and immediately after the question about whether he had ever been suspended, Sheriff Nanos was questioned about the Arizona Peace Officer's Bill of Rights.”
Cool added that Nanos had reviewed the transcript shortly after the deposition, spotted his misunderstanding and notified his attorney.
Nanos resignation from the El Paso Police Department came in the wake of a dispute with a supervisor "over the towing of vehicles," Cool wrote.
His supervisor wanted to impose a three-day suspension for insubordination, but Nanos appealed the recommended discipline to the police chief, who found in favor of the supervisor, Cool wrote. "Rather than accept a three-day suspension, Sheriff Nanos offered to resign in lieu of discipline. The Chief accepted his offer and Sheriff Nanos resigned,” Cool wrote.
In response to questions about disciplinary actions taken against Heather Lappin, his former political opponent, and Sgt. Aaron Cross, Cool wrote that the process was “rooted in long-settled county policy and well-document department policy and procedures.”
He wrote that the decision to put Lappin on administrative leave was the "unfortunate" result of a change to a policy that had allowed county employees run for county office without leaving their jobs.
Cool wrote that since lawsuits filed by Cross and Lappin against the sheriff are ongoing, Nanos “must be mindful of the impact his public statements in response to this inquiry could have on the litigation.”
In the report, Nanos also denied working with federal immigration authorities.
Cool wrote that the sheriff has implemented policies to limit cooperation with U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE), including not allowing ICE to assign agents to the Pima County Adult Detention Center.
And regarding management of the department’s budget, Cool wrote that the department has operated under budget in three of the last five fiscal years. In the years that the department exceeded its budget, the overruns were “minimal,” Cool wrote.
New Details About Nanos’ Disciplinary History
The Arizona Republic reported that as a police officer in El Paso, Nanos was suspended eight times for incidents including excessive force, making a false statement and off-duty gambling. The outlet reported on details of the incidents on Tuesday after obtaining records including suspension notices and incident reports through a public records request.
In one case, Nanos was suspended for beating a handcuffed suspect until he man suffered blood loss and had to be admitted to hospital.
In another case, supervisors said Nanos had threatened to “waste” a witness who participated in a disciplinary complaint against him, then lied about stopping the man in the street.
He was also disciplined for using a profanity-laden insult against women, for gambling on a pool game and for turning up late for shifts.
What Happens Next
The board unanimously voted to discuss Nanos’ report at their next meeting on May 12.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines