10
Loading video...

By Dan Gooding
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A Democratic congressman on Wednesday compared the training U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents receive to the barbers in his state, saying those cutting hair had longer training requirements.
Michigan Representative Shri Thanedar asked Secretary of Homeland Security Markwayne Mullin about the protocols in place, after a series of violent and, in some cases, fatal incidents involving federal agents under the Trump administration, some of whom had been through a speedy hiring process under the previous secretary, Kristi Noem.
"I proudly represent Detroit, and we have some of the finest barbers in the U.S.," Thanedar said during a House Homeland Security Committee hearing. "Our barbers go through more training than your ICE officers. Do you know that?"
Read More on Politics
Mullin replied, saying he had never been a barber, "but I know the service industry and apprentice license for, electricians, plumbers and heating engineers—roughly 3 to 4 years. I can talk about that."
Several states require aspiring barbers to complete 1,000 or more hours of training before obtaining a license, while ICE has historically put new deportation officers through a roughly 20-week basic academy, which was dramatically shortened under Noem. For reference, a 20-week academy with attendees present for eight hours a day, five days a week would provide 800 hours of instruction.
"Shri Thanedar's remark is theatrical and crafted to make a political point with the hopes to trigger a reaction from Markwayne Mullin. It fell flat," Michael Alcazar, a professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, told Newsweek. "The comparison oversimplifies the two jobs."
When reached for comment, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) told Newsweek that the Trump administration was "preserving ICE’s reputation as one of the most elite law enforcement agencies not only in the U.S., but the entire world."
Mullin Defends ICE Training
The Secretary of Homeland Security was asked multiple times about ICE agent training and background checks Wednesday, including by Rhode Island Democrat Seth Magaziner, who wanted to know how many ICE agents on the streets had not completed full background checks.
"Every ICE agent we have in service right now have had full background checks," Mullin said. "Some of them are on administrative leave until they get their [full background checks]."
Magaziner said he asked because the agent who shot and killed Colombian national Johan Guerrero in Biddeford, Maine, in July had been put to work before his full background check had been completed. Reports in the days after the fatal shooting suggested agent David Brouillette had severe mental health issues and had been violent toward two ex-wives.
Mullin said he had addressed training and background check concerns following Noem's departure, restoring the 13-week training period. Some, Magaziner said, had only completed eight weeks of online training.
"Unfortunately, Congressman, there were some decisions that were made before I was secretary that we were having to undo," Mullin said, adding, "We have a lot of work to do."

...
Do Barbers Really Train Longer Than ICE Agents?
Depending on the U.S. state, barbers do appear to spend more time on pre-license training hours than ICE agents do in dedicated training before being sent out into the field, according to state licensing requirements reviewed by Newsweek.
Ohio requires one of the highest numbers of hours of training for new barbers, at 1,800 hours, working out at around 45 weeks compared to the 13 weeks for ICE. In Illinois, the state requires 1,500 hours, while Pennsylvania requires 1,250.
Not all state license requirements are the same. In Texas, where 1,000 hours of training are required, the state also requires barbers to pass written and practical exams.
Mullin, who trained as a plumber before serving as a congressman and Senator for Oklahoma, would have had to have undergone at least 8,000 hours of on-the-job learning, with some apprenticeships running for around four or five years in some areas, along with classroom-based teaching.
For cosmetologists, between 1,000 and 2,000 hours of training is needed, depending on the state. That contrasts with private security guards, who often only need eight to 40 hours of mandated training, while some states have no statewide minimum.
As for regular law enforcement officers, the amount of training also differs across the country. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics in 2022, the average basic state and local police academy training lasted 806 hours, or around 20.15 weeks. Just under 90 percent of academies required on-the-job training for at least some recruits after graduation.
"Federal agent training compared to other law enforcement training is quite different," Alcazar said. "Federal officer training is narrower, more focused on immigration laws, arrest and deportation procedures. Their mark is noncitizens suspected of entering the US illegally.
"Local police training focus on public safety. They are first responders tasked with investigating crimes and protecting civilians from criminals. Police are general practitioners, and ICE agents are specialists," he said. "The disconnect happens when ICE agents are confronted by protesters. They have no specific training on de-escalation and crowd control. When elected officials limit cooperation between local police and ICE, it's a political statement, but at what cost?"
ICE Training Was Shortened During Hiring Surge
An archived ICE webpage from 2017 showed its ERO deportation officers received 20 weeks of basic training, which covered immigration law, Spanish, firearms, physical fitness, law-enforcement tactics, multicultural communication, and avoidance of racial profiling.
Under Noem, who became secretary following President Donald Trump's return to the White House in January 2025, training was dramatically compressed during a hiring surge.
DHS said in February that new recruits were receiving 56 days of training, plus an average of 28 days of on-the-job training, arguing the change didn't cut any actual training hours because recruits were now training six days per week for 12 hours rather than five eight-hour days. DHS also said no subject matter had been eliminated.
When Mullin took over, he said the agency was returning to 13 weeks of training.

...
"ICE maintains rigorous standards for all personnel," a DHS spokesperson told Newsweek Wednesday. "All graduates of the previous academy curriculum attend follow-on training at the Advanced Field Officer Training Program. ICE is also instituting additional training including, crowd control measures, additional training for high-risk vehicle stops, a live-fire cover course for officer safety, and medical training."
DHS said that ICE training does not end when recruits leave the academy, with rigorous on-the-job training and mentorship which is tracked online.
"New hires take what they learn at FLETC and apply it to real-life scenarios while on duty, preserving ICE’s reputation as one of the most elite law enforcement agencies not only in the U.S., but the entire world," the spokesperson said.
Michael D. Lyman, a former senior-level law enforcement officer and trainer, told Newsweek that DHS could address public concerns about ICE agents, "through improved training, clear policies addressing field operations, effective supervision, and accountability.
"The issue is not whether ICE officers have the authority to enforce federal immigration laws. They do," he said. "The issue is whether they exercise that authority in a manner consistent with constitutional requirements, established law enforcement 'best practices' and appropriate use-of-force standards."
Why ICE Training Remains a Flashpoint
The Trump administration's expansion of ICE and its focus on mass deportations created additional pressure to hire and train officers quickly, and while some officers have been pulled from duty, the concerns have not disappeared.
Criticism of the shortened training program became serious enough that former ICE instructor Ryan Schwank filed a whistleblower complaint describing the training process as "deficient, defective, and broken" in a complaint to Congress.
While DHS has defended its federal agents, the repeated clashes with protesters and immigrants have led to repeated questions from lawmakers—most of them Democrats—as to how effective vetting is. Mullin's testimony Wednesday suggested the administration is moving away from at least one major element of the accelerated hiring strategy.
"The people who benefit the most from improved ICE officer training are the officers themselves," Schwank said in a statement to Newsweek Wednesday. "I sincerely hope that the Department of Homeland Security has actually restored the training that was cut, because what they have said is only that they have restored the hours.
"I would call on Homeland Security to publish the training the officers are getting—at the minimum, a syllabus or schedule of classes and what recruits are taught as a general matter."
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Gray R. Thomas
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines